Independent legal practice.

Detained? +34 613 889 381 — 24/7
INTERPOLSTOP — home Русский: RU Free consultation Detained?

Extradition from Germany: two keys to one door

German law never lets a single office decide on surrender. A Higher Regional Court (OLG) first rules whether extradition is legally admissible; the federal executive then decides whether to approve it. Above both sits the Federal Constitutional Court, which has more than once stopped a surrender to Russia.

The court says “may”; the government decides “will”

The Act on International Cooperation in Criminal Matters (IRG) splits extradition into two separate stages: the admissibility review (Zulässigkeitsverfahren) and executive approval (Bewilligungsverfahren).

Key 1 — judicial

Oberlandesgericht

IRG §§ 13, 29, 33
  • The OLG of the federal state where the person is held tests whether the law permits surrender: dual criminality, the political-offence bar, risk of persecution, prison conditions and the reliability of assurances.
  • The prosecution office at that court (Generalstaatsanwaltschaft) prepares the case and later carries out any surrender.3
  • OLG decisions are final (§ 13); new circumstances allow a fresh ruling (§ 33).
Key 2 — executive

Approval: BfJ and Foreign Office

IRG §§ 74, 73, 8
  • Under § 74 the Federal Ministry of Justice decides in agreement with the Foreign Office; in practice approval of incoming requests rests with the Federal Office of Justice (Bundesamt für Justiz, BfJ) unless delegated to the federal states.56
  • Foreign-policy considerations and the requesting state's assurances come in here.
  • § 73 — no assistance contrary to fundamental principles of German law; § 8 — death penalty only with an assurance of non-imposition.

A refusal at either stage closes the door, while a favourable court ruling does not by itself mean surrender. OLG decisions cannot be appealed, so the next step is not an appeal at all but a constitutional complaint to the Federal Constitutional Court (BVerfG), coupled with an application for an interim order.

Three questions every case starts with

Before anyone argues about prisons or politics, establish which category the person falls into: the answer determines whether surrender to a non-EU state is possible at all.

Art. 16(2) GGBasic Law

A German national?

No German may be extradited abroad. Statute may make an exception only for surrender to an EU member state or an international court, and only where rule-of-law principles are upheld.1 Russia, like any third state, falls outside that exception; the question becomes one of prosecution in Germany itself.

CJEU, C-182/15Petruhhin, 06.09.2016

A national of another EU state?

On receiving a third-state request for another EU state's national, Germany must inform that state so that it can prosecute and issue a European Arrest Warrant itself. Courts check that the notification was real; in 2022 the French Court of Cassation quashed a ruling on a Russian request precisely because the notification had been treated as a formality.10

§ 6 AsylGAsylum Act

A recognised refugee or asylum seeker?

Status is taken into account but does not automatically bar extradition: the Asylum Act expressly denies asylum decisions binding force in extradition proceedings.4 See below.

IRG map: provision, rule, use in practice

ProvisionWhat it saysHow the defence uses it
§ 6(1)No extradition for a political offence or a connected offence; genocide, murder and manslaughter (including attempts) are excluded from the bar.Arguing that the conduct itself is political: public activism, criticism of the authorities, protest, “extremism” charges based on speech.
§ 6(2)No extradition where there are serious grounds to believe the person would be prosecuted, punished or disadvantaged because of race, religion, nationality, membership of a social group or political opinion.2The main line in economic cases with a political backdrop: corporate raiding, pressure on a business, a refusal to cooperate with officials.
§ 8Where the offence carries the death penalty, extradition requires an assurance that it will be neither imposed nor carried out.14Relevant for some third-state requests; for Russia §§ 6 and 73 matter more.
§ 13Judicial decisions are made by the OLG and are not open to appeal; the prosecution office at the OLG prepares and executes surrender.3All evidential work must be done before the OLG — there is no second instance on the facts.
§ 33If new circumstances arise after the admissibility ruling, the OLG must (or may) decide afresh and can postpone surrender.7The tool for a changed picture: new prison-monitoring reports, an asylum decision, new facts about the case.
§ 41Simplified extradition with consent; consent recorded by the local court judge cannot be withdrawn and may waive speciality protection.8Sign nothing before speaking to counsel. This is the costliest mistake of the first day.
§ 73Assistance is inadmissible if it would contravene fundamental principles of the German legal order.9The gateway for Article 3 and Article 6 ECHR standards: torture, inhuman conditions, an unfair trial.

What the Constitutional Court has demanded of the OLGs in Russian cases

Three published BVerfG decisions on surrender to Russia show where lower courts go wrong and what a constitutional complaint can build on.

2 BvR 2486/15, 02.02.2016, OLG Munich

Trust in assurances is a presumption, not a dogma

No violation found: Russia had given assurances against torture and agreed to visits by German embassy staff. Protection granted in Austria is normally a strong indicator of risk, but here the Austrian court had expressly ruled out political persecution.12

Takeaway: assurances hold only while there is a real mechanism to monitor compliance.

2 BvR 828/19, 14.05.2019, Brandenburg OLG

A condition Russia cannot meet

The OLG allowed the surrender of a Chechen man on condition that he be tried outside the North Caucasus Federal District. Russia's Prosecutor General refused that assurance, citing the constitutional right to a lawful judge. The Constitutional Court temporarily barred the handover.13

Takeaway: test every assurance for enforceability under the requesting state's own law.

2 BvR 1282/21, 28.07.2021, OLG Düsseldorf

A persecution argument cannot be passed over in silence

Surrender to Russia was temporarily prohibited because the OLG had not engaged with detailed persecution arguments, had made no overall assessment of the expected detention conditions and had not tested the reliability of Russian assurances.11

Takeaway: the fuller the defence submissions before the OLG, the stronger the case in Karlsruhe.

In Germany, asylum and extradition are separate proceedings

The assumption

  • “I've applied to BAMF, so they can't extradite me.”
  • “I'm already a recognised refugee — that settles it.”

The law

  • An asylum decision binds every authority except in two settings: extradition proceedings and removal under § 58a of the Residence Act (§ 6 AsylG).4
  • The OLG assesses the risk of persecution for itself. Status is powerful evidence, not immunity.

The two proceedings therefore have to run in parallel and in step: evidence of persecution submitted to BAMF must also reach the extradition file, and any inconsistency between them will be used against the applicant. For asylum, including the constitutional right under Article 16a of the Basic Law, see Political asylum in Germany and Asylum in Germany with a Red Notice.

Russian requests since 2022: what has changed, and what the law has not

ECE 1957Committee of Ministers, 23.03.2022

The legal basis survives

Extradition between Germany and Russia rests on the 1957 European Convention on Extradition. On 23 March 2022 the Council of Europe's Committee of Ministers decided that Russia remains a party to Council of Europe treaties open to non-member states, and the Extradition Convention is one of them — a point the French Court of Cassation applied directly to a Russian request.10 A Russian request therefore remains formally admissible for consideration.

ECHR, Art. 3Russia outside since 16.09.2022

The factual footing of assurances has shifted

Germany is still bound by the Convention, and the Article 3 standard governs its own decision to surrender. The reasoning of 2016 — trust the assurances because monitoring and an international accountability mechanism exist — calls for far closer scrutiny now that Russia has left the Convention system. That is our assessment, not a quotation from a particular judgment; each outcome turns on the court, the charge and the defence evidence.

What not to expect

German law contains no blanket ban on extradition to Russia, and we are not aware of any formal German act suspending extradition cooperation with Russia. Arrest on an INTERPOL Red Notice or diffusion remains possible while the alert stands. For anyone living in or travelling to Germany, work on the alert itself matters — Red Notice removal through the Commission for the Control of INTERPOL's Files (CCF) or a preventive request.

If an arrest has already happened: the first days

§ 41 IRGconsent is irrevocable

Before the local court judge

After arrest the person is brought before an Amtsgericht judge. This is not the merits hearing, but it is where consent to simplified extradition may be offered. The answer waits until counsel has been consulted.

German counsel experienced in extradition law

The lawyer in court must be admitted in Germany — that is our partner counsel; in parallel, INTERPOLSTOP's lawyers and advocates assemble the evidence in Russian: the case file in Russia, evidence of pressure, publications, medical records.

§§ 6, 73 IRGeverything goes before the OLG

The case before the OLG

Objections under §§ 6 and 73 IRG, scrutiny of assurances, applications to relax custody. There is no appeal on the facts.

Parallel tracks

A request to the CCF, an asylum claim and, where needed, a constitutional complaint and an ECtHR Rule 39 request.

What a defence costs and what we cannot promise

Extradition defenceon request
Emergency help on detention24/7on request
Risk analysis and auditfrom €2,000
First consultation60 minutesfree
Figures are starting points. The exact fee is set after the free consultation and depends on the stage of the case, the number of jurisdictions and the work required from partner counsel. See fees.

Limits

  • No guaranteed refusal. The decision belongs to the OLG, the federal authorities and, if it gets that far, the Constitutional Court.
  • Court representation. Only a lawyer admitted in Germany can appear before a German court — that is our partner counsel.
  • Asylum is not automatic protection. Refugee status or a pending asylum claim does not rule out extradition.
  • Case law since 2022 is only partly published. A realistic assessment is possible only after reviewing the documents in a given case.

Legislation, judgments and documents

  1. 1Basic Law (Grundgesetz), Art. 16: no extradition of German nationalsgesetze-im-internet.de
  2. 2IRG, § 6: political offences, persecutiongesetze-im-internet.de
  3. 3IRG, § 13: OLG jurisdiction, finality of decisionsgesetze-im-internet.de
  4. 4Asylum Act (AsylG), § 6: asylum decisions not binding in extradition proceedingsgesetze-im-internet.de
  5. 5IRG, § 74: federal competence for approvalgesetze-im-internet.de
  6. 6Federal Office of Justice: international cooperation in criminal matters, approval of extradition requestsbundesjustizamt.de
  7. 7IRG, § 33: fresh admissibility rulinggesetze-im-internet.de
  8. 8IRG, § 41: simplified extradition, irrevocable consentgesetze-im-internet.de
  9. 9IRG, § 73: limits of legal assistancegesetze-im-internet.de
  10. 10French Court of Cassation, 11.10.2022, No. 22-80.120: Russian request, Petruhhin, Russia's continuing party status under the 1957 Conventioncuria.europa.eu
  11. 11Federal Constitutional Court, 2 BvR 1282/21, 28.07.2021 (HRRS 2021 No. 916)hrr-strafrecht.de
  12. 12Federal Constitutional Court, 2 BvR 2486/15, 02.02.2016: case noterechtslupe.de
  13. 13Federal Constitutional Court, 2 BvR 828/19, 14.05.2019 (HRRS 2019 No. 555)hrr-strafrecht.de
  14. 14IRG, § 8: death penaltygesetze-im-internet.de

General legal information as of October 2026, not advice on any particular case. Strategy is decided only after reviewing the documents, with counsel admitted to practise in Germany.