Independent legal practice.

Detained? +34 613 889 381 — 24/7
INTERPOLSTOP — home Русский: RU Free consultation Detained?

Asylum case preparation

A person with entirely genuine grounds can be refused because the case was presented badly. A carefully documented and legally structured case gives the decision-maker what they need to say yes, at first instance and on appeal. Much of our work involves applicants from post-Soviet states.

This page is about proof, not groundsFor the legal grounds for asylum and how jurisdictions compare, see Political asylum. This page covers how the case itself is built: the written account, the evidence, expert reports and preparation for interviews and hearings.

The written account takes a different form in each system

Every asylum system relies on the applicant’s own account, and most give it a fixed written form with its own deadline. Knowing which document carries the case, and when the decision-maker reads it, is the starting point of preparation.

Reg. (EU) 2024/1348applicable from 12 June 2026

SystemCore written documentWhen it matters most
United StatesForm I-589 with a detailed personal declarationAsylum office interview or immigration court hearing; the application must generally be filed within one year of arrival
CanadaBasis of Claim (BOC) form, mandatoryFiled shortly after the claim is referred to the Immigration and Refugee Board; the hearing is examined against it
United KingdomWitness statementBefore the Home Office interview and, above all, on appeal to the First-tier Tribunal
SwitzerlandInterview record (SEM) and written submissionsThe hearing before the State Secretariat for Migration; appeals to the Federal Administrative Court have short deadlines
EU Member StatesPersonal interview record, supported by written statements and evidenceThe personal interview under the Asylum Procedure Regulation (EU) 2024/1348, applicable from 12 June 2026

From the first assessment to a finished case

The account is the applicant’s own; our role is structure and completeness, never invention.

  1. Initial assessment of the grounds

    A detailed interview with the applicant, usually several hours: the chronology, the reasons for leaving, the forms of persecution and any attempts to obtain protection in the country of origin. We analyse the documents and which of the five Convention grounds apply. The result is a written assessment with the legal characterisation of the case, a candid view of its strengths and weaknesses, the likely deciding jurisdiction, a preparation plan, timing and budget.

  2. Drafting the detailed account

    The witness statement, declaration or Basis of Claim narrative is the centre of the case; its form depends on the system (see the table above). The structure: a short biography and summary of the grounds; a detailed chronological account of the persecution (who, what, when, where, how); the reasons for leaving; a conclusion. The principles: detail, consistency, a personal voice and legal relevance.

  3. Gathering and organising evidence

    Evidence is organised chronologically and by theme, with certified translations and an indexed bundle; what to gather is listed below. Evidence from the country of origin can often still be obtained after departure, through relatives, local lawyers or online sources, with care for everyone’s safety.

  4. Country expert report

    An independent assessment of conditions in the country of origin by a recognised specialist: an academic, former diplomat, researcher or journalist. It places the account in context, addresses the risk for a person with the applicant’s profile, and assesses state protection and internal relocation. Experts owe their duty to the tribunal, not to the party instructing them, which is precisely what gives their reports weight. Preparation usually takes several weeks.

  5. Material from human rights organisations

    Amnesty International, Human Rights Watch or the Committee to Protect Journalists can independently corroborate the political nature of a prosecution, through published reports, inclusion in lists of persecuted journalists or activists, or, occasionally, an individual letter. These organisations decide independently and selectively; many requests are declined, and published reports are often the more realistic source.

The file: what to gather

Highlighted: where you can start now, while you still have access to the material and before details fade.

UNHCR Handbookparas. 196–205: benefit of the doubt

  • A detailed chronology of events, dates and incidents
  • Identity documents
  • Copies of every important document in the case
  • Evidence of persecution: records of detention, summonses, recorded threats
  • Medical reports on injuries and, where relevant, a psychological assessment
  • Evidence of activity: membership documents, publications, photographs from events
  • Attempts to obtain protection at home: police reports, court papers
  • Certified translations and an index of all material
  • A country expert report where direct evidence is thin
  • Human rights reports on the country and the applicant’s profile

Preparation differs with the ground of the claim

Political cases: visibility and the causal link

A dated chronology of activity and roles, proof of participation, evidence that the authorities knew, and a direct link between the activity and the persecution. The typical weakness is the grassroots activist with no public profile: the case must explain how the authorities found out (informants, surveillance, lists seized during other arrests).

LGBT+ cases: credibility of identity

A detailed personal account of the applicant’s experience of their identity, consistent evidence, and no stereotypes. Not having lived openly in a repressive country is understandable and does not disprove identity, and applicants cannot be expected to conceal their identity to avoid persecution (CJEU, X, Y and Z, 2013).7

Religious cases: depth, not formality

For conversion cases: the length of practice, regular participation in community life, rites undergone and knowledge of the teaching. Authorities are sceptical of conversions after arrival, so the case has to show a genuine change of belief rather than formal attendance.

Gender-based violence: violence and the state’s failure to protect

Documenting specific incidents with medical reports and a psychological assessment, documenting attempts to obtain protection, and an expert report on the position of women and how laws against violence are actually enforced.

Interviews, hearings and interpreters

Being caught out is worse than a gap in memory, and translation errors create apparent contradictions. That is why the oral stage is prepared as carefully as the file.

Common mistake

  • Inventing an answer when you do not remember
  • Building on someone else’s story or a template
  • Treating the interpreter as your advocate
  • Accepting the interview record without checking the translation
  • Delaying the claim itself to prepare
  • Waiting after a refusal before turning to the appeal

What to do instead

  • Say “I don’t remember”: being caught out is worse than a gap
  • Your own account: every account must be your own and genuine
  • Address the caseworker; the interpreter is a neutral intermediary
  • Check the record and ask for translation errors to be corrected
  • Prepare in parallel without delaying the claim
  • Act as soon as the decision arrives: appeal deadlines are short

Preparing for the interview

  • Knowing the written account thoroughly: every date, event and detail, without contradictions.
  • Mock interviews with typical questions and follow-ups.
  • Difficult points: delay in claiming, previous travel, inconsistencies.
  • Preparing to talk about traumatic events.

Preparing for hearings

  • Agreeing the presentation of the case with the representing lawyer and identifying witnesses.
  • Rehearsing examination-in-chief and cross-examination where the system uses them.
  • Preparing witnesses: experts, family members, colleagues.
  • Serving evidence on time under the procedural rules.
  • Preparing for the government representative’s attempts to find inconsistencies.

Working with an interpreter

  • Speak clearly, at a moderate pace, in short sentences, without idioms or slang.
  • Raise problems with the interpreter immediately and ask for a replacement if needed.
  • Translation errors can create apparent contradictions and distort your evidence.

Fees and the limits of the work

The fee depends on complexity and scope: core preparation (account, organised evidence, interview preparation), extended preparation (adding an expert report and work with human rights organisations), or an appeal after refusal. Expert reports are usually paid separately. The exact fee is set after the free consultation; instalments are arranged individually. All fees and third-party costs.

What no one can promise

  • A positive decision. It belongs to the asylum authority or court.
  • That an expert or NGO will support the case. They act independently and selectively.
  • Risk-free evidence from the country of origin. Safety comes first.
  • An “improved” account. We do not write accounts for people or change facts: a fabricated account is unlawful and destroys a genuine claim.

Contact us without delay if

  • you have an interview or hearing in the coming weeks;
  • you have been refused and are considering an appeal;
  • your representative is overloaded and has no time for detailed preparation;
  • you have no direct evidence of persecution and need a strategy built on expert context;
  • your case involves conversion, LGBT+ identity or gender-based violence, which require specific preparation.

Questions

When should case preparation start?

Ideally before the claim is made, where that is possible without delaying it. Thorough preparation usually takes several weeks. Many people come to us after claiming, once an interview has been scheduled, or after a refusal and before an appeal. Preparation is possible at any stage, but the earlier it starts, the more can be done.

How much does case preparation cost?

Asylum work starts from €2,000. The fee depends on scope: core preparation, extended preparation (with an expert report and work with human rights organisations), or an appeal after refusal. Expert reports are usually paid separately. The exact fee is set after the free consultation; instalments are arranged individually.

Can you promise that my claim will succeed?

No. The decision is taken by independent asylum authorities and courts. We commit to an assessment of your prospects, careful preparation of the materials and the use of every lawful means of strengthening the case.

Can you help if I have already been refused?

Yes; preparing appeals is a large part of our work. A first-instance refusal is often linked to weak preparation or thin evidence. We analyse the refusal, strengthen the evidence and prepare a new, considerably fuller written account. Appeal deadlines are short, so contact us as soon as you receive the decision.

Do you work with cases from all post-Soviet countries?

Yes: Russia, Belarus, Ukraine, Kazakhstan, Uzbekistan, Tajikistan, Kyrgyzstan, Turkmenistan, Azerbaijan, Armenia, Georgia and Moldova, relying on country experts and published human rights sources on these states.

Do I need to come in person?

No. We work remotely by video call, email and messaging: the initial consultation, several sessions to build the account, and document exchange. Where you already have a local lawyer, we can arrange joint online meetings. We agree with you which channels suit sensitive material: Signal offers end-to-end encryption by default, ordinary Telegram chats do not.