ECtHR Rule 39: an emergency brake on removal
An interim measure from the European Court of Human Rights (ECtHR) is the only international tool that can, at short notice, require a State not to extradite or expel someone while the Court examines the case. Its scope is narrow: it binds only States party to the European Convention on Human Rights (ECHR), it comes after suspensive domestic remedies are exhausted, and as a rule it is reserved for risks to life or of ill-treatment.
The first filter: ask “removed from where?”, not “to where?”
An interim measure is addressed to the respondent State — the country preparing to extradite or expel you. That is why Russia’s departure from the Convention does not prevent Rule 39 being used against extradition to Russia: what matters is that the country you are in is a party.
The 46 Council of Europe States
All 27 EU States, the United Kingdom, Switzerland, Norway, Türkiye, Georgia, Armenia, Azerbaijan, Serbia, Montenegro, Moldova, Ukraine.
Country detail: Türkiye, Georgia, Armenia, Serbia, Montenegro, Cyprus.
Countries outside the Convention
Russia (since 16.09.2022), Belarus, Kazakhstan, Kyrgyzstan, Uzbekistan, UAE, Thailand, Israel, United States.
Here the UN mechanisms remain: the UN Committee against Torture and the UN Human Rights Committee — where the State has accepted individual complaints.
What Rule 39 § 1 actually says
“The Court may, in exceptional circumstances, whether at the request of a party or of any other person concerned, or of its own motion, indicate to the parties any interim measure which it considers should be adopted. Such measures, applicable in cases of imminent risk of irreparable harm to a Convention right, which, on account of its nature, would not be susceptible to reparation, restoration or adequate compensation, may be adopted where necessary in the interests of the parties or the proper conduct of the proceedings.”
Practice Directionrevised 28.03.2024
The President’s Practice Direction adds that measures are indicated only on prima facie evidence of an imminent risk of irreparable harm — not where an applicant would merely endure hardship — and that most such cases involve a clearly arguable threat to life and limb, i.e. Articles 2 and 3.2
ECHR, Art. 34Mamatkulov and Askarov v. Turkey
Interim measures are binding: citing Mamatkulov and Askarov v. Turkey, the Practice Direction states that failure to comply engages Article 34 of the Convention.
What the 2024 reform changed
The plenary Court amended the text on 23 February 2024 and a revised Practice Direction took effect on 28 March 2024. The Court presents the change as codifying existing practice rather than tightening it.2
| What | How it works now | Para. |
|---|---|---|
| Threshold | “Imminent risk of irreparable harm”. A test previously found only in the case-law now sits in Rule 39 itself, together with a definition of irreparable harm. | Rule 39 § 1 |
| Form | Signed decisions naming the judges. Every outcome — grant, refusal, adjournment, lifting — is notified as a decision signed by the duty judge or President, with the judges named. Further reasoning remains discretionary. | paras 13, 24 |
| Decision-makers | Duty judges and the President of the Court. The duty judges are the Vice-Presidents of the five Sections and do not deal with requests against their own State. New: an express power for the President of the Court to indicate measures. | paras 9–10 |
| Review | No appeal, but a fresh request is possible if circumstances change. The State may ask for a measure to be reconsidered. | paras 25–27 |
Making the request: what the file must contain
Requests go through the “ECHR Rule 39 Site”, by fax or by post — the Court does not deal with requests sent by email (para. 32). Incomplete or unsubstantiated requests are not normally put before a judge. The list follows paras 33–34 of the Practice Direction.2
- Applicant details: names, date of birth, nationality, current address or place of detention; representative’s details and capacity.
- Respondent State: the State the request is lodged against — the one extraditing or expelling.
- Removal details: reasons for leaving and for fearing return, date and circumstances of arrival, destination, scheduled removal date.
- The risk: a detailed account of the situation and of the imminent irreparable harm; the Convention Articles relied on.
- Prosecution documents: search and arrest warrants, convictions, press coverage and country reports.
- Domestic proceedings: all extradition and asylum decisions with dates, copies of appeals, details of removal proceedings.
- Authority form: may follow shortly after the request; the applicant’s consent is required.
- Documents, not references: referring to arguments made elsewhere is not enough (para. 36); everything must be attached.
Three conditions on which requests most often fail
para. 40Practice Direction
Domestic remedies first
While a suspensive domestic appeal is open, the Court will not apply Rule 39.
para. 38Practice Direction
At least a working day
Requests received less than a working day before removal may not be dealt with.
paras 23, 39Practice Direction
Do not wait for urgency
If a final decision is imminent, file in advance, conditional on a negative outcome.
paras 16–20, 31, 44Practice Direction
There is no fixed response time: requests are handled as a priority in a written procedure. The Court may grant a measure for a limited period while it asks for information, or adjourn until the Government replies. Once a measure is in place the applicant must keep the Court informed of domestic proceedings, or the case may be struck out.
Official statistics: how often the Court says yes
ECtHR data only. The 2023 spike reflects mass reception-conditions cases (Belgium) and border cases (Poland, Greece), not extradition.
| Year | Outside the scope | Refused | Granted | Total |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2023 | 857 | 359 | 1418 | 2634 |
| 2024 | 916 | 346 | 371 | 1633 |
| 2025 | 1984 | 495 | 222 | 2701 |
ECtHR, 2025by State and theme
Of the 222 measures granted in 2025, 149 concerned border situations and 38 expulsion or extradition; of the 495 requests refused by a judge, 299 concerned expulsion or extradition.5 In our category of case, judges therefore refused roughly eight requests for every one granted in 2025 — before counting requests found to fall outside Rule 39 altogether.
| Respondent State | Outside scope | Refused | Granted | Total 2025 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Türkiye | 193 | 34 | 3 | 230 |
| Georgia | 29 | 22 | 5 | 56 |
| Armenia | 18 | 5 | 4 | 27 |
| Azerbaijan | 8 | 5 | 2 | 15 |
| Serbia | 20 | 11 | 2 | 33 |
| Montenegro | 9 | 2 | 0 | 11 |
| Republic of Moldova | 23 | 2 | 0 | 25 |
| Cyprus | 16 | 4 | 2 | 22 |
| Germany | 262 | 22 | 0 | 284 |
| France | 212 | 68 | 5 | 285 |
| Spain | 92 | 14 | 0 | 106 |
| United Kingdom | 197 | 21 | 0 | 218 |
What Russia’s exit changed
- 16.03.2022Council of Europe
Expulsion from the Council of Europe
The Committee of Ministers ended the Russian Federation’s membership.
- 22.03.2022ECtHR
Plenary resolution of the Court
Russia ceases to be a party on 16.09.2022; the Court keeps jurisdiction over acts or omissions up to that date.6
- 16.09.2022ECHR
The Convention stops applying
Complaints about later events cannot be brought against Russia, and interim measures cannot be addressed to it.
ECtHR factsheet“Interim measures”, March 2024
For someone Russia is pursuing abroad, the other side matters more: removal to Russia from Convention States remains under the Court’s supervision. The Court’s factsheet on interim measures cites, for example, the November 2023 decision in I.A. v. France suspending an expulsion to Russia, and Khachaturov v. Armenia, an extradition to Russia in which a measure was applied in 2017.3 Russian diplomatic assurances are weighed on their merits by national courts and the ECtHR, not taken on trust.
What Rule 39 does not do
- It quashes nothing. Not an extradition order, a Red Notice or a SIS alert; it only suspends physical removal while the Strasbourg case runs.
- It does not replace domestic appeals. If a suspensive domestic remedy is open, the Court will not act.
- It has no guaranteed turnaround. A last-minute request may not be decided before the flight.
- It is granted in a minority of cases. In 2025 the Court granted 38 measures in expulsion and extradition cases and refused 299.
Primary sources
- 1ECtHR, Rules of Court, Rule 39echr.coe.int
- 2ECtHR, Practice Direction “Requests for interim measures”, revised 28.03.2024 — paras 1–46echr.coe.int
- 3ECtHR, Factsheet “Interim measures”, March 2024 — I.A. v. France, Khachaturov v. Armenia, Othman (Abu Qatada)echr.coe.int
- 4ECtHR, “Rule 39 requests … processed by the Court in 2023, 2024 and 2025”echr.coe.int
- 5ECtHR, “Interim measures by respondent State and key theme in 2025”echr.coe.int
- 6ECtHR, Resolution on the consequences of the cessation of membership of the Russian Federation to the Council of Europe, 22.03.2022echr.coe.int
- 7ECtHR, statisticsechr.coe.int
This page is general information, not legal advice. Rules and practice change; whether any of this applies to you can only be assessed after reviewing your documents.