Results
Stories from our practice involving nationals of Russia, Belarus, Central Asia and the Caucasus, followed by public precedents — real, documented cases and decisions: annual reports of the Commission for the Control of INTERPOL’s Files (CCF), judgments of the European Court of Human Rights and the Court of Justice of the EU, decisions of national courts, publications of the European Data Protection Supervisor (EDPS), Eurojust and the US State Department, and cases recorded by Fair Trials, Freedom House, Reporters Without Borders, the Committee to Protect Journalists and others.
Stories from our practice
These stories are based on cases we have handled since 2015. Names, cities, dates and details have been changed so that no client can be identified — including by the state pursuing them.
Most of the stories date from after February 2022: once the war in Ukraine began, requests from nationals of Russia, Belarus and Central Asia multiplied. Not every case ends the way we would want. We have kept those too.
- 2015–2017Russia
A shareholder dispute recast as fraud
A co-owner of a plant in the Volga region refused to sell his stake to his partners. Two months later a case was opened against him under Article 159(4) of the Russian Criminal Code, and in the summer of 2015 he was arrested at Málaga airport on a Red Notice. Our advocate was with him on the day of the arrest.
We showed the court the chronology: a commercial dispute over the stake, letters offering to “settle the matter”, a criminal case opened six weeks after he said no. He was released on conditions and surrendered his passport. In 2016 Spain refused extradition. A year later the CCF deleted the notice, finding that the dispute was essentially private.
- 2017–2019Kazakhstan
A former banker in Vienna
The deputy chairman of a regional bank was charged with misappropriation (Article 189 of the Kazakh Criminal Code) after the bank changed hands. By the time the Red Notice appeared he had been living in Austria for three years.
Our request to the CCF rested on three points: the case was opened right after the change of shareholders, relatives were called in for questioning, and human-rights reports describe Kazakh courts in such cases as lacking independence. The data were deleted after eleven months. The Austrian court rejected the extradition request.
- 2018–2019Uzbekistan
Twenty-four hours for Rule 39
A builder from the Fergana region was accused of religious extremism (Article 244-2 of the Uzbek Criminal Code) on the word of an acquaintance who was himself under investigation. On a diffusion he was detained in Istanbul when he came to renew his residence permit, and served with a deportation order.
His wife called us in the evening. By morning a request for an interim measure under Rule 39 was with the European Court: reports on torture in such cases and a note on who had testified. The Court granted the measure and the deportation was halted. A year later he received subsidiary protection in Germany.
- 2019–2020Tajikistan
A notice that was never published
A supporter of the opposition movement Group 24, banned in Tajikistan as extremist, was living in Poland when acquaintances told him a request to INTERPOL was being prepared.
We sent the CCF a pre-emptive submission before publication: the movement’s charter, the decisions banning it, reports on the persecution of other members. A later access request showed that the General Secretariat had decided not to publish the notice. In 2020 Poland recognised him as a refugee.
- 2019–2021Moldova
When the CCF said no
A manager of a trading company from Chișinău was charged with fraud (Article 190 of the Moldovan Criminal Code) at the height of the 2019 political crisis. He lived in Germany and was sure the case was political: the company was linked to people around the former government.
We told him plainly that the evidence of a political motive was thin and that the investigators did have the transaction records. The CCF refused deletion. We then focused on the German court and obtained Moldovan assurances on detention conditions and release on bail pending trial. He was surrendered in 2021, awaited trial at liberty in Chișinău, and the charge was reduced.
- 2021–2022Belarus
A protester who learned of a diffusion from a residence form
A participant in the 2020 protests was charged under Article 342 of the Belarusian Criminal Code with “gross violation of public order”. He moved to Lithuania and found out he was wanted by chance, when the migration department asked about an “INTERPOL entry”.
An access request confirmed a diffusion from Minsk. The deletion request relied on Article 3 of the Constitution: the case concerned the protests, not an ordinary crime. The CCF deleted the data and he received his residence permit.
- 2022–2023Russia
A teacher and a post about Bucha
A teacher from the Perm region was charged under Article 207.3 of the Russian Criminal Code over a social-media post. She managed to leave for Yerevan. Six months later she was stopped at Zvartnots airport: she was on the interstate wanted list.
Overnight we contacted an Armenian partner lawyer and prepared a submission to the prosecutors on the political nature of the case. She was released in the morning, and two weeks later the Prosecutor General of Armenia refused extradition. We then helped her obtain a humanitarian visa for Germany.
- 2022–2023Russia
A CIS extradition that did not happen
An engineer from Omsk moved to Kazakhstan in autumn 2022. Five months later he was detained in Astana on the CIS interstate wanted list: Russia accused him of embezzlement at his former job. Kazakhstan often extradites Russians on such requests.
The defence was built on documents: acceptance certificates, correspondence with management, a report showing that the “embezzlement” was equipment written off on the director’s order. Our Kazakh partner lawyer filed them with the Prosecutor General’s Office together with an appeal against the extension of custody. Four months later extradition was refused and he was released.
- 2022–2024Russia
A call-up, Upper Lars and France
A programmer from Novosibirsk received his call-up papers in September 2022 and three days later was queuing at the Georgian border. A case was later opened against him under Article 328 of the Russian Criminal Code and he was put on the federal and interstate wanted lists.
INTERPOL was not the main issue: evading military service is a military matter, and INTERPOL as a rule does not process such requests. The danger lay in the CIS search and in transit flights. We planned a route avoiding transit through countries that act on such searches and prepared an asylum case. He was granted protection in France in 2024.
- 2023Belarus
A five-euro donation
A software developer from Minsk was charged with “financing extremist activity” (Article 361-2 of the Belarusian Criminal Code) for a transfer to a fund helping political prisoners. He was detained at Milan airport on a diffusion on his way to a holiday.
The Italian court released him after three days, helped by notes on the substance of the charge and on the agreement of EU justice ministers of 4 March 2022 not to execute Belarusian requests in criminal matters. The CCF deleted the diffusion eight months later.
- 2023Russia
A comment and Antalya
A Russian who had lived in Antalya for two years was charged with “justifying terrorism” (Article 205.2 of the Russian Criminal Code) over a comment under a news item. Turkish police detained him on a Red Notice right outside his home.
With a partner lawyer we showed the Turkish court that the charge rested on a single sentence on social media. The court refused extradition, but the migration service almost at once issued a deportation order. An application for international protection helped: while it was pending he could not be removed. Six months later he received a residence permit.
- 2023Russia
A request that failed review
A former regional government official who had moved to Lithuania was charged with abuse of office after giving an interview about public procurement. He learned that Moscow was preparing a request to INTERPOL.
Since March 2022 the General Secretariat has scrutinised Russian requests with particular care. We sent the CCF a pre-emptive submission: the interview, a chronology, the decisions opening the case. An access request a year later showed that no notice had been published.
- 2023–2024Russia
Forty days in Dubai
A co-owner of a logistics company was charged with fraud after his stake was transferred to entities close to the security services. In March 2023 he was arrested in Dubai on a Red Notice.
Our local partner lawyer appeared in court, and we secured his release on bail, with his passport surrendered, after forty days. We showed the court the civil nature of the dispute and the documents on the change of ownership. A request went to the CCF in parallel. In February 2024 the notice was deleted and the extradition proceedings were closed.
- 2023–2024Kyrgyzstan
A journalist and “calls to riot”
A journalist at an independent outlet was charged under Article 278 of the Kyrgyz Criminal Code with “calls to mass riots” over a series of investigations. He was living in Germany and wanted to know whether he could travel in Europe.
An access request confirmed a diffusion. For the deletion request we gathered the publications, the positions of international journalists’ organisations and a chronology of pressure on the newsroom. The data were deleted after ten months.
- 2024Tajikistan
A case we did not win
A migrant worker near Moscow was detained at Tajikistan’s request: “extremism” for following an opposition channel. His relatives came to us on the second day.
We asked the UN Committee against Torture for interim measures, and a Russian lawyer appealed against the removal order. The Committee requested the measures, but he was removed before the appeals were heard. In Tajikistan he was sentenced to seven years. We are now pursuing a complaint before the UN Committee. We write about this case because, since Russia left the Council of Europe, such outcomes have become common.
- 2024Armenia
Forty days in Almaty
An Armenian national who had run an IT business in Moscow for years and left in 2022 was put on the CIS interstate wanted list by Russia under Article 159(4) of the Russian Criminal Code. He was detained while changing planes in Almaty.
Under the CIS convention Russia had a limited time to send a formal extradition request. We watched the deadline and prepared objections, which our Kazakh partner lawyer argued in court. The point was simple: the client was an Armenian national, and the “embezzlement” was an order left unpaid under a contract. No complete request arrived in time; he was released on the fortieth day and flew to Yerevan.
- 2024Russia
Two months in Belgrade
An activist from St Petersburg charged with “discrediting the army” (Article 280.3 of the Russian Criminal Code) was detained in Belgrade, where he had flown for a conference. Serbia examines such requests in court, and the final word rests with the Minister of Justice.
We lost at first instance: the court found the formal conditions for extradition met. On appeal our Serbian partner lawyer stressed that the act is not a crime in Serbia and that Russia had left the European Convention on Human Rights. The appeal court quashed the decision, and he was released after two months.
- 2024–2025Russia
A contract soldier in Gyumri
A contract soldier left his unit without permission (Article 337 of the Russian Criminal Code) and went to Armenia. He knew from the news that in Gyumri, near the Russian base, Russian military police had detained people.
We helped him prepare an application for a humanitarian visa at the German embassy in Yerevan: documents on his service, the criminal case and the risk of persecution. The visa was issued six weeks later. In Germany he was recognised as a refugee.
- 2024–2025Azerbaijan
A blogger arrested in absentia
A video blogger living in Germany was arrested in absentia in Baku under the article on public calls. We knew the next step would be a request to INTERPOL.
A pre-emptive submission went to the CCF before Azerbaijan applied for a Red Notice. The notice was not published. Baku later circulated a diffusion, and the CCF deleted that too, in 2025.
- 2025Russia
Ninety days in Phuket
The owner of a construction firm was charged with tax evasion (Article 199 of the Russian Criminal Code). In February 2025 he was arrested in Phuket on a Red Notice.
Thai law gives the requesting state a limited time to submit a formal extradition request. Our Thai partner lawyer appeared in court; we followed every extension and pressed the court to examine the documents rather than simply extend the detention. Russia did not file a complete request in time, and he was released on the ninetieth day. The request to the CCF is under examination.
- 2025Russia
Someone else’s SIS alert
A Russian woman who had lived in Spain for eight years was refused boarding for Riga: Latvia had entered her in SIS with an entry ban. The alert also put the renewal of her residence permit at risk.
It turned out that the ban rested on a mistaken match with another person. The access request and the deletion request to the Latvian authority took five months. The alert was deleted and her permit renewed.
- 2025Kyrgyzstan
A witness in Europol’s files
A businessman from Bishkek living in the Czech Republic could not open an account at any bank. It turned out that his data had entered a Europol analysis file from someone else’s investigation, in which he was a witness.
We sent an access request through the Czech national authority and asked for deletion of data no longer needed for the investigation. Europol deleted them. The bank accepted the letter confirming this, and the account was opened.
- 2025Kazakhstan
Three countries, one case
A Kazakh national who co-owned a logistics firm in Spain was caught up in a money-laundering investigation that the Latvian and German prosecutors were coordinating through Eurojust. A European Arrest Warrant was issued for him.
The worst outcome would have been lawyers in three countries each defending him their own way. We built a single position and one body of evidence. The Spanish court executed the warrant but released him pending surrender, and the German prosecutor, once given the transaction records, reclassified him as a witness.
- 2025–2026Kazakhstan
The Red Notice is gone, but the bank remembers
A financier from Almaty had his notice deleted back in 2021, yet in 2025 a bank in Cyprus closed the family’s accounts. The cause was an old entry in a compliance database that nobody had updated.
We sent the database provider GDPR requests for access, rectification and erasure of the outdated data, with the CCF decision attached. Two months later the entry was corrected and the bank resumed service.
- 2026Russia
Arrested in Podgorica
A correspondent for a regional outlet was charged under two articles at once: on “fakes” and on “discrediting the army”. In May 2026 he was detained in Montenegro on a diffusion.
With our partner lawyer arguing before the Montenegrin court, we showed that the charges concerned nothing but his publications. A month later the court declared the extradition inadmissible and released him. A request to delete the diffusion has been filed.
- 2026Uzbekistan
A residence permit with a Red Notice still open
An entrepreneur who had run a business in Valencia for six years was charged with embezzlement at home after a land dispute with local officials. The Red Notice stays in place until the CCF decides.
We ran two tracks at once. For the immigration office we prepared an application for a residence permit based on settlement, explaining the notice and enclosing a copy of the CCF request. At the CCF we filed for deletion. He received his permit in spring 2026; the request is still before the Commission.
Public precedents: how to read this collection
This part is not our own cases but an open collection of public precedents that we draw on when building a defence strategy, and every entry links to its primary source: the institution’s own website, the judgment, or the publication of the organisation that documented it.
We have deliberately included refusals, open cases and cases where extradition went ahead as well as successes; a page of nothing but wins would not be credible. Past decisions in other people’s cases do not predict the outcome of yours. The collection has three parts: named cases (24), case law (13) and official reports and institutional decisions (12).
Named cases
Real people whose Red Notice, diffusion or extradition cases have been documented by Fair Trials, RSF, CPJ, OCCRP or major media. Most ended well for the person concerned; some are open, and in some extradition went ahead. Entries are ordered by the year events began; under the year is the state that made the request.
- 1999–2018China
Dolkun Isa: 19 years under a Chinese Red Notice, deleted after Fair Trials' work
President of the World Uyghur Congress. A Chinese Red Notice issued in 1999 led to his detention or exclusion in South Korea, India, the USA, Turkey and Italy. Following submissions by Fair Trials in 2017, the CCF deleted the notice in February 2018.1
Outcome: Red Notice deleted.
- 2000–2015Uzbekistan
Nadejda Atayeva: a human-rights defender's 15-year wait
Uzbek human-rights defender, a refugee in France. In 2000 she, her brother and her father were charged with embezzlement after she publicly criticised state policy on food production, and a Red Notice followed. It was lifted only in 2015, when INTERPOL accepted that the prosecution was politically motivated.2
Outcome: Red Notice removed after 15 years.
- 2002–2003Russia
Akhmed Zakayev: released for lack of evidence, then granted asylum
Former envoy of the Chechen government in exile. Detained in Copenhagen in October 2002 on a Russian request linked to the Dubrovka theatre siege and released after 34 days for lack of evidence. After a further arrest at Heathrow, the UK granted him political asylum in 2003 and has since refused his extradition.3
Outcome: Extradition refused; asylum granted.
- 2004–2006Venezuela
Patricia Poleo: 18 months under a Venezuelan Red Notice despite US asylum
Venezuelan anti-corruption journalist and critic of Hugo Chávez, accused in 2004 of involvement in the murder of a prosecutor, although the key witness later said on air that he had been paid to give false testimony. Despite her asylum in the USA, the Venezuelan Red Notice remained for 18 months before INTERPOL found it politically motivated.4
Outcome: Red Notice found political.
- 2006–2015Azerbaijan
Azer Samadov: notice deleted after nine years
Former Azerbaijani opposition activist who fled to Georgia in 2003 after threats from the security services for supporting an opposition candidate. Detained in Georgia in 2006 on an Azerbaijani request; the Red Notice was deleted in September 2015, after he had become a Dutch citizen, under INTERPOL's refugee policy.5
Outcome: Red Notice deleted.
- 2011–2012Indonesia
Benny Wenda: Indonesia against a West Papuan independence leader
Leader of the West Papuan independence movement, granted asylum in the UK in 2002. In 2011 Indonesia obtained a Red Notice on the same political charges he had fled. INTERPOL found the case to be "predominantly political" and withdrew the notice in 2012.6
Outcome: Red Notice withdrawn.
- 2012–2014Russia
Petr Silaev: a diffusion over a protest, deleted after Fair Trials' work
Russian environmental and anti-fascist activist, recognised as a refugee in Finland. Arrested in Spain in 2012 on a Russian diffusion for "hooliganism" after the 2010 Khimki forest protest; the Spanish court refused extradition as politically motivated. In October 2014 the CCF ordered his data deleted from INTERPOL's files.7
Outcome: Data deleted; extradition refused.
- 2013–2018Russia
Bill Browder: seven Russian attempts to obtain a Red Notice
Founder of Hermitage Capital and the driving force behind the Magnitsky sanctions laws. Between 2013 and 2018 Russia sought Red Notices and diffusions against him at least seven times, and INTERPOL refused each time. After he was briefly detained in Spain in May 2018 on a Russian alert, INTERPOL stated publicly that there was not, and never had been, a Red Notice against him.8
Outcome: Red Notice requests refused.
- 2013–2016Russia
Andrei Borodin: former Bank of Moscow head granted asylum in the UK
Accused by Russia of embezzlement connected with the bank's rescue. He left for London in 2011 and became the subject of a Red Notice in November that year. In February 2013 he was granted political asylum in the UK after presenting evidence that the charges were politically motivated; in May 2016 INTERPOL removed him from its wanted list.9
Outcome: Asylum granted; Red Notice later lifted.
- 2013–2014Turkey
Bahar Kimyongür: INTERPOL finds Turkish data non-compliant
Belgian activist of Turkish origin. From March 2006 he was the subject of a Turkish request alleging membership of a banned organisation, which led to his arrest in the Netherlands, Spain and Italy despite his acquittal by a Belgian court in 2009. The CCF found the Turkish data did not comply with INTERPOL's rules and ordered their deletion.10
Outcome: Data found non-compliant and deleted.
- 2013Cambodia
Daniel Lainé: French documentary-maker and a Cambodian Red Notice
Documentary-maker who investigated child sex tourism in Cambodia for French television. Convicted in absentia in Phnom Penh of "procuring", which led to a Red Notice. After a campaign by Reporters Without Borders and pressure from the French government, the CCF recognised him as the victim of arbitrary prosecution and the notice was lifted in February 2013.11
Outcome: Red Notice lifted.
- 2016–2020Russia, at Kazakhstan's instigation
Mukhtar Ablyazov: French court finds the request politically motivated
Kazakh opposition politician and former banker. In December 2016 France's Conseil d'État annulled the decree for his extradition to Russia, finding that the request was politically motivated and driven by Kazakhstan. He was granted refugee status in France in 2020.12
Outcome: Extradition annulled.
- 2016–2018USA / Russia
Yevgeniy Nikulin: competing US and Russian requests; sent to the USA
Russian hacker arrested in Prague in October 2016 on two requests: from the USA (the LinkedIn and Dropbox intrusions) and from Russia (an alleged WebMoney theft). The Czech courts allowed extradition on both; in March 2018 the US request was given priority and he was surrendered there. Included as a case where the system worked on the merits of the charges.13
Outcome: Extradited.
- 2016Russia
Mikhail Khodorkovsky: INTERPOL refuses Russia's request in a Yukos-related case
Former head of Yukos and a prominent Kremlin critic. In February 2016 INTERPOL declined to publish a notice at Russia's request, regarding it as politically motivated, consistent with its wider position on Yukos-related cases.14
Outcome: Red Notice request refused.
- c. 2017Kazakhstan / Russia / Ukraine
Ablyazov's associates: three people whose data INTERPOL deleted
Tatiana Paraskevich, Alexander Pavlov and Muratbek Ketebayev, all connected with Mukhtar Ablyazov. The CCF confirmed that their data had been deleted from INTERPOL's files, recognising the political background of the requests from Kazakhstan, Russia and Ukraine.15
Outcome: Data deleted by the CCF.
- 2017–2024USA / France / Russia
Alexander Vinnik: three competing requests, a case taken to judgment
Operator of the BTC-e crypto exchange, arrested in Greece in 2017 on a US money-laundering request, with competing requests from Russia and France. Surrendered to France in January 2020, where he was convicted, then to the USA in August 2022, where he pleaded guilty in 2024. Another case pursued to the end on its merits.16
Outcome: Extradited.
- 2017Azerbaijan
Fikret Huseynli: journalist detained in Kyiv on an Azerbaijani Red Notice
Journalist of Azerbaijani origin living in exile in the Netherlands. On 14 October 2017 he was detained at Boryspil airport in Kyiv as he was about to fly to Düsseldorf, on a Red Notice requested by Azerbaijan; a court ordered him held while the matter was examined. Reporters Without Borders called for his release. Included to show that not every entry here ends in a clear victory.17
Outcome: Detained in 2017; final outcome not covered by the cited source.
- 2018Tajikistan
Muhiddin Kabiri: leader of a banned Tajik party removed from the wanted list
Head of the Islamic Renaissance Party of Tajikistan, living in exile. In March 2018 he announced that INTERPOL had removed him from its wanted list, recognising the political motivation of Dushanbe's request.18
Outcome: Red Notice removed.
- 2018Turkey
Can Dündar: INTERPOL refuses Turkey over a former Cumhuriyet editor
Former editor-in-chief of Cumhuriyet, living in exile. In April 2018 Turkey sought a Red Notice over a 2015 report on arms shipments to Syria; after the Committee to Protect Journalists publicly urged INTERPOL to reject the politically motivated request, INTERPOL declined to issue it.19
Outcome: Red Notice request refused.
- 2022US Court of Appeals, Ninth Circuit
González-Castillo: the US Ninth Circuit on the weight of a Red Notice
A Salvadoran asylum applicant; the only evidence the US authorities offered that he had committed a "serious non-political crime" was the Red Notice itself. Fair Trials filed an amicus brief, and the Ninth Circuit held that a Red Notice alone cannot establish probable cause that a crime was committed.20
Outcome: Court rejects a Red Notice as proof of guilt.
- 2024–2025Japan
Paul Watson: released after five months in Greenland
Founder of Sea Shepherd, detained in Nuuk, Greenland, in July 2024 on a Japanese Red Notice relating to events in the Antarctic in 2010. Denmark refused Japan's extradition request and he was released in December 2024. In July 2025 his lawyer announced that the CCF had deleted the Red Notice.21
Outcome: Red Notice deleted.
- 2025Kyrgyzstan
Rinat Tukhvatshin: INTERPOL refuses Kyrgyzstan over an independent outlet
Co-founder of the independent Kyrgyz outlet Kloop, living in exile. After a Kyrgyz court declared him and colleagues “extremists” on 27 October 2025, Kyrgyzstan requested a Red Notice; INTERPOL refused, citing the prohibition on activities of a political character.22
Outcome: Red Notice request refused.
- 2025Poland
Marcin Romanowski: INTERPOL declines Poland's request
Former Polish deputy justice minister (Law and Justice party) who went to Hungary and was granted asylum there in December 2024, amid charges concerning the Justice Fund. INTERPOL declined to publish a notice, citing confidentiality and giving no reasons. We include it deliberately as a contested case: some see accountability being frustrated, others political protection of an ally by Hungary.23
Outcome: Request refused (politically contested case).
- open caseEl Salvador
Diego Andrés Rosa Rosales: photojournalist detained in Seville while claiming asylum
Salvadoran photojournalist who has worked with The Guardian and El País. He was detained at a police station in Seville at the moment he applied for international protection, on a Red Notice requested by El Salvador. Reporters Without Borders publicly urged Spain to respect his right to protection. The case is open.24
Outcome: Open case: protection requested.
Case law
Judgments of the European Court of Human Rights, the Court of Justice of the EU and senior national courts, all published in HUDOC, EUR-Lex or official court databases. Some went against the applicants: they show where the line is drawn.
- Soering v. United KingdomEuropean Court of Human Rights, 1989
the death-row phenomenon. A German national faced extradition to Virginia on a charge carrying the death penalty. The Court held for the first time that extradition exposing a person to the "death row phenomenon" would breach Article 3, and that the extraditing state is responsible for foreseeable consequences after the person crosses the border.25
Outcome: Extradition blocked.
- WS (C-505/19)Court of Justice of the EU, 2021
a Red Notice against a person whose case is closed. A German national was the subject of a US Red Notice for bribery, although German prosecutors had finally discontinued proceedings for the same acts after he paid a sum of money. The Court of Justice held that the ne bis in idem principle may prevent Schengen states from arresting a person on a Red Notice where a final decision on the same acts has been taken in an EU or Schengen state.26
Outcome: Ne bis in idem applied to a Red Notice.
- Othman (Abu Qatada) v. United KingdomEuropean Court of Human Rights, 2012
a flagrant denial of justice. The UK sought to deport a Jordanian preacher for retrial in Jordan on evidence likely obtained by torturing third parties. The Court found for the first time that removal would breach Article 6 because of a real risk of a flagrant denial of justice.27
Outcome: Deportation blocked.
- Trabelsi v. BelgiumEuropean Court of Human Rights, 2014
life without a prospect of review. A Tunisian national convicted of terrorism in Belgium was extradited to the USA on further charges. The Court held that the risk of an irreducible life sentence breached Article 3, and that Belgium also breached Article 34 by extraditing him despite an interim measure indicating that it should not.28
Outcome: Violation found after extradition.
- Chahal v. United KingdomEuropean Court of Human Rights, 1996
Article 3 cannot be balanced away. The UK sought to deport a Sikh separatist activist to India on national-security grounds. The Court held that the prohibition of torture and inhuman treatment under Article 3 is absolute and cannot be weighed against national security or the person's conduct.29
Outcome: Deportation blocked.
- Saadi v. ItalyECtHR, Grand Chamber, 2008
the Grand Chamber confirms Chahal. A Tunisian national convicted in Italy of terrorism-related offences faced deportation to Tunisia. Italy and the UK, as a third party, argued for a more flexible standard in terrorism cases; the Grand Chamber unanimously confirmed that Article 3 protection is absolute, whatever the person's conduct or the threat they pose.30
Outcome: Deportation blocked even in a terrorism case.
- Aranyosi and CăldăraruCourt of Justice of the EU, 2016
prison conditions and the European Arrest Warrant. Hungarian and Romanian nationals resisted surrender under European Arrest Warrants, citing degrading prison conditions. The Court of Justice held that execution must be postponed, and may be refused, where there is a real risk of inhuman treatment because of detention conditions in the issuing state.31
Outcome: Execution of EAW postponed.
- PetruhhinCourt of Justice of the EU, 2016
protecting EU citizens from extradition to third countries. An Estonian national living in Latvia faced a Russian extradition request; Latvian law protected only its own nationals from extradition. The Court of Justice held that the requested state must inform the person's state of nationality and allow it to seek surrender under a European Arrest Warrant before extraditing to a third country.32
Outcome: Extradition to a third country restricted.
- Harkins and Edwards v. United KingdomEuropean Court of Human Rights, 2012
a life sentence is not in itself a violation. Two men challenged extradition from the UK to the USA on murder charges, citing the risk of life imprisonment without parole. The Court found no breach of Article 3: a discretionary life sentence imposed after considering all the circumstances was not grossly disproportionate.33
Outcome: Extradition permitted.
- Babar Ahmad and Others v. United KingdomEuropean Court of Human Rights, 2012
harsher conditions are not enough. Six terrorism suspects challenged extradition from the UK to the USA, citing conditions at ADX Florence and long sentences without parole. The Court found no breach of Article 3, noting that conditions harsher than in Europe do not in themselves bar extradition.34
Outcome: Extradition permitted.
- USA v. AssangeUnited Kingdom, 2021
two outcomes in one case. The USA sought Julian Assange's extradition on charges including offences under the Espionage Act. In January 2021 Westminster Magistrates' Court refused extradition because of the risk of suicide in harsh US pre-trial conditions. After the USA gave assurances on conditions, the High Court allowed the appeal in December 2021. Included deliberately as a case with different outcomes at different stages.35
Outcome: Refused at first instance, allowed on appeal.
- PuigdemontGermany, 2018
a German court refuses surrender for rebellion. Spain issued a European Arrest Warrant for the former Catalan president Carles Puigdemont, including a charge of rebellion, after his arrest in Germany. The Higher Regional Court of Schleswig-Holstein held surrender on that charge inadmissible because the conduct did not meet the German dual-criminality requirement (it did not amount to high treason under German law); Spain later withdrew the warrant.36
Outcome: Surrender on the rebellion charge refused.
- Roman PolanskiSwitzerland, 2010
Switzerland refuses the USA on procedural grounds. The USA sought the director's extradition for sentencing in a long-standing case involving a minor. The Swiss authorities refused, citing the US failure to provide confidential records on whether his earlier detention for psychiatric evaluation had counted towards his sentence; he was released after about nine months in custody and house arrest.37
Outcome: Extradition refused.
Official statistics and institutional decisions
Figures taken directly from the published reports of the CCF, the EDPS, Eurojust, the US State Department and Freedom House: their numbers, not our estimates.
CCF, 2022interpol.int
CCF report for 2022: more requests, and only 26% of data found compliant
The CCF received 2,258 requests in 2022 (1,643 in 2021), of which 1,597 were admissible. Of the 470 admissible complaints closed after a decision on compliance, the CCF found the data compliant with INTERPOL's rules in 124 cases (about 26%); in 271 cases it found them non-compliant after examination, and in 75 more it ordered deletion because the source NCB failed to cooperate.38
CCF, 2023interpol.int
CCF report for 2023: a record 2,793 requests; 32% of data found compliant
Requests rose to 2,793, 70% more than in 2021 and 24% more than in 2022. In the 500 complaints decided on compliance, the CCF found the data compliant in 158 cases (32%) and non-compliant in 342 (68%). Some 30% of access requests took seven to eight months on average, against a statutory limit of four.39
CCF, 2024interpol.int
CCF report for 2024: 2,586 admissible requests; compliance level 40%
The CCF received 2,586 new admissible requests in 2024, the highest number it has recorded. Of the 539 deletion requests it decided, the data were found compliant in 217 cases, giving a compliance level of 40% (up from 32% in 2023 and 26% in 2022), and non-compliant in 322. In other words, the share of complaints in which the data survived review has risen. 30% of deletion requests exceeded the nine-month statutory limit.40
EDPS, 2022edps.europa.eu
EDPS v. Europol: an order to erase data, and a court challenge
On 3 January 2022 the European Data Protection Supervisor ordered Europol to erase personal data of people with no established link to criminal activity, setting deadlines for categorisation and deletion. When amendments to the Europol Regulation retroactively legalised the earlier practice, the EDPS brought an action before the Court of Justice in September 2022 seeking annulment of the transitional provisions.41
Eurojust, 2024eurojust.europa.eu
Ukraine joint investigation team extends its work to torture and filtration
On 11 September 2024 the members of the Eurojust-supported joint investigation team into core international crimes in Ukraine agreed to extend their work to torture, ill-treatment and the "filtration" of Ukrainian civilians, after more than two and a half years of evidence-gathering.42
Eurojust, 2024eurojust.europa.eu
Joint team disrupts a sabotage network using self-igniting parcels
A Eurojust-supported team involving Germany, Lithuania, the Netherlands, Poland and the UK disrupted an operation that sent self-igniting parcels through European logistics hubs, identifying 22 suspects in Lithuania and Poland allegedly acting for Russian military intelligence.43
Eurojust, 2023–2024eurojust.europa.eu
Ireland's first labour-trafficking convictions, with Eurojust support
A joint investigation supported by Eurojust led to Ireland's first convictions for labour trafficking, an example of the practical value of cross-border coordination in exploitation cases that national authorities had struggled to bring to court alone.44
Eurojust, 2024eurojust.europa.eu
Eurojust annual report 2024: more than 1,200 arrests
According to its annual report for 2024, Eurojust supported 25% more joint investigation teams than the year before, contributing to the arrest of more than 1,200 suspects and the seizure or freezing of assets worth over EUR 1 billion.45
Freedom House, 2021–2026freedomhouse.org
Freedom House: tracking transnational repression since 2014
Freedom House published the first global study of transnational repression in February 2021 and has updated its data since, documenting the misuse of INTERPOL Red Notices and diffusions as one tool used against exiled dissidents. Its April 2026 update records 1,375 direct, physical incidents by 54 governments in 107 host countries between 2014 and 2025.46
US State Department, 2022state.gov
US State Department 2022 report on misuse of Red Notices
A report required by the TRAP Act provisions of the US defence budget for fiscal year 2022 assesses the misuse of INTERPOL Red Notices for political persecution, naming Russia, Azerbaijan, Kazakhstan, Tajikistan and Turkey among frequent sources of abusive requests, and restates the US position that a Red Notice alone is not a sufficient basis for extradition.47
US State Department, 2023, published 2024state.gov
2023 Country Reports add a section on transnational repression
For the first time, the annual human-rights reports included a dedicated section on transnational repression (section 1.f), recording credible reports of misuse of INTERPOL mechanisms for politically motivated purposes by countries including Belarus, China, Russia, Turkey and Venezuela.48
INTERPOL, 2025interpol.int
Silver Notice: a pilot for tracing assets, not people
On 10 January 2025 INTERPOL published the first Silver Notice, requested by Italy, to trace criminal assets. The pilot involves 52 countries and territories, which can collectively request up to 500 Silver Notices and Silver Diffusions. The notice seeks information about assets; any seizure or confiscation remains a matter for national law.49
Why the stories are anonymised and there are no reviews
We do not publish client reviews. People come to us when they are sought through INTERPOL, face extradition or are claiming asylum, and the very fact that they have done so is confidential.
- An enquiry is itself a sensitive fact. Even an anonymised story about a search, a detention or an asylum claim can make a person identifiable — including to the state pursuing them. That is why in our stories we change names, cities, dates and details.
- Anonymised only. The stories contain nothing that could identify a client or their relatives.
- Not a promise of outcome. Each case turns on its own facts: someone else’s story does not predict how yours will end.
What to ask any lawyer at the first consultation
- What their professional status is, where they are admitted to practise and who will represent you in court in the country of detention.
- Which specific grounds for deletion they see in your case — Article 3 of the INTERPOL Constitution, a lack of legal safeguards, inaccurate data — and which documents support them.
- What time limits the CCF Statute sets — 4 months for an access request and 9 months for a deletion request, from admissibility — and what is outside their control.
- What they cannot promise. A conscientious lawyer does not guarantee an outcome: the decisions belong to the CCF, the courts and state authorities.
Sources
Each entry links to its primary source; below is a consolidated list in order of mention.
- 1Fair Trials: Dolkun Isa: 19 years under a Chinese Red Notice, deleted after Fair Trials' workfairtrials.org
- 2Fair Trials: Nadejda Atayeva: a human-rights defender's 15-year waitfairtrials.org
- 3The Moscow Times: Akhmed Zakayev: released for lack of evidence, then granted asylumthemoscowtimes.com
- 4Fair Trials: Patricia Poleo: 18 months under a Venezuelan Red Notice despite US asylumfairtrials.org
- 5Fair Trials: Azer Samadov: notice deleted after nine yearsfairtrials.org
- 6Fair Trials: Benny Wenda: Indonesia against a West Papuan independence leaderfairtrials.org
- 7Fair Trials: Petr Silaev: a diffusion over a protest, deleted after Fair Trials' workfairtrials.org
- 8Fortune: Bill Browder: seven Russian attempts to obtain a Red Noticefortune.com
- 9IBTimes UK: Andrei Borodin: former Bank of Moscow head granted asylum in the UKibtimes.co.uk
- 10Fair Trials: Bahar Kimyongür: INTERPOL finds Turkish data non-compliantfairtrials.org
- 11Reporters Without Borders: Daniel Lainé: French documentary-maker and a Cambodian Red Noticersf.org
- 12Open Dialogue Foundation: Mukhtar Ablyazov: French court finds the request politically motivateden.odfoundation.eu
- 13RFE/RL: Yevgeniy Nikulin: competing US and Russian requests; sent to the USArferl.org
- 14Center for Public Integrity: Mikhail Khodorkovsky: INTERPOL refuses Russia's request in a Yukos-related casepublicintegrity.org
- 15Open Dialogue Foundation: Ablyazov's associates: three people whose data INTERPOL deleteden.odfoundation.eu
- 16RFE/RL: Alexander Vinnik: three competing requests, a case taken to judgmentrferl.org
- 17Reporters Without Borders: Fikret Huseynli: journalist detained in Kyiv on an Azerbaijani Red Noticersf.org
- 18RFE/RL: Muhiddin Kabiri: leader of a banned Tajik party removed from the wanted listrferl.org
- 19Committee to Protect Journalists: Can Dündar: INTERPOL refuses Turkey over a former Cumhuriyet editorcpj.org
- 20Fair Trials: González-Castillo: the US Ninth Circuit on the weight of a Red Noticefairtrials.org
- 21Al Jazeera: Paul Watson: released after five months in Greenlandaljazeera.com
- 22OCCRP: Rinat Tukhvatshin: INTERPOL refuses Kyrgyzstan over an independent outletoccrp.org
- 23Notes from Poland: Marcin Romanowski: INTERPOL declines Poland's requestnotesfrompoland.com
- 24Reporters Without Borders: Diego Andrés Rosa Rosales: photojournalist detained in Seville while claiming asylumrsf.org
- 25HUDOC: Soering v. United Kingdom: the death-row phenomenonhudoc.echr.coe.int
- 26EUR-Lex: WS (C-505/19): a Red Notice against a person whose case is closedeur-lex.europa.eu
- 27HUDOC: Othman (Abu Qatada) v. United Kingdom: a flagrant denial of justicehudoc.echr.coe.int
- 28HUDOC: Trabelsi v. Belgium: life without a prospect of reviewhudoc.echr.coe.int
- 29HUDOC: Chahal v. United Kingdom: Article 3 cannot be balanced awayhudoc.echr.coe.int
- 30HUDOC: Saadi v. Italy: the Grand Chamber confirms Chahalhudoc.echr.coe.int
- 31EUR-Lex: Aranyosi and Căldăraru: prison conditions and the European Arrest Warranteur-lex.europa.eu
- 32EUR-Lex: Petruhhin: protecting EU citizens from extradition to third countrieseur-lex.europa.eu
- 33HUDOC: Harkins and Edwards v. United Kingdom: a life sentence is not in itself a violationhudoc.echr.coe.int
- 34HUDOC: Babar Ahmad and Others v. United Kingdom: harsher conditions are not enoughhudoc.echr.coe.int
- 35Judiciary of England and Wales: USA v. Assange: two outcomes in one casejudiciary.uk
- 36eucrim: Puigdemont: a German court refuses surrender for rebellioneucrim.eu
- 37CNN: Roman Polanski: Switzerland refuses the USA on procedural groundscnn.com
- 38INTERPOL CCF Annual Report 2022: CCF report for 2022: more requests, and only 26% of data found compliantinterpol.int
- 39INTERPOL CCF Annual Report 2023: CCF report for 2023: a record 2,793 requests; 32% of data found compliantinterpol.int
- 40INTERPOL CCF Annual Report 2024: CCF report for 2024: 2,586 admissible requests; compliance level 40%interpol.int
- 41European Data Protection Supervisor: EDPS v. Europol: an order to erase data, and a court challengeedps.europa.eu
- 42Eurojust: Ukraine joint investigation team extends its work to torture and filtrationeurojust.europa.eu
- 43Eurojust: Joint team disrupts a sabotage network using self-igniting parcelseurojust.europa.eu
- 44Eurojust: Ireland's first labour-trafficking convictions, with Eurojust supporteurojust.europa.eu
- 45Eurojust Annual Report 2024: Eurojust annual report 2024: more than 1,200 arrestseurojust.europa.eu
- 46Freedom House: Freedom House: tracking transnational repression since 2014freedomhouse.org
- 47U.S. Department of State: US State Department 2022 report on misuse of Red Noticesstate.gov
- 48U.S. Department of State: 2023 Country Reports add a section on transnational repressionstate.gov
- 49INTERPOL: Silver Notice: a pilot for tracing assets, not peopleinterpol.int
This page is general information about the law as at October 2026, based on publicly available sources: institutional websites, court databases, and publications of human-rights organisations and the media. Public precedents are not INTERPOLSTOP cases and not a guarantee of any result in your case: past precedents, including those involving third parties, do not determine the outcome of a future case. It is not legal advice and does not create a lawyer–client relationship.
Your situation is not a line in a statisticThe first consultation is free and confidential. We first assess the risks, the evidence and the procedural position.