SIS alert vs Red Notice: what changes for people who live in Schengen
An INTERPOL Red Notice and an alert in the Schengen Information System are two different instruments, with different reach, different consequences and different ways to challenge them. Deleting one does not delete the other.
Published , reviewed . Reading time: 11 min.
What SIS is in legal terms
Regs (EU) 2018/1860–1862since 7 March 2023
The Schengen Information System is a shared EU database for alerts on persons and objects.4 Since the renewed system went live on 7 March 2023 it rests on three regulations: 2018/1862 (police and judicial cooperation: arrest alerts, missing persons, discreet and specific checks), 2018/1861 (border checks: refusal of entry or stay for third-country nationals) and 2018/1860 (return decisions). This is EU legislation, not the internal rules of an international organisation, as with INTERPOL. Old references to “Article 95” or “Article 96” of the 1990 Schengen Convention describe a framework that no longer applies.
SIS is operated by 31 states: all 27 EU Member States and the four Schengen associated countries (Switzerland, Norway, Liechtenstein and Iceland). Ireland and Cyprus, outside the Schengen area, use it with limitations.5 INTERPOL notices reach all 196 member countries. If your concern is an entry ban rather than an arrest alert, see our guide on how to find out about a Schengen entry ban.
The key difference: who issues the alert and what follows an arrest
Art. 26 Reg. 2018/1862arrest alert
Only a participating state can enter an SIS alert. An alert for arrest is entered for surrender on the basis of a European Arrest Warrant (EAW) or for extradition — and only by the competent authorities of a state that operates SIS. A country outside the system, such as Russia, Kazakhstan or Turkey, cannot place anyone in SIS; its requests travel through INTERPOL as a Red Notice or diffusion. A Red Notice issued by Moscow will not, by itself, become an SIS arrest alert.
FD 2002/584/JHAEAW surrender
Alerts backed by a European Arrest Warrant. The EAW rests on mutual recognition of judicial decisions and applies whatever the nationality of the person sought: a Russian or Kazakh citizen living in Spain can be surrendered to Germany just as an EU citizen can. Arrest is followed by surrender with tight time limits and only limited grounds for refusal. The executing court does not re-examine the merits, and there is no “political offence” exception of the kind found in classic extradition law.
Alerts for extradition. Article 26 also allows them, for example where the person is sought by an SIS state from a state where the EAW does not apply. Classic extradition then follows: a separate decision of the courts and often the government, with broader grounds for refusal.
What matters is who is looking for you. A third-country request reaches Schengen through INTERPOL and leads to classic extradition, where the defence has real room for manoeuvre. An SIS arrest alert from an EU state normally means an EAW — faster and far harder to resist, regardless of your passport.
Comparison table
| Criterion | Red Notice (INTERPOL) | SIS alert (Schengen) |
|---|---|---|
| Legal basis | INTERPOL’s own rules (Constitution, RPD) | EU law: Regulations 2018/1862 (arrest and police alerts) and 2018/1861 (entry bans) |
| Reach | 196 member countries | 31 European states (27 EU + 4 associated) |
| Who can request it | Any member country’s NCB; published by the General Secretariat after review | Only competent authorities of a state that operates SIS |
| Duration | Maximum period set by the Executive Committee; reassessed on expiry and renewable (RPD Arts 49–50) | Arrest alerts reviewed within 5 years; kept longer only after a recorded individual assessment (Art. 53) |
| After arrest | Classic extradition in the arresting state | Usually EAW surrender; extradition where the EAW does not apply |
| Nationality | Some states refuse to extradite their own nationals | Under the EAW, not a general bar (limited safeguards for nationals and residents) |
| Where to complain | CCF | National authorities and data protection authorities; courts (Arts 67–68); supervisors coordinate under Art. 71 |
| Publicity | Some extracts published with the requesting country’s consent | Never published |
Review periods: where SIS is more transparent
A real advantage of SIS for the defence is that its review periods are written into EU legislation. Under Article 53 of Regulation 2018/1862, alerts on persons may be kept only for as long as needed to achieve their purpose, and the issuing state must review them within:
- 1 year
Discreet, inquiry and specific checks
Alerts under Article 36.
Art. 53 Reg. 2018/1862 - 3 years
Judicial procedure and unknown suspects
Alerts for a judicial procedure (Art. 34) and for unknown suspects (Art. 40).
Art. 53 - 5 years
Arrest and certain missing persons
Arrest alerts (Art. 26) and certain missing-person alerts. After a recorded individual assessment the issuing state may keep the alert longer.
Art. 53
RPD Arts 49–50INTERPOL retention and reassessment
INTERPOL works differently: data are recorded for a maximum period set by the Executive Committee and must be re-examined by the requesting bureau when that period expires. In practice a requesting country can renew a Red Notice repeatedly, and an outside challenge usually comes only from the person concerned, through the CCF.6
Art. 55 Reg. 2018/1862deletion of the alert
An SIS arrest alert is deleted when the person has been surrendered or extradited to the issuing state, when the underlying judicial decision has been revoked, or when the alert expires under Article 53.
Challenging an SIS alert: another body, another procedure
Arts 67, 68, 71 Reg. 2018/1862data subject rights and remedies
Complaints about SIS data do not go to the CCF. Article 67 gives the rights of access, rectification of inaccurate data and erasure of unlawfully stored data; Article 68 provides remedies before the courts or competent authority of any SIS state. National supervisory authorities and the European Data Protection Supervisor cooperate under Article 71 within the Coordinated Supervision Committee (CSC) of the European Data Protection Board.3
Access request
You may ask whether data about you are processed in SIS, obtain access to them, and request rectification or erasure.
Where to file
Usually in the state where you live: depending on national law, directly to the police or SIRENE bureau, or through the data protection authority (in Spain, the AEPD).7 The CSC guide sets out the procedure country by country.
Consultation and appeal
If another state entered the alert, it is consulted before the reply. If you are not satisfied, complain to the supervisory authority or go to court.
SIS is policed through EU data protection law and national courts, not by a dedicated commission inside an international organisation.
Can a Red Notice and an SIS alert coexist?
Yes, and it is not unusual. A Red Notice is global; an SIS alert is regional. They are technically independent but often linked in substance: a state that operates SIS may enter an SIS alert and also ask INTERPOL for a Red Notice to reach countries outside Europe. Deleting the Red Notice through the CCF does not delete the SIS alert; that takes a separate request.
What this means for a defence strategy
- An SIS arrest alert from an EU state usually rests on an EAW and moves faster and with fewer grounds for refusal than a Red Notice, whatever your nationality.
- A request from a non-EU state (Russia, Kazakhstan, Belarus and others) reaches you through INTERPOL; if you are arrested in a Schengen state, classic extradition follows and the defence has real procedural room.
- Checking one system does not check the other. Each is verified separately: through the CCF and through the SIS access procedure.
- SIS review periods are a procedural argument when an alert is kept without a properly recorded reassessment.
- If both are in play, parallel proceedings before the CCF and the SIS authorities are needed.
What no one can promise
- Deletion from SIS or of a Red Notice. The decisions belong to the competent authorities and independent bodies.
- That an EAW-based alert can be fought like classic extradition. Mutual recognition sharply limits the scope for review.
- That there is no alert because nothing has happened. SIS alerts are never published.
- That deleting a Red Notice changes anything in SIS. It does not oblige any Schengen state to delete an alert.
Questions
Which is more dangerous, a Red Notice or an SIS alert?
It depends on who is seeking you. An SIS arrest alert from an EU state usually rests on a European Arrest Warrant, which leads to faster surrender with fewer grounds for refusal, whatever your nationality. A request from a non-EU state reaches Europe through INTERPOL and leads to classic extradition proceedings, where the defence has more room.
Can Russia or another non-EU country put me in SIS?
No. Only the competent authorities of a state that operates SIS can enter an alert. A non-EU country uses INTERPOL channels instead: a Red Notice or a diffusion.
Where do I complain about SIS data?
Not to INTERPOL’s CCF. Requests for access, rectification or erasure go to the competent national authority or the data protection authority, usually in the state where you live. If the alert came from another state, that state is consulted. You can then complain to the supervisory authority or go to court.
Do SIS alerts expire?
They must be reviewed. An arrest alert must be reviewed within five years (Article 53 of Regulation (EU) 2018/1862) and may be kept longer only after a recorded individual assessment by the issuing state.
If the CCF deletes my Red Notice, is the SIS alert deleted too?
No. They are separate systems with separate procedures. If your data are also in SIS, a separate request through the SIS route is needed.
How many countries use SIS?
31: all 27 EU Member States and four associated countries (Switzerland, Norway, Liechtenstein and Iceland). Ireland and Cyprus, which are outside the Schengen area, use it with limitations.
Related
Sources
Based on the full texts of Regulations (EU) 2018/1861 and 2018/1862 (EUR-Lex), INTERPOL’s Rules on the Processing of Data, guidance from the EDPB’s Coordinated Supervision Committee, and information from the European Commission, eu-LISA and the AEPD. Facts current as at October 2026.
- 1Regulation (EU) 2018/1862 — SIS in police and judicial cooperation: Arts 26, 53, 55, 67, 68, 71eur-lex.europa.eu
- 2Regulation (EU) 2018/1861 — SIS in border checks: refusal-of-entry alertseur-lex.europa.eu
- 3CSC guide: exercising data subject rights in SIS, country by country (April 2023)edpb.europa.eu
- 4European Commission: What is SIS and how does it work?home-affairs.ec.europa.eu
- 5eu-LISA: countries operating SIS, status of Ireland and Cypruseulisa.europa.eu
- 6INTERPOL legal documents: RPD, Arts 49–50interpol.int
- 7AEPD: supervision of SIS in Spainaepd.es
This article is general information, not legal advice. Which rules apply depends on who issued the alert, where you live and the facts of your case.