Independent legal practice.

Detained? +34 613 889 381 — 24/7
INTERPOLSTOP — home Русский: RU Free consultation Detained?

UK extradition after Brexit: how Part 2 differs from the EAW

Since Brexit, surrender to the EU runs under the Trade and Cooperation Agreement (TCA) — with safeguards the European Arrest Warrant never had. Requests from Russia and the CIS live in a different part of the law altogether: Part 2, with the Home Secretary at the start and at the end.

Published . Reading time 10 minutes.

Many assume Brexit made UK extradition law harsher and more closed. For EU cases the picture is subtler: the TCA keeps a fast judicial procedure but adds safeguards the EAW deliberately excluded. Anyone concerned with Russian or other post-Soviet requests must look at a different part of the Act. A country overview is in the guide “Extradition from the UK”.

The end of the EAW — and what replaced it

FD 2002/584/JHAof 13.06.2002

Until 31 December 2020 the UK took part in the European Arrest Warrant system: judicial authorities requested surrender on a standard warrant, bypassing classic inter-state extradition.

TCA, Part Three, Title VIIsigned 30.12.2020

When the transition period ended, the EAW ceased to apply to the UK. It was replaced by the surrender arrangements in the EU–UK Trade and Cooperation Agreement.1 Domestically they are implemented through Part 1 of the Extradition Act 2003, so EU requests are still “Part 1 cases”, but their basis is now an international agreement rather than EU membership.

The new system largely mirrors the old one: judicial rather than diplomatic requests, statutory time limits, a streamlined procedure.2 But there are important differences, agreed precisely because the UK is no longer bound by EU law.

New refusal options that never existed under the EAW

EAW (to 2021)TCA (from 2021)
Political offenceNo refusal: mutual recognitionArt. 602: a party may notify that the bar on refusal applies only to certain offences (e.g. terrorism), reopening the exception for the rest
Own nationalsSurrendered: a key achievement of the systemArt. 603: a state may notify that it will not surrender its nationals, or only on conditions
ProportionalityNo express requirementArt. 597: surrender must be necessary and proportionate, considering seriousness, likely penalty and less coercive alternatives
OversightCourt of Justice of the EUSpecialised Committee on Law Enforcement and Judicial Cooperation; the CJEU has no jurisdiction

According to commentators, the UK has made no Article 602 notification, so the political offence exception applies only where the EU state concerned has introduced it. UK courts treat proportionality as carrying new weight compared with the Framework Decision.

EU surrender remains fast, but the requested side now has more grounds to refuse than under the EAW.

The other half of the Act: Part 2 and the world beyond the EU

Extradition Act 2003, Part 2legislation.gov.uk

Russian, Kazakh, Uzbek and most other post-Soviet requests never had anything to do with the EAW. They are dealt with under Part 2 of the Extradition Act 2003, which governs “category 2 territories” — non-EU states with which the UK has extradition relations.3 Here the Home Secretary decides twice — at the start and at the end; Part 1 cases have no executive stage at all.4

Decision 1 — entry

Home Secretary

s.70
  • Whether to issue a certificate sending the request to court.
  • May refuse for refugees or those protected under ECHR Arts. 2–3 — s.70(2).
Decision 2 — court

Westminster Magistrates’ Court

s.81, s.87
  • Extradition hearing: can extradition proceed.
  • Extraneous considerations, human rights.
Decision 3 — exit

Home Secretary

s.93 ff.
  • Whether to order extradition.
  • On a limited set of grounds reserved to the executive.

Mishcon de Reya, 2022commentary

Prima facie evidence — or none. Some category 2 territories must supply evidence sufficient to make a case to answer; others are exempt. Russia is among the exempt: the Act does not require Russian requests to show a prima facie case.5 That makes a Russian request procedurally easier to bring — although, for quite another reason, its prospects are very poor in practice.

What the Act says — and does not say — about political cases

Extradition Act 1870, s.3exception not carried into the 2003 Act

The 2003 Act has no “political offence” exception as such. UK law once had one: section 3 of the Extradition Act 1870 allowed courts to refuse requests for offences of a political character — but it was not carried into the 2003 Act.7

s.81extraneous considerations

That does not leave politically motivated requests unchecked. Section 81 bars extradition to a category 2 territory if the request, though framed as one for an extradition offence, is in fact made to prosecute or punish the person on account of race, religion, nationality, gender, sexual orientation or political opinions — or if for those reasons the person might be prejudiced at trial, punished or detained. The burden is on the defence; a bare assertion of political motive is not enough.

s.87; ECHR Art. 3Human Rights Act 1998

The strongest defence in Russian cases has been the human-rights bar: the judge must decide whether extradition is compatible with the person’s Convention rights. On that basis UK courts have found that extradition to Russia creates a real risk of inhuman or degrading treatment in Russian detention.6 In Shmatko (2018) the High Court held that Russian assurances cannot be relied upon without independent monitoring, and no extraditions to Russia have been ordered since.5

The result is almost paradoxical: Russia remains a category 2 territory with a lighter evidential burden on the way in, but years of consistent Article 3 refusals on the way out make actual extradition from the UK to Russia highly unlikely.

An extra safeguard for people already protected in the UK

s.70(2)ministerial discretion before court

The Home Secretary may refuse to certify a Part 2 request if the person has been recognised as a refugee under the Refugee Convention or granted leave to enter or remain because removal would breach ECHR Article 2 or 3. It is a discretion, not absolute immunity, but it is written into the Act as a separate ground that operates before any court hearing. If you have claimed or obtained protection in the UK, see also political asylum and the guide “Asylum in the UK”.

Appeals — and why a country’s status is not set in stone

s.103, s.108two separate appeals

The judge’s decision to send the case to the Home Secretary can be appealed to the High Court (s.103), and the Home Secretary’s extradition order separately (s.108). A further appeal to the Supreme Court lies on a point of law of general public importance. Part 1 has no such two-track structure — one appeal against the court, another against the executive.

  1. 07.2020Hong Kong

    Arrangements with Hong Kong suspended indefinitely

    In response to the national security law — a precedent showing relations can be suspended by executive decision.

  2. after 02.2022Russia

    Calls to remove Russia from the list

    Widely reported; as far as we know, no formal removal followed.

    In any live case, check the current designation order.

What it means in practice

If the request is from the EU (Part 1)

Proportionality and TCA notifications

Proportionality under Art. 597 and, where the state has notified them, the political offence and own-national exceptions. The extraneous considerations bar (s.13) and the human-rights bar (s.21) also apply.
If the request is from Russia or the CIS (Part 2)

s.81 and ECHR Article 3

No “political offence” exception; the defence rests on s.81 and above all on compatibility with the Human Rights Act 1998.

Extradition defence in the UK is handled by INTERPOLSTOP’s lawyers and advocates; before the UK courts our partners — a solicitor and barrister admitted in England and Wales — appear. If a Red Notice also exists, see the procedure before the Commission for the Control of INTERPOL’s Files (CCF).

Questions

Did Brexit give the UK a political offence exception for EU surrender requests?

Not automatically. The TCA lets each party notify that the exception will apply (Art. 602), but according to commentators the UK has made no such notification. In UK law, protection against politically motivated requests comes from the extraneous considerations bar and the human-rights bar in the Extradition Act 2003.

Is there a direct bar in UK law on extradition to Russia for political reasons?

The 2003 Act has no “political offence” exception, but s.81 bars extradition if the request is in fact aimed at persecution for political opinions or if, because of them, the person might be prejudiced at trial or punished. In addition, extradition to Russia has been refused for years under ECHR Article 3 because of prison conditions.

Sources

Basis of this article: the official texts of the TCA and the Extradition Act 2003, and independent legal analysis of UK case law on category 2 territories, including Russia.

  1. 1EU–UK Trade and Cooperation Agreement, Part Three, Title VII; Arts. 597, 602, 603eur-lex.europa.eu
  2. 26KBW — the surrender system after the EAWblog.6kbw.com
  3. 3Extradition Act 2003 — ss. 13, 21, 70, 81, 87, 93, 103, 108legislation.gov.uk
  4. 4Peters & Peters — Part 2 requestspetersandpeters.com
  5. 5Mishcon de Reya (March 2022) — the UK–Russia extradition relationship, Shmatkomishcon.com
  6. 6Bindmans — Russian extradition and ECHR Article 3 risksbindmans.com
  7. 7Arnell P., Walker C. (2024). The resurrection of the political offence exception to extradition in UK lawjournals.sagepub.com

This article is general information, not legal advice. Any case requires analysis of the applicable arrangements and country status, current case law and the facts.