Revision of a CCF decision: when a new fact changes the outcome
Decisions of the Commission for the Control of INTERPOL's Files (CCF) are final and binding. There is no appeal — only an application for revision, and only on the basis of a newly discovered fact. What the Commission accepts as such a fact, how the two-gate filter on the portal works, and why an admitted revision does not yet mean deletion.
The three conditions in Article 42
Article 38(1) of the Statute makes Requests Chamber decisions final and binding on the Organization and the applicant; Article 42 is the only route by which a party can reopen them.1
"(1) Applications for the revision of decisions of the Requests Chamber may be made only when they are based on the discovery of facts1 which could have led the Requests Chamber to a different conclusion2 if that fact had been known at the time at which the request was being processed. (2) Applications for revision must be made within six months after the discovery of the fact3. (3) The timeframe for a decision on a request for revision shall be that provided for in Article 40."
Decision 2017, No. 10"new" letters on context
A fact, not a fresh argument
A new reading of old documents or a better-crafted argument is not a fact. The Commission has refused applications where "new" letters merely described a context it already knew.10
Rule 30(7)Operating Rules
Capable of changing the result
The fact must go to the ground on which the decision rested. Rule 30(7) requires an explanation of why it could have changed the conclusion.2
Art. 42(2)CCF Statute
Rule 31(4); Art. 28(3)abuse
The Commission will not process a repeat request without a new fact: its FAQ states that a request essentially the same as one already examined, with no new facts justifying revision, will not be processed.6 Repetitive requests can be treated as abusive.21
Portal procedure: two gates rather than one letter
Since the portal went live, revision is split into stages. At first you may attach a single document — a summary of no more than two pages succinctly describing the newly discovered fact. The statement of arguments of up to ten pages comes later, and only if the Commission asks for it after its initial review.3
Gate 1 — admissibility
Summary of no more than 2 pages: which fact, when discovered, why it could change the outcome.
CCF request
After its initial review the Commission may ask for arguments of up to 10 pages and documents.
Gate 2 — merits
The data are reassessed in the light of the new fact and the earlier file.
That is how the decisions are structured: the Commission first establishes whether the conditions for revision are met, and only then studies compliance "anew" — on the basis of both the new fact and the information the parties supplied the first time.8 Either the applicant or the data source — the National Central Bureau (NCB) — may apply.4
What the Commission has accepted as a new fact — and what it has not
All examples come from officially published, anonymised excerpts; links go to the PDFs on INTERPOL's website. The 2017 decisions applied the former "re-examination" rules.
| What the applicant produced | New fact? | Outcome | Decision |
|---|---|---|---|
| New judgments from the state of nationality, dismissing most counts, handed down after the CCF decision | accepted | Admitted; ne bis in idem not applied — data retained | 2023, No. 9 |
| A letter from the "victim" company confirming the applicant owed nothing | accepted | Admitted; doubts on seriousness not enough — data retained | 2019, No. 8 |
| Another state's prosecutor refusing mutual legal assistance over rights risks and incoherent charges | accepted | Admitted; data deleted | 2019, No. 6 |
| New material the NCB failed to answer (former rules) | accepted | Admitted; blocking of access recommended if the NCB stayed silent | 2017, No. 7 |
| Previously unsubmitted letters describing the general context | rejected | Not a fact about the applicant — refused | 2017, No. 10 |
| Deletion of another person's data in a related case | rejected | That decision turned on its own facts — not transferable | 2017, No. 10 |
| Repeated arguments plus an alleged extradition refusal that proved untrue | rejected | Refused | 2017, No. 6 |
| Inaccuracies in a Green Notice raised by the applicant | accepted | The NCB corrected the data and reissued the notice; outcome unchanged | 2017, No. 11 |
Admission is not victory
Published decisions in which the conditions for revision were met have ended differently. A new fact opens the door, but the data are then judged by the same rules as before.
| Decision | Art. 42 conditions | Outcome | Why |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2023, No. 9 | met | Data retained | Ne bis in idem between states needs a treaty or a transfer of proceedings.9 |
| 2019, No. 8 | met | Data retained | A civil settlement abroad does not end a criminal case. |
| 2019, No. 6 | met | Data deleted | The new fact combined with earlier Article 2 doubts.8 |
| 2017, No. 7 | met | Blocking if the NCB stays silent | The Commission recorded doubts and gave the source a month. |
CCF reports2023 and 2024
The official figures give a sense of scale: in 2023 the Commission received 557 revision applications — up from 9% of requests in 2022 to 20% — with some countries sharply increasing their own applications. In 2024 revisions made up about 18% of new admissible requests, and 62 applications were closed.54 The Commission estimates that a revision application involves some thirty pieces of correspondence on average.5
Is an application worth filing? A self-check
The four statements mirror Article 42 and Rule 30(7). This is not a prediction of the outcome, only a filter to avoid filing something plainly inadmissible: if even one does not fit your case, the application will probably not pass the first gate.
- The fact arose or came to my knowledge after the Commission dealt with my request (not merely something I failed to submit).
- No more than six months have passed since I learned of it, and I can prove the date.
- The fact goes to the very ground on which the Commission kept the data (seriousness, involvement, Article 2, Article 3, etc.).
- The fact is backed by a document (a court ruling, an official letter), not just my own account.
If revision is not available: other lawful routes
Approaching the data source
The Statute expressly preserves requests to the source authorities to correct or delete data, and the General Secretariat's own power to block, correct or delete.1New developments in the case
An acquittal, discontinuance or limitation in the source country supports both a revision and a withdrawal by the NCB. The Commission has said it may act quickly where an applicant produces a court acquittal.5Asylum and extradition proceedings
The CCF does not decide extradition or immigration matters. Protection from surrender and removal comes from national courts — see extradition defence and political asylum.7Intimidation and reprisals
Where, after a decision upholding the data, you or people close to you face reprisals linked to the CCF request, the Commission suggests considering a revision application or reporting it on a dedicated form.6What we cannot promise
Revision is a narrow procedure.
- Outcome. We cannot promise that a fact will be accepted as new or that the decision will change: that is the Commission's call.
- Time. Missing the six-month window generally closes this route for that fact.
- Odds. The published excerpts are a selection, not the full body of practice; they say nothing about odds of success.
The fee is set after the free first consultation. See Fees.
A new fact has emerged?Send us the CCF decision and the new document: we will assess whether it meets Article 42 and how to stay within six months.
Free consultationThis page is general information, not legal advice.
Primary sources this page was checked against
- 1Statute of the Commission for the Control of INTERPOL's Files — Arts 28, 38, 40, 42interpol.int
- 2Operating Rules of the CCF (2026) — Rules 30(7), 30(8), 31(4)interpol.int
- 3CCF Portal User Guide for Applicants (2026) — section 10.3, Application for Revisioninterpol.int
- 4Annual activity report of the CCF for 2024 — para. 40 and statisticsinterpol.int
- 5Activity Report of the CCF for 2023 — share and number of revision applications, correspondence, quick action on acquittalsinterpol.int
- 6CCF — Frequently Asked Questions: repeat requests, appeals, reprisalsinterpol.int
- 7INTERPOL — How to submit a request (CCF): limits of the CCF's competence; revision requirementsinterpol.int
- 8CCF Decision Excerpt 2019, No. 6 (revision)interpol.int
- 9CCF Decision Excerpt 2023, No. 9 (revision)interpol.int
- 10CCF Decision Excerpt 2017, No. 10 (revision refused)interpol.int
Article 42 is quoted from the official English text.