Independent legal practice.

Detained? +34 613 889 381 — 24/7
INTERPOLSTOP — home Русский: RU Free consultation Detained?

The European Arrest Warrant: surrender without diplomacy

Between EU Member States the European Arrest Warrant (EAW) replaced extradition with a court-to-court “surrender” procedure. What the Framework Decision actually says, how long the procedure runs, when a court must or may refuse, and how the Court of Justice protects EU citizens when a third country — Russia included — asks for them.

A judicial decision, not a request for help

“The European arrest warrant is a judicial decision issued by a Member State with a view to the arrest and surrender by another Member State of a requested person, for the purposes of conducting a criminal prosecution or executing a custodial sentence or detention order.”

Art. 1(1), Framework Decision 2002/584/JHA; source 1

Art. 1(3)duty to respect fundamental rights

Three consequences follow. Warrants are issued and executed by judicial authorities, so the political discretion of classic extradition disappears. Mutual recognition means the executing court does not re-try the evidence. And Article 1(3) preserves the duty to respect fundamental rights — the hook on which the Court of Justice has built refusals that are not written into the text (see the Aranyosi test).

Art. 2(1), 2(2)threshold and 32 categories

Article 2(1) sets the threshold: the offence must carry a maximum of at least 12 months’ imprisonment, or, for enforcing a sentence, the sentence imposed must be at least four months. For the 32 categories listed in Article 2(2), punishable by at least three years in the issuing State, double criminality is not verified.

The procedural clock: 10, 60, 30 and 10 days

The limits come from Articles 17 and 23. They run from arrest in the executing State, not from the date the warrant was issued.1

  1. Day 0

    Arrest and rights

    The person is told the content of the warrant, the right to a lawyer and an interpreter, and the option of consenting to surrender.

    Art. 11
  2. +10 d

    Decision after consent

    Where the person consents, the final decision is due within 10 days of that consent.

    Art. 17(2)
  3. +60 d

    Contested decision

    Without consent, the final decision is due within 60 days of arrest.

    Art. 17(3)
  4. +30 d

    Extension with reasons

    In specific cases a further 30 days; the issuing authority is told why. If the limits are nonetheless missed in exceptional circumstances, the executing state informs Eurojust of the reasons; repeated delays by another Member State are reported to the Council.

    Art. 17(4), 17(7)
  5. +10 d

    Physical surrender

    No later than 10 days after the final decision; a new date is set if circumstances beyond control intervene.

    Art. 23(2)–(3)

CJEU, C-237/15 PPULanigan, 16.07.2015

If the deadlines are missedExpiry of the Article 17 limits does not release the court from its duty to decide, and does not in itself require release from custody. Detention remains lawful only while its overall length is not excessive, which the court must assess concretely, looking at how diligently the authorities acted; if the person is released, measures against absconding follow.3 In practice: a missed 60- or 90-day deadline is an argument about custody, not the end of the case.

Directive 2013/48/EU, Art. 10a lawyer in both States

Representation runs on both sides of the border. Directive 2013/48/EU entitles a person arrested on an EAW to appoint a lawyer in the issuing State to assist the lawyer in the executing State.8 In politically charged cases that second lawyer is often where the evidence about the prosecution actually comes from.

Grounds for refusal: Articles 3, 4 and 4a

The list is closed. “Political offence” is not a stand-alone ground: recital 12 allows refusal where objective elements show the warrant was issued to prosecute or punish someone because of sex, race, religion, ethnic origin, nationality, language, political opinions or sexual orientation — which has to be proved with facts, not with a general view of the issuing State.

The court must refuse

Art. 3 — mandatory
  • Amnesty in the executing State, where it had jurisdiction over the offence.
  • Ne bis in idem: a final judgment in a Member State for the same acts, where the sentence has been served, is being served or can no longer be executed.
  • Age: the person cannot be held criminally responsible under the executing State’s law because of age.

The court may refuse

Art. 4 — optional
  • No double criminality (outside the 32 categories).
  • The person is already being prosecuted in the executing State for the same act.
  • Prosecution there was declined or halted, or a final judgment exists in another Member State.
  • Time-bar under the executing State’s law, where it had jurisdiction.
  • A final judgment for the same acts in a third country.
  • Sentence-enforcement warrant against a national or resident whom the executing State undertakes to imprison itself.
  • Territoriality: the offence is regarded as committed (wholly or partly) in the executing State; or it was committed outside the issuing State and the executing State’s law would not allow prosecution for such an offence committed outside its territory.

Trials in absence

Art. 4a — in absentia

The court may refuse where the person was absent from trial unless he or she:

  • was summoned in person or otherwise actually knew of the date, place and possibility of a judgment in absence;
  • knew of the trial and instructed a lawyer who did defend him or her;
  • was served with the decision, told of the right to a retrial, and did not use it;
  • was not served, but will be immediately after surrender together with the right to a retrial.

FD 2009/299/JHAinserted Art. 4a

Article 4a was inserted by Framework Decision 2009/299/JHA.2 For Russian and other CIS nationals convicted in absentia in an EU State, this is the main safeguard in the text itself. How ne bis in idem and limitation periods play out in INTERPOL cases is covered in a separate analysis.

The Aranyosi and Căldăraru test: two steps, not a slogan

In its judgment of 5 April 2016 (C-404/15 and C-659/15 PPU) the Court of Justice held that a real risk of inhuman treatment through detention conditions blocks surrender — but only after a two-stage examination.4

The Aranyosi and Căldăraru two-step test Step 1: objective, reliable, specific and properly updated information on systemic deficiencies. Step 2: individual assessment for the person concerned, with an urgent request for information to the issuing State. Then: if the risk is discounted, surrender may proceed; if it persists, postponement and possibly ending the procedure. Step 1 — the system Objective, reliable,specific, updated evidenceof systemic deficiencies ECtHR judgments, CoE and UN reports Step 2 — the person Substantial grounds that this individualwill in fact be exposed to the risk? urgent request for informationto the issuing State Risk discountedsurrender may proceed Risk persistspostponement, then possiblyending the procedure
Diagram: our summary of CJEU press release No 36/16.4

CJEU, C-216/18 PPULM, 2018

Pointing at “bad prisons” or “captured courts” is not enough; without the second step the court must surrender. In 2018 (C-216/18 PPU, LM) the Court applied the same logic to the right to a fair trial where judicial independence is in doubt.6 Evidence therefore has two layers: sources on the system, and documents about this case, this remand centre, this court.

Petruhhin: when Russia asks for an EU citizen

Case C-182/15 (6 September 2016) began with an INTERPOL Red Notice: an Estonian national was arrested in Latvia on a priority Red Notice and Russia then requested his extradition.5 The sequence the Court laid down now governs requests from any third country.

  1. Inform the State of nationality

    Of all the factual and legal elements of the request.

  2. Give it the chance to issue its own EAW

    Where its law allows it to prosecute nationals for offences abroad, within a reasonable time.

  3. Prefer the EAW to extradition

    If a warrant is issued, surrender within the EU takes priority.

  4. Check Article 19 of the Charter in every case

    No removal to a State where there is a serious risk of the death penalty, torture or inhuman treatment, assessed on objective, reliable, specific and updated information.

CJEU, C-897/19 PPURuska Federacija, 02.04.2020

Russia asked Croatia to extradite an Icelandic national to whom Iceland had granted asylum. The Court extended Petruhhin to nationals of European Free Trade Association (EFTA) States party to the European Economic Area (EEA) Agreement and held that a grant of asylum is particularly substantial evidence in the Article 19 assessment — especially where it rests on the very prosecution behind the extradition request.6

The limitThe mechanism protects EU (and EEA/EFTA) citizens who have exercised free movement. A Russian national without EU citizenship cannot rely on it; national extradition law, the European Convention on Human Rights (ECHR) and, where available, ECtHR Rule 39 and a complaint to the UN Committee against Torture remain.

EAW, SIS and INTERPOL: three tools that tend to arrive together

An EAW is normally entered straight into the Schengen Information System as an alert for arrest for surrender or extradition (Article 26 of Regulation (EU) 2018/1862),7 and mirrored through INTERPOL when the search extends beyond the EU. Removing one layer leaves the other two in place.

European Arrest WarrantSIS alert (Art. 26, Reg. 2018/1862)INTERPOL Red Notice
What it isA court decision ordering arrest and surrenderAn entry in the shared Schengen database, seen at checksAn international request to locate and provisionally arrest
Issued byA judicial authority of an EU StateA SIS State (on the basis of the warrant)INTERPOL’s General Secretariat at the request of a National Central Bureau (NCB)
Binding forceMust be executed unless a ground for refusal appliesRequires action (arrest) by SIS StatesNot a warrant; each country decides for itself
Territory27 EU StatesStates connected to SIS196 INTERPOL member countries
Where to challengeCourts of the issuing and executing StatesNational authorities and data-protection supervisorsThe Commission for the Control of INTERPOL’s Files (CCF)

For a fuller comparison see “SIS II versus the Red Notice”; for removal from the Schengen system, see our SIS service page.

Where the EAW applies — and its look-alikes

AreaMechanismWhat matters
27 EU Member StatesEAW under Framework Decision 2002/584/JHACommon grounds for refusal; CJEU oversight through preliminary references
Norway and IcelandA separate EU surrender agreement (OJ L 292, 21.10.2006)Close to the EAW but a distinct treaty, read alongside it by the CJEU9
United KingdomPost-Brexit surrender arrangements under the EU–UK Trade and Cooperation AgreementSee “Extradition from the UK: Part 2, the EAW and Brexit”
Third countries (Russia, CIS, UAE…)Classic extradition under treaties and national lawPetruhhin for EU citizens; for everyone else, national safeguards, the ECHR and UN mechanisms. See the extradition section

What this page cannot promise

  • Refusal is the exception. Most warrants are executed; the system rests on mutual trust. We do not quote a “refusal rate” because no official statistics exist for politically sensitive cases.
  • Deleting a Red Notice does not cancel an EAW. CCF deletion leaves a live warrant and SIS alert untouched — they are separate legal regimes, each challenged in its own forum.
  • Systemic arguments need individual evidence. Without it the argument will fail; Aranyosi says so expressly.
  • Deadlines do not lapse in the person’s favour. Missing Article 17 limits affects custody, not the outcome (Lanigan).

Primary sources

  1. 1Council Framework Decision 2002/584/JHA on the European arrest warrant (consolidated) — Arts 1–4a, 11, 17, 23; recital 12eur-lex.europa.eu
  2. 2Council Framework Decision 2009/299/JHA (decisions in absentia) — inserting Art. 4aeur-lex.europa.eu
  3. 3CJEU press release No 91/15: C-237/15 PPU Lanigan, 16.07.2015curia.europa.eu
  4. 4CJEU press release No 36/16: C-404/15 and C-659/15 PPU Aranyosi and Căldăraru, 05.04.2016curia.europa.eu
  5. 5CJEU press release No 84/16: C-182/15 Petruhhin, 06.09.2016curia.europa.eu
  6. 6Eurojust, Case-law by the Court of Justice of the EU on the European Arrest Warrant, updated 11.11.2025 — LM, Ruska Federacija, Article 17 and extradition of EU citizenseurojust.europa.eu
  7. 7Regulation (EU) 2018/1862 on SIS in police and judicial cooperation in criminal matters — Art. 26eur-lex.europa.eu
  8. 8Directive 2013/48/EU on the right of access to a lawyer — Art. 10eur-lex.europa.eu
  9. 9Agreement between the EU and Iceland and Norway on the surrender procedure, OJ L 292, 21.10.2006eur-lex.europa.eu

This page is general information, not legal advice. Rules and practice change; whether any of this applies to you can only be assessed after reviewing your documents.