Independent legal practice.

Detained? +34 613 889 381 — 24/7
INTERPOLSTOP — home Русский: RU Free consultation Detained?

Extradition from Israel: citizenship, dates and eight statutory bars

How Israel's Extradition Law 5714-1954 applies to Russian requests: when an Israeli passport protects you and when it does not, how the Jerusalem procedure works, and which arguments carry weight in court.

Three things that decide the outcome

Israel is not a jurisdiction where a passport ends the conversation. The 1954 Law works as three filters: is there an international basis, when did the person become Israeli, and does the charge fall under one of the eight bars in section 2B?

Legal basis

European Convention on Extradition 1957

Israeli law permits extradition only where an agreement exists (s. 2A).1 There is no bilateral treaty with Russia, but both are parties to the ECE.45
The main trap

The date of citizenship matters more than the passport

Section 1A protects only those who were Israeli citizens and residents when the offence was committed.1 A recent immigrant facing an older Russian case does not benefit.
Where to fight

Jerusalem District Court → Supreme Court → Minister

Three layers of review, each with its own arguments and deadlines (ss. 3, 13, 18).12

Citizen or not is a question of dates

The 1978 version of the rule barred extradition of Israeli citizens for offences committed after naturalisation altogether. After the Sheinbein affair in 1999, when a divided Supreme Court refused a US request, the provision was rewritten.10

If a person committed an extradition offence and, when it was committed, was an Israeli citizen and an Israeli resident, he shall not be extradited unless both conditions are met: the request is for the purpose of trial in the requesting state, and that state has undertaken in advance to return him to Israel to serve any prison sentence.

s. 1A(a), Extradition Law 5714-1954, as translated1

Three practical consequences follow. First, a citizen-resident cannot be surrendered to serve a sentence already passed in absentia; only surrender for trial is allowed. Second, the person may waive the right to be returned (s. 1A(b)). Third, and most important for people who left Russia recently, both citizenship and residence are tested at the date of the alleged offence, not at the date of the request.

Scenario A: citizen before the eventsScenario B: aliyah after the events
Order of datesCitizen and resident → alleged offenceAlleged offence → citizenship
RegimeSection 1A appliesGeneral rules
What it meansLong-term resident; the Russian charge concerns later events. Surrender is possible only for trial and only with an undertaking to return the person to serve any sentence in Israel.The prosecution says the offence took place in Russia before Israeli citizenship was granted. Section 1A does not apply; what remains are the section 2B bars and arguments about the nature of the prosecution.

Eight bars in section 2B, and which of them matter against Russia

If any one bar is made out, extradition is refused. The list follows the statute;1 the right-hand column is our assessment of how each bar plays in typical Russian cases.

ProvisionBar to extraditionRelevance to Russian requests
2B(a)(1)An offence of a political nature, or a request that in substance aims to prosecute or punish for oneThe core argument in “fake news”, “discrediting the army” and extremism cases, and in business disputes where a criminal case stands in for a civil claim. The statute expressly excludes murder, kidnapping and certain sexual and violent offences from the political category (s. 2B(b)).
2B(a)(2)Reason to suspect the request is motivated by discrimination on grounds of race or religionNarrower than Article 3(2) ECE, which also covers nationality and political opinion.4 The defence relies on both provisions together.
2B(a)(3)A purely military offence, or a breach of security-service statutesRelevant to draft-evasion and desertion charges, which need careful analysis of whether the Russian offence is “purely military”.
2B(a)(4)Already tried in Israel for the same conductRare, but relevant where there is a parallel Israeli investigation, for example into money laundering.
2B(a)(5)Convicted abroad and the sentence served in IsraelA narrow prisoner-transfer scenario.
2B(a)(6)The offence or the penalty is time-barred under Israeli lawLimitation is measured under Israeli, not Russian, law, which often decides older economic cases. Time during a postponed hearing does not count (s. 11).
2B(a)(7)Pardoned in the requesting stateA documentary check.
2B(a)(8)Surrender would harm public order or a vital interest of IsraelThe gateway for arguments about prison conditions, ill-treatment and the state of the justice system in the requesting country.

ss. 2, 16, 17Extradition Law

Beyond section 2B, the Law requires dual criminality with a threshold of at least one year's imprisonment under Israeli law (s. 2), applies the rule of speciality (s. 17) and bars surrender for a capital offence without assurances (s. 16).12

From arrest to the Minister's order

Every time limit below is taken from the statute.12 In practice months pass between stages, and each stage is a separate opportunity for the defence.

  1. pre-petition

    Arrest without a court order

    The Attorney General, his representative or a police officer of the rank of Chief Superintendent or above may order an arrest in writing where it is needed to secure extradition. Information received through INTERPOL channels is a common trigger.

    s. 6
  2. 48 h

    Magistrates' Court judge

    The detainee is brought before a judge within 48 hours. Each detention order lasts up to 20 days and may be renewed, but pre-petition detention may not exceed 60 days in total; a further 10 days is possible once a request has arrived and the Attorney General confirms there are prima facie grounds for a petition.

    s. 7: 48 h / 20 days / 60 + 10 days maximum
  3. Ministry

    The request and the Attorney General's petition

    The request goes to the Minister of Justice, who decides whether to refer the case to court. The Attorney General then petitions the Jerusalem District Court for a declaration of extraditability, and the court may order detention for the duration of the hearing (s. 5).

    s. 3
  4. court

    Declaration of extraditability

    The Jerusalem District Court must be satisfied that the person is lawfully charged in the requesting state, or that there is evidence sufficient to commit him for trial in Israel, and that the Law's other conditions are met. At the person's own request the court may make the declaration without examining the evidence (s. 9(b)); the consequences are hard to undo, so this step should never be taken without advice.

    s. 9
  5. 30 days

    Appeal to the Supreme Court

    Both the requested person and the Attorney General may appeal. Petitions to the High Court of Justice against administrative decisions remain available.

    s. 13
  6. 60 days

    Ministerial order and surrender

    Once the ruling is final, the Minister of Justice may, but need not, order surrender. If the person is not surrendered within 60 days, the declaration lapses unless the court extends the period for special reasons.

    ss. 18–20

Russia → Israel: the legal basis and two telling cases

ECE 1957Committee of Ministers, 23.03.2022

Russia ratified the ECE with a declaration that it will not extradite its own nationals, citing Article 61 of its Constitution.611 After Russia's expulsion from the Council of Europe on 16 March 2022, the Committee of Ministers decided on 23 March 2022 that Russia remains a party to Council of Europe conventions that are open to non-member states. The ECE is one of them, and the French Cour de cassation relied on that decision in October 2022 to hold the Convention still applicable to Russia.5 Israel itself participates in the ECE as a non-member state. The European Convention on Human Rights does not come into it: Israel has never been a party, and Russia ceased to be one on 16 September 2022.

  1. 2014–2016surrendered to Russia

    Gleb Grozovsky

    A St Petersburg priest charged in Russia with offences against minors was arrested in Israel in 2014. In January 2015 the Jerusalem court held him extraditable under the ECE; his appeal failed, the Minister of Justice signed the order in April 2016, and in August 2016 the Supreme Court dismissed his final challenge.78

    What it shows: Israeli courts accept the ECE as a sufficient basis for surrender to Russia, and political-motive arguments gain little traction where the charge is an ordinary crime on the statute's excluded list.

  2. 2015–2019competing requests

    Aleksei Burkov

    A Russian IT specialist was arrested in Israel in 2015 at the request of the United States. Russia sought his transfer instead. On 10 November 2019 the Israeli Supreme Court dismissed his petition and refused to send him to Russia, noting that no rule of law required Israel to do so.9

    What it shows: with competing requests, Israel decides under its own statute and treaty obligations rather than diplomatic pressure. For someone wanted by both the US and Russia, that is a distinct risk scenario.

Law of Return: aliyah is not a form of asylum

s. 2(b)(3)Law of Return, 1954 amendment

A warrant can complicate aliyah itself

Since 1954 the authorities may refuse an immigrant visa to “a person with a criminal past, likely to endanger public welfare”.3 An open Russian warrant can therefore raise questions while status is still being processed, and that is exactly when a prepared case on the political nature of the prosecution matters most.

s. 1Extradition Law

Citizenship confers no immunity

The Law permits the extradition of any person present in Israel provided its conditions are met.1 For a new citizen whose case concerns events before the move, the decisive questions become section 2B, dual criminality, limitation and the evidential basis of the request.

A defence plan for an Israeli case

  • A status chronology. We line up the dates of citizenship, residence and the alleged conduct; that decides whether section 1A applies.
  • Analysis of the Russian file. The charge, its legal classification, limitation under Israeli law and indicators of political motivation.
  • The INTERPOL track. Where there is a Red Notice or diffusion, we prepare access and deletion requests to the Commission for the Control of INTERPOL's Files (CCF) alongside the national proceedings.
  • Evidence for the court. Expert reports on Russian enforcement practice, NGO reporting, and corporate-dispute records where the case grew out of one.
  • The ministerial stage. Even after an adverse ruling the Minister may decline to sign; separate humanitarian and legal submissions are prepared for that stage.
Extradition defenceon request
Red Notice removal via the CCFfrom €5,000
Emergency help on detention24/7on request
Risk analysis and auditfrom €2,000
The exact fee is set after the free first consultation (60 minutes) and a review of the documents. See fees.

What we cannot promise

  • A refusal. The decision belongs to the Israeli courts and the Minister of Justice.
  • Court representation by our own team. Only an advocate admitted in Israel appears in Israeli courts; where needed, we engage a partner lawyer, while the strategy and the Russian side of the case are handled by INTERPOLSTOP's lawyers and advocates.

Frequently asked questions about extradition from Israel

Does Israel extradite its own citizens to Russia?

Israeli law restricts it rather than forbids it. If the person was both an Israeli citizen and an Israeli resident when the alleged offence was committed, extradition is possible only for trial, and only if the requesting state undertakes in advance to return him to Israel to serve any prison sentence (section 1A of the Extradition Law). If citizenship was acquired after the events in the request, that protection does not apply.

Does making aliyah under the Law of Return protect me from a Russian request?

No. Citizenship on its own does not block extradition. Section 2(b)(3) of the Law of Return also allows the authorities to refuse immigrant status to a person with a criminal past who is likely to endanger public welfare, so an open Russian warrant can complicate the aliyah process itself.

What is the legal basis for Russian extradition requests to Israel?

There is no bilateral treaty. The basis is the 1957 European Convention on Extradition, to which both states are parties. The Jerusalem court relied on that Convention in the Gleb Grozovsky case in 2015.

Can someone be arrested in Israel before a formal request arrives?

Yes. Section 6 allows the Attorney General or a senior police officer to order an arrest before a petition is filed where this is needed to secure extradition. The person must be brought before a judge within 48 hours, and pre-petition detention is capped at 60 days, with a possible further 10 days (section 7).

How long do I have to appeal an extraditability ruling?

The Jerusalem District Court's decision can be appealed to the Supreme Court within 30 days (section 13). Once the ruling is final, the Minister of Justice still decides whether to order surrender (section 18).

Does removing a Red Notice help in an Israeli case?

Deleting a notice through the CCF does not cancel an extradition request that has already been filed, but it removes the risk of arrest in third countries and can support the argument that the prosecution is political. The two tracks are run in parallel.

Sources

  1. 1Israel Extradition Law 5714-1954 and Extradition Regulations 5731-1970, up-to-date English translation (UNODC SHERLOC)sherloc.unodc.org
  2. 2Extradition Law 5714-1954, Hebrew text (Wikisource)he.wikisource.org
  3. 3Law of Return 5710-1950 with Amendment 5714-1954, s. 2(b)(3) (English translation)jewishvirtuallibrary.org
  4. 4European Convention on Extradition 1957 (CETS No. 024), Council of Europecoe.int
  5. 5Cour de cassation (France), 11 Oct 2022, No. 22-80.120: Russia remains a party to the ECE after its exclusion from the Council of Europecuria.europa.eu
  6. 6Constitution of the Russian Federation, Art. 61 (no extradition of Russian citizens)constitution.ru
  7. 7RAPSI via Bishop Accountability, 17 May 2016: the Gleb Grozovsky case, 2015 Jerusalem ruling and ministerial orderbishop-accountability.org
  8. 8Bishop Accountability, 3 Aug 2016: Israeli Supreme Court rejects appeal against Grozovsky's extraditionbishop-accountability.org
  9. 9NBC News, 10 Nov 2019: Israeli Supreme Court clears Aleksei Burkov's extradition to the USnbcnews.com
  10. 10Kancelaria Skarbiec: overview of Israeli extradition practice (Sheinbein, 1999)kancelaria-skarbiec.pl
  11. 11BOE (Spain), 18 May 2000: Russia's ratification of the ECE with its declarations and reservationsboe.es

General legal information as at October 2026, not legal advice on your particular case. Law and practice change; any decision about a specific situation should be taken only after the documents have been reviewed.