Lapse of time and ne bis in idem: underrated grounds for removing a Red Notice
The WS case reached the Court of Justice nine years after the Red Notice was published — although the police of his own country considered the prosecution a repeat one from the start. Why both grounds sound simple but work in more complicated ways, and what an argument the CCF accepts looks like.
Published . Reading time 9 minutes.
The WS story
- 2010Germany
Proceedings finally discontinued
The case against German national WS was closed after he paid a sum under a procedure provided for in German criminal law.
- 2012INTERPOL
Red Notice at the request of the US
Based on a US arrest warrant — in the German court’s view, for the same acts. The Federal Criminal Police Office (BKA) itself told INTERPOL it considered ne bis in idem applicable. The notice stayed.
- 2017Wiesbaden
Action before the Wiesbaden Administrative Court
WS asked that Germany take steps to have the notice withdrawn. The case was referred to the Court of Justice.
- 12.05.2021CJEU
Grand Chamber judgment, C-505/19
Nine years after the notice was first published.1
The story is not an anomaly but a precise explanation of why ne bis in idem and lapse of time are called underrated grounds: they sound simple and persuasive, but working with them inside INTERPOL’s system is far more complicated.
What the Court of Justice actually decided
CJEU, C-505/19WS v Germany, ECLI:EU:C:2021:376
This Grand Chamber ruling is a rare case of a supranational court directly addressing how ne bis in idem interacts with a Red Notice. The Court first confirmed that the principle can apply where a case was finally closed on conditions such as payment of a sum set by the prosecutor. It then laid down two rules — contradictory at first sight, logical in substance.
Provisional arrest permitted
A police view (like the BKA’s) is not enough. Until the principle’s application is established, arrest may be needed to check and to prevent flight.Arrest and detention not permitted
Mutual trust between Schengen states and freedom of movement (Art. 21 TFEU) preclude provisional arrest or continued detention.…a State affiliated to Interpol which refrains from making such an arrest would therefore not fail to fulfil its obligations as an affiliate of that organisation.
What is needed is a final judicial decision establishing that the case on the same facts has already been disposed of. A police statement does not replace it.
Until there is such a decision, a Red Notice in the EU may lead to provisional arrest — even if the police of the person’s own country disagree. The Court added that states must provide remedies enabling such a decision to be obtained.
The second part of the ruling: what happens to the data
Directive (EU) 2016/680police data processing
The Court also addressed the fate of the personal data in the notice. Entering Red Notice data into national wanted-person databases is “processing” under Directive (EU) 2016/680, and it does not become unlawful merely because ne bis in idem may apply: processing is often needed precisely to find that out.
But once application of the principle is finally confirmed, keeping the data is no longer necessary, because the person cannot be prosecuted for the same acts. The Court said expressly that the person must be able to request deletion. If the data remain, they must carry a note that the person can no longer be prosecuted for the same acts because of ne bis in idem — a practical tool even before full deletion is achieved.
Caveat: the ruling covers the scope of EU law
CISA Art. 54; Charter Art. 50; TFEU Art. 21basis of the ruling
The ruling rests on EU law and binds EU and Schengen states in respect of decisions given in those states. Outside that system — including most jurisdictions relevant to people from the CIS — the construction does not apply automatically. But the principle itself — a final judicial decision, not a police opinion, is the reliable basis — remains a good guide for arguments before the CCF too. How surrender works inside the EU is covered in our entry on the European Arrest Warrant.
Ne bis in idem before the CCF: the same logic, a different body
Constitution Art. 2; RPD Art. 10a specific, explicit purpose of processing
The Commission for the Control of INTERPOL’s Files (CCF) checks whether keeping data complies with INTERPOL’s rules — Article 2 of the Constitution (the spirit of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights) and the requirement in Article 10 of the Rules on the Processing of Data (RPD) that processing serve a specific, explicit purpose. The logic mirrors the CJEU’s: if a person has already been finally acquitted or convicted of the same act, or has served the sentence, it is hard to see what lawful purpose a Red Notice serves.
The standard of proof is high: not a general claim of double prosecution but a documented final decision — a judgment, an acquittal, a decision to discontinue — relating to the very facts behind the Red Notice.
Lapse of time: less straightforward than it looks
If prosecution is no longer possible under the requesting country’s own law, why keep the notice? Intuitively simple — but published CCF practice shows the argument succeeds less often than applicants expect.
CCF, 107th session, 2019excerpt No. 3
An applicant argued that a court in another country had refused to extradite his alleged accomplice in the same case — partly because the limitation period had expired under that country’s law — so his own extradition would probably be refused too. The Commission disagreed: the period had expired only under one country’s law, while in the requesting country it had been suspended because the applicant evaded the proceedings; other member countries could still extradite him. The other ground for that refusal — no extradition treaty in force at the time — concerned only that country and said nothing about the notice’s compliance with the rules.2
The applicant also pointed out that the requesting country had never sought his extradition from his country of residence. The CCF accepted the explanation that this state does not extradite its own nationals, together with an assurance that extradition would be requested from any other country where he was found. The Red Notice stayed.
What a strong argument looks like
Weak argument
- The view of the requesting country’s or home country’s police
- An extradition refusal in one separate jurisdiction
- Limitation under a third country’s law
- Asking only for full deletion
Strong argument
- A final judicial decision expressly establishing ne bis in idem
- A ground that holds for all member countries, not a local one
- Limitation under the requesting country’s own law
- In parallel, a note in the data that prosecution is no longer possible, as in WS
Build the evidence in advance, not when filing the complaint: seek a final judicial decision rather than rely on correspondence with the police or a single extradition refusal. WS shows that even a well-founded position can take years — and the quality of the underlying judicial document determines whether the route exists at all.
Procedural time limits worth knowing in advance
- 4 mo
Decision on an access request
From admissibility; in 2024 only about 30% were decided in time.
CCF Statute, Art. 40 - 9 mo
Decision on a correction or deletion request
From admissibility; extendable in exceptional circumstances. Met in 70% of cases in 2024.4
CCF Statute, Art. 40 - 1 mo
Implementing a deletion decision
The General Secretariat implements it within a month of receipt, unless clarification is needed.
CCF Statute, Art. 41 - 6 mo
Application for revision
Only on newly discovered facts that could have led to a different conclusion — within six months of their discovery. Repeating earlier arguments is not revision. See revision of CCF decisions.
CCF Statute, Art. 42
Since 26 March 2026 requests are filed through the CCF’s online portal. Red Notice removal through the CCF starts from €5,000; if a diffusion exists in the same case it is challenged in parallel (diffusion removal from €5,000). The exact fee is set after the free consultation.
What no one can promise
- That the CCF will accept a ne bis in idem or limitation argument.
- That a court will issue the final decision on which such an argument rests.
- That the Commission will meet the Statute’s time limits.
Questions
Is the police view that ne bis in idem applies enough to make a Red Notice ineffective?
No. In WS v Germany (C-505/19) the CJEU held that what matters is a final judicial decision confirming that the case on the same facts has been finally disposed of. Until then, provisional arrest on a Red Notice remains permissible under EU law.
Does a refusal to extradite an accomplice in another country help remove my own Red Notice?
Usually not. In a published 2019 decision the CCF held that one country’s refusal, based partly on its own limitation rules, does not stop the Red Notice functioning elsewhere. The limitation argument is strongest when prosecution is time-barred under the law of the requesting country.
Related materials
Sources
Basis of this article: the CJEU judgment in WS (C-505/19) as summarised in the Court’s official press release, the anonymised CCF decision excerpt published by INTERPOL, the CCF Statute and the CCF’s 2024 annual report.
- 1CJEU press release No 76/21: C-505/19, WS v Bundesrepublik Deutschland, 12.05.2021 (ECLI:EU:C:2021:376)curia.europa.eu
- 2CCF anonymised Decision Excerpt No. 3, 107th session (2019)interpol.int
- 3Statute of the CCF, Arts. 40–42interpol.int
- 4CCF Annual Activity Report 2024, para. 73interpol.int
- 5INTERPOL Rules on the Processing of Data (RPD), Art. 10interpol.int
This article is general information, not legal advice. Whether a ground applies requires an analysis of the facts and national law.