Extradition defence
There is no single law of extradition. A common-law court, a court executing a European Arrest Warrant and a civil-law court each read the same request through a different lens. We build the defence around the legal system of the state that has to decide on surrender. The defence is run by INTERPOLSTOP’s lawyers and advocates. In a Spanish court our advocates appear; before a court in another country, a partner lawyer admitted there.
Do
- Ask for a lawyer immediately, and an interpreter if needed; you are not obliged to discuss the allegations before you have legal advice.
- Have your family or a trusted person informed so they can instruct lawyers if you cannot. Ask for your consulate to be notified only if that is safe in your situation.
- Prepare for the first hearing: proof of address, family ties and employment can decide whether you stay in custody until the main hearing.
Do not
- Sign documents in a language you do not understand, even if you are told it is a formality.
- Consent to simplified surrender without advice: in many systems consent is irrevocable and waives the examination of refusal grounds.
Extradition and Red Notices are two separate fronts
Having an INTERPOL notice deleted through the Commission for the Control of INTERPOL's Files (CCF) does not cancel the national arrest warrant behind it and does not halt extradition proceedings already under way. Winning in the extradition court does not remove the notice either.
Red Notices and diffusions are INTERPOL messages asking police forces to locate and provisionally arrest a person. Extradition is a separate national court process for surrendering that person, and it can run without any notice, for example on a direct diplomatic request. Both fronts usually have to be run at the same time: the CCF application and the defence in the court of the country where the person is.
Where the right to demand surrender comes from
A state never extradites "just because". Every request rests on a treaty, a multilateral convention or a national statute, and whether that instrument actually applies is the first thing we test.
Bilateral treaty
agreement between two statesDefines extraditable offences, the documents the requesting state must supply and the grounds on which surrender may be refused. Each treaty is different, so the defence works from the actual text and the way the two states have applied it, not from general principles.
Multilateral convention
ECE 1957; UN conventionsThe Council of Europe's 1957 European Convention on Extradition governs extradition between many European states and some non-European parties. UN conventions (e.g. against corruption, art. 44) can serve as a legal basis and impose an "extradite or prosecute" obligation, but they do not remove the refusal grounds discussed below.
National law and reciprocity
law of the requested stateWhere there is no treaty, many states can still extradite under their own legislation on the basis of reciprocity. Such cases tend to attract closer judicial scrutiny and often turn on diplomatic assurances, which the defence can and should test.
One set of facts — four legal logics
An argument that wins in one system may be irrelevant in another. Before any strategy is drafted we establish which procedural regime governs the case. The classification is a working simplification: every state has its own statute and case law.
| Regime | Examples | What is distinctive | Key instrument |
|---|---|---|---|
| Common law precedent-based | United Kingdom, United States, Canada | Prior judgments carry as much weight as the statute. Courts examine the sufficiency of the request closely, and there are separate appeal routes with very short filing deadlines. | e.g. UK Extradition Act 2003 |
| EU mutual recognition | Spain, Germany, France, Italy, Poland, Czechia, the Netherlands and other Member States | Surrender between Member States is largely a judicial formality with an exhaustive list of refusal grounds, short time limits and, for 32 listed offence categories, no double-criminality check. Fundamental rights remain a limit, as the CJEU has confirmed. | Framework Decision 2002/584/JHA |
| Civil law statute and doctrine | Many states of Central and Eastern Europe and Latin America, e.g. Switzerland, Moldova, Argentina, Brazil, Mexico | Emphasis on systematic interpretation and constitutional guarantees. Many constitutions bar the extradition of nationals to non-EU states. | ECE 1957; national codes |
| Treaty and reciprocity strong executive role | e.g. UAE, Türkiye, Qatar, Saudi Arabia, Egypt, several Asian states such as Indonesia and Vietnam | The court's ruling sits alongside a significant executive and diplomatic decision. Legal argument often has to be complemented by work on the diplomatic track and parallel CCF proceedings. | Bilateral treaties; national extradition laws |
Country guides explain the treaty framework, the court that hears the case, the appeal route and the practical risks: EU and EAW — Spain, Germany, France, Italy, Cyprus; common law — United Kingdom, United States; treaty — Israel, Türkiye, UAE, Thailand; Council of Europe — Serbia, Montenegro, Georgia, Armenia; CIS — Kazakhstan, Kyrgyzstan, Uzbekistan. All country guides; extradition status of CIS nationals from 69 countries — on the extradition map.
Bars close the case; discretionary grounds persuade the court
A bar makes surrender legally impossible once it is established; a discretionary ground has to be argued and weighed. The list differs between classic extradition to a non-EU state and surrender under a European Arrest Warrant (EAW).
Bars to surrender
FD 2002/584/JHA, art. 5(3)return to serve the sentence
Nationality — extradition to third states
Many civil-law constitutions prohibit extraditing their own nationals. Under the EAW this bar does not apply: Member States surrender their nationals, although they may require that the person be returned to serve any sentence at home.1
ECE, art. 3political offences; for the EAW — recital 12
Political offence — extradition only
A traditional exception in extradition treaties and the European Convention on Extradition.2 It is not a refusal ground under the EAW, although recital 12 of the Framework Decision allows refusal where there are objective reasons to believe the warrant was issued to punish a person for political opinions.
FD 2002/584/JHA, art. 3(2)mandatory refusal ground
Ne bis in idem
A person cannot be surrendered for acts for which they have already been finally convicted or acquitted. Under the EAW this is a mandatory refusal ground.
art. 3 ECHR; art. 3 UN CATSoering v. UK, 1989
Death penalty or torture
Article 3 ECHR and article 3 of the UN Convention against Torture prohibit removal to a real risk of torture or inhuman treatment; the European Court applied this to extradition in Soering v. United Kingdom.58 Assurances from the requesting state are examined critically and are not automatically sufficient.
art. 22 ECPTRussia out from 01.11.2026
No one left to verify Russia’s assurances
From 1 November 2026 Russia is no longer a party to the European Convention for the Prevention of Torture. The Council of Europe’s Committee for the Prevention of Torture can no longer visit Russian prisons and pre-trial detention centres; its President called this the end of any independent monitoring of places of deprivation of liberty in Russia. Between 1998 and 2021 the Committee made 30 visits there, but Russia authorised publication of only four reports. For the defence this is an argument: a court can no longer test Russia’s assurances on detention conditions against independent monitoring. Russia remains a party to the UN Convention against Torture.13
art. 6 ECHR"flagrant denial" threshold
Flagrant denial of a fair trial
Systemic absence of judicial independence, denial of access to counsel or reliance on evidence obtained by torture. The threshold is high: the risk must be of a "flagrant" denial, not merely of a trial below domestic standards.
Discretionary and evaluative grounds
| Ground | What the court weighs | Rule |
|---|---|---|
| No double criminality | In classic extradition the conduct must be an offence in both states; "insulting public officials" in an authoritarian state rarely meets that standard. Under the EAW the check is removed for the 32 listed categories. | FD 2002/584/JHA, art. 2 |
| Humanitarian circumstances | Health, age and young children: a balance between the interests of justice and private and family life. | art. 8 ECHR |
| Long residence in the requested state | Work, family and social ties are part of the proportionality assessment; under the EAW, residence also matters for the optional ground. | FD 2002/584/JHA, art. 4(6) |
| Disproportionality | Where the gravity of the charge bears no relation to the conduct alleged, some courts may refuse or require further information. | case law |
| Defects in the request | Missing documents, inconsistent dates or amounts, expired limitation periods, missed deadlines and absent mandatory assurances. | treaty, national statute |
Within the EU, the Court of Justice confirmed that fundamental rights limit surrender in Aranyosi and Căldăraru.7
From arrest to decision: junctions, not just stages
At each stage the defence can change the course of the case. Timings are typical orders of magnitude; exact deadlines depend on the treaty and the national statute.
The request
Travels through diplomatic channels or directly between ministries of justice. It must identify the person precisely, describe the alleged conduct with dates and circumstances, give the legal classification and the text of the applicable provisions, and enclose the underlying warrant or judgment.
Junction: an incomplete or poorly prepared request is a self-standing and often underestimated line of defence.
Provisional arrest or arrest on a full request
A person can be provisionally arrested on the strength of an INTERPOL notice or diffusion before the full file arrives. Under the European Convention on Extradition provisional arrest may end after 18 days and must not exceed 40 days if the request has not been received;2 bilateral treaties often allow longer periods.
Junction: if the documents do not arrive in time, the person must be released from provisional arrest; where release is arguable, the application is made at this stage.
Initial appearance — usually within a day or two
The judge confirms identity, explains the person's rights, ensures they are represented and decides on custody or release pending the main hearing.
Junction: release on bail or other conditions makes preparing the defence considerably easier.
Main hearing
The court does not decide guilt. It examines whether the request meets the legal requirements and whether any refusal ground applies. From weeks under the EAW to many months in classic extradition cases.
Junction: a bar is established — refusal, the case ends in that jurisdiction; no bar — the court rules on the request.
Decision
Refusal (the person is released), authorisation (in many systems the file then passes to the executive) or conditional authorisation subject to specific assurances from the requesting state.
Junction: on authorisation — appeal, often on a very short deadline (in the UK, 7 days for EAW cases and 14 days in non-EU cases).10
Challenge: appeal, cassation, constitutional court, ECtHR
The appeal reviews the application of the law and procedural errors. In civil-law systems cassation is the last national instance on points of law. Where available, a constitutional complaint addresses breaches of fundamental rights and may suspend surrender. If irreparable harm is imminent, an application to the European Court of Human Rights with a request for interim measures.
Junction: interim measure indicated — surrender is suspended while the Court examines the application.
Execution
In many classic extradition systems a minister or the government takes the final decision and may refuse on political or humanitarian grounds even after the court has authorised surrender. Under the EAW there is no executive stage: surrender follows the judicial decision, normally within 10 days (art. 23).
The clock is set by law, not by the court diary
Six time limits that most often shape the outcome: some work for the defence, others against it.
What a missed deadline does — and does not — mean
ECE, art. 16(4)release from provisional arrest
If the requesting state fails to send the extradition file within the treaty period, provisional arrest has to end. That is a release from custody, not the end of the case: the request can still arrive later.
CJEU, LaniganC‑237/15 PPU, 16.07.2015
Under the EAW, the Court of Justice held that expiry of the art. 17 time limits does not release the executing state from its obligation to decide on surrender, though continued detention must remain proportionate.6
Extradition Act 2003, s. 26(4)7 days to appeal
Appeal deadlines run the other way: in the UK a defence appeal in an EAW case must be lodged within 7 days. These are the moments when acting the same day matters.
When national appeals cannot keep up — the ECtHR
Rule 39, Rules of CourtECtHR factsheet
Domestic appeals can take months while the threat is immediate. Rule 39 of the Rules of the European Court of Human Rights fills that gap: the Court may indicate to a state that it should not remove the applicant while the application is being examined.3
The Court grants such measures only in exceptional circumstances, where there is an imminent risk of irreparable harm, typically to life (Article 2) or of treatment contrary to Article 3. Most requests concern expulsion or extradition. Requests are dealt with on a priority basis, in writing, and no appeal lies against the decision.
16.09.2022Russia ceased to be a party to the ECHR
Rule 39 is only available against a state party to the Convention. Where Russia is the requesting state, the measure is directed at the requested state, provided it is a party.11
art. 34 ECHRMamatkulov and Askarov v. Turkey [GC], 2005
Who does what in your case
The case is run by INTERPOLSTOP’s lawyers and advocates, largely remotely. In Spain our advocates appear in court; in other countries a partner lawyer admitted in the requested state appears in court, and we prepare the position, evidence and written submissions.
Included in our work
- Defence strategy.
- Objections based on the treaty, the political nature of the case, the risk of torture and of an unfair trial.
- Evidence and written submissions for the court.
- Coordination with the parallel fronts — the CCF and asylum; where irreparable harm is imminent, a Rule 39 request.
Paid separately
- A partner lawyer’s fees in another country, unless the agreement says otherwise.
- Bail and other sums set by the court.
- Travel and accommodation.
- State and court fees, translations.
| Service | Fee |
|---|---|
| Extradition defencestrategy, objections, evidence, coordination with the CCF and asylum | on request |
| Emergency assistance on detention24/7: first instructions, local counsel, first written objections | on request |
| Initial consultation60 minutes, confidential | free |
What no one can promise
- An outcome. Extradition decisions depend on the evidence, the treaty, the court and, in many states, the executive.
- That a refusal in one country protects you elsewhere, or that a CCF deletion ends a national prosecution.
- That Rule 39 measures will be granted. The European Court indicates them only in exceptional cases.
- That our own advocates appear in court in every country. Outside Spain, a partner lawyer admitted locally appears in court; we prepare the position for the hearing.
Contact us without delay if
- You have already been arrested on an extradition request or a European Arrest Warrant.
- The first-instance court has authorised extradition: appeal deadlines can be as short as 7 days.
- You fear torture, a flagrantly unfair trial or the death penalty in the requesting state: a Rule 39 request may have to be filed within hours.
- You have learned of a request informally, for example through a lawyer in the requesting state.
- You may be the subject of an INTERPOL notice or diffusion and are planning to travel — see how to check.
Questions
Is extradition the same as a Red Notice?
No. Red Notices and diffusions are INTERPOL messages asking police forces to locate and provisionally arrest a person. Extradition is a separate national court process for surrendering that person, and it can run without any INTERPOL notice, for example on a direct diplomatic request. Deleting a notice through the CCF does not cancel the national warrant or stop extradition proceedings already under way.
What should I do if I am arrested on an extradition request?
Ask for a lawyer and an interpreter, do not sign documents you do not understand and do not consent to simplified surrender without advice. Have a relative contact us: we bring in a partner lawyer in the country where you are as quickly as possible and start preparing the release application and the defence.
Why does the strategy depend on the country of arrest?
Extradition law is not harmonised worldwide. Common-law courts rely heavily on precedent; within the EU, refusal grounds under the European Arrest Warrant are exhaustively listed in Framework Decision 2002/584/JHA; civil-law systems emphasise statutory interpretation and often bar the extradition of nationals to non-EU states. An argument that decides a case in one system may carry no weight in another.
Can I be released on bail?
In many jurisdictions, yes. Courts weigh the risk of flight, the seriousness of the charges and the person's ties to the country. Conditions may include a financial guarantee, surrender of passports, reporting and sometimes electronic monitoring. Release makes preparing the defence considerably easier, but it is never automatic.
What are ECtHR interim measures (Rule 39)?
An urgent indication by the European Court of Human Rights that a state should not extradite or expel a person while the application is examined. The Court grants them only exceptionally, where there is an imminent risk of irreparable harm such as torture or death. States party to the Convention are bound to comply; Russia has not been a party since 16 September 2022.
What happens after the court refuses extradition?
The person is released. Whether a new request can be made depends on the law of the requested state: a fresh request on the same facts is usually refused, but a request based on new facts or new documents is not always excluded. A refusal in one country does not protect you in others, and any INTERPOL notice stays active until it is deleted, so we work on the CCF application in parallel.
Can I travel while extradition proceedings are pending?
That depends on the conditions of release. In custody, no. On bail, you are usually not allowed to leave the jurisdiction until the case ends, and breaching that condition leads to re-arrest and weakens your position. After a final refusal the formal restrictions fall away, but the practical risk of arrest in other countries remains as long as an INTERPOL notice or national warrant is in force.
Is it true that countries without an extradition treaty never extradite?
No. Many states can extradite without a treaty, under their own legislation and on the basis of reciprocity or a multilateral convention. The absence of a bilateral treaty is a factor in the analysis, not a guarantee of safety.
What lawful ways are there to resist extradition?
Three routes are often combined: international protection (refugee status or asylum) where the prosecution is shown to be persecution, which engages the non-refoulement principle; challenging the request itself in court on the grounds described above; and, where the risk is serious and imminent, an application to the European Court of Human Rights. Running these alongside a CCF application usually gives the strongest position.
Sources
- 1Council Framework Decision 2002/584/JHA on the European Arrest Warrant — arts. 2–5, 17, 23; recital 12eur-lex.europa.eu
- 2European Convention on Extradition, ETS No. 24 — arts. 3, 16coe.int
- 3Factsheet "Interim measures" (Rule 39), March 2024echr.coe.int
- 4Mamatkulov and Askarov v. Turkey [GC], nos. 46827/99 and 46951/99, 4 February 2005hudoc.echr.coe.int
- 5Soering v. the United Kingdom, no. 14038/88, 7 July 1989hudoc.echr.coe.int
- 6CJEU, Lanigan, C‑237/15 PPU, 16 July 2015curia.europa.eu
- 7CJEU, Aranyosi and Căldăraru, C‑404/15 and C‑659/15 PPU, 5 April 2016curia.europa.eu
- 8UN Convention against Torture, art. 3ohchr.org
- 9UN Convention against Corruption, art. 44unodc.org
- 10Extradition Act 2003, s. 26 (7-day appeal period); s. 103 (14-day appeal period)legislation.gov.uk
- 11Russia ceases to be party to the European Convention on Human Rights (16 September 2022)coe.int
- 12Commission for the Control of INTERPOL's Files (CCF)interpol.int
- 13CPT: Russia officially withdraws from the Anti-Torture Convention (1 November 2026)coe.int
General information, not legal advice; outcomes depend on the facts of each case and the law of the jurisdictions involved. Stories from our practice are published only in anonymised form, with names, cities, dates and details changed.
Facing an extradition request or the risk of arrest?The first consultation is 60 minutes, free and confidential.
Free consultation