Extradition from Brazil to Russia
In Brazil three different bodies decide on extradition: the ministry, the Supreme Federal Court (STF) and the President. The court reviews legality only and its ruling cannot be appealed, while the decision whether to hand the person over belongs to the head of state. How this works with Russian requests and what the cases of 2023–2026 show.
Three decisions a Russian request goes through
Brazil and Russia have an extradition treaty signed in Moscow on 14 January 2002, in force since 1 January 2007.3 Everything the treaty does not cover is governed by Migration Law 13.445/2017.2
Ministry of Justice
Law 13.445, Art. 89- Checks the formal conditions of the request.
- An incomplete request is archived; Russia may file it again.
Supreme Federal Court (STF)
Const. Art. 102 I g; Arts. 90–91- No extradition without an STF ruling.
- The ruling is final and cannot be appealed.
President of the Republic
STF case law; Art. 92- The STF reviews legality only.
- Whether to hand over the person is for the President.
STF authorisation does not yet mean surrender. In the Sergey Cherkasov case an STF justice stated plainly that handing over a foreign national is the exclusive prerogative of the President.7
The Russia treaty and the statute: where they differ
For a Russian request the treaty applies first; the statute applies where the treaty is silent or where the Constitution and the statute require more.23 The differences matter for calculating deadlines.
| Brazil–Russia treaty, 2002 | Law 13.445/2017 | |
|---|---|---|
| Deadline for the formal request after arrest | 90 days from arrest; otherwise release (Art. 12(3)–(4)) | 60 days from notice of the arrest — "unless a treaty provides otherwise" (Art. 84 §§ 4–5) |
| Arrest via INTERPOL | Allowed if confirmed in parallel through diplomatic channels (Art. 12(5)) | Through the INTERPOL focal point with proof of a foreign arrest order (Art. 84 § 2) |
| Further information | No more than 90 days; then a decision on what is available (Art. 11) | 60 days to fill gaps at the prosecution's request (Art. 91 § 3) |
| Own nationals | Extradition barred (Art. 6(2)(a)); at Russia's request Brazil prosecutes itself (Art. 7) | Native-born Brazilians are never extradited; naturalised ones only for an act before naturalisation or for drug trafficking (Const. Art. 5 LI; Art. 82 I, § 5) |
| Political character | Refusal for an act of a political nature and where the aim is persecution (Art. 6(2)(f)–(g)); an ordinary crime with a political motive is extraditable on an undertaking not to aggravate the sentence (Art. 6(4)) | Refusal for political and "opinion" crimes; the STF assesses the nature of the act (Art. 82 VII, §§ 1–2) |
| Penalty | No death penalty; life imprisonment replaced by the maximum term under Russian law (Art. 8(3)) | Surrender only on an undertaking to commute life or death sentences to no more than 30 years (Art. 96 III) |
| Time to collect the person | 60 days; otherwise release (Art. 14) | 60 days from notification (Arts. 92–93) |
| Refugees | No specific rule | No extradition of a refugee or a person with territorial asylum (Art. 82 IX) |
Extradition of a foreigner shall not be granted for a political or opinion crime.
Art. 96Law 13.445
Undertakings without which there is no surrender. Russia must undertake not to prosecute the person for other acts before the request, to credit time held in Brazil, not to pass him to a third state without Brazil's consent, not to use political motives to aggravate the sentence, and not to subject him to torture or cruel treatment.2 The defence may show why such undertakings will not be honoured in the specific case — more on diplomatic assurances.
The procedure before the STF
Deadlines and rules under Law 13.445/2017.2
- arrest
Precautionary arrest on request
A request for arrest can arrive through INTERPOL's national bureau in Brazil — for instance on the basis of a Red Notice. The ministry passes it to the STF after the federal prosecutor's opinion. The arrest may be extended until the court's final ruling.
Art. 84 §§ 1–3, § 6 - questioning
Questioning by the rapporteur
The STF rapporteur sets a date for questioning and appoints counsel if the person has none.
Art. 91 - 10 days
Written defence
Filed within 10 days of questioning. Its scope is narrow: identity, defects in the documents, illegality of extradition. The STF does not assess guilt in the Russian case.
Art. 91 § 1 - at any time
Application for a non-custodial measure
The STF may allow house arrest or let the person await the ruling at liberty with travel documents retained, taking into account migration status, background and the circumstances of the case.
Art. 86 - ruling
STF panel
The ruling on legality and merits cannot be appealed. If extradition is refused, a new request on the same facts is not admitted.
Arts. 90, 94; treaty Art. 17 - 60 days
Surrender
After the STF ruling and authorisation by the Executive, Russia must remove the person within 60 days. Surrender is postponed while criminal proceedings or a sentence in Brazil are pending, and in case of serious illness.
Arts. 92–95; treaty Arts. 14–15
Extradition cases to Russia: 2023–2026
Confirmed by STF releases and publications. We found no STF decision refusing Russia in this period — no data.
| Case | Russian charge | What happened |
|---|---|---|
| Sergey Cherkasov 03.2023 / 02.2024 | Membership of a criminal group linked to drug trafficking | In March 2023 the STF approved voluntary surrender, but only after the end of proceedings in Brazil, where he is investigated for espionage and was convicted of using a forged document. In February 2024 the court refused immediate surrender7 |
| Vitaly Petrov since 03.2023 | Embezzling 12.8 million roubles at a military unit in 2010 | A former serviceman who describes himself as an ex-Wagner fighter, arrested in Rio de Janeiro. In May 2024 he applied for humanitarian refuge; Brazil's Prosecutor General's Office supported extradition. As of June 2024 the case awaited a ruling of the STF First Panel8. Outcome — no data |
| Denis Asfandyarov 07.06.2024 | Fraud in dealings with construction firms | Internationally wanted since March 2020, detained in Brazil about three years later and taken to Moscow9 |
| Veronika Lebedeva 06.2024 | Fraud of more than 67 million roubles (29 flats in Kazan) | Detained via INTERPOL channels, handed to a Russian escort at São Paulo airport9 |
| Alexander Davydov 18.08.2026, Ext 2000 | Cryptocurrency fraud | The STF First Panel unanimously authorised the extradition of the journalist and sociologist. It dismissed the persecution argument as unproven and noted that he had not filed a refugee claim with the Ministry of Justice. Before Brazil he had fled to Kazakhstan. Surrender is for the President6 |
- The political argument must be proven. In Davydov the STF did not accept claims of persecution without evidence. Documents are needed: a chronology, publications, human-rights assessments, the link between the charge and the person's activity.
- Without a refugee claim the defence is weaker. The court expressly noted its absence. A CONARE claim also brings a statutory suspension of extradition — see below.
- Cases take years. Petrov waited more than a year after arrest; Cherkasov will not be surrendered until the Brazilian cases end.
Refugee status stops extradition by law
The CONARE procedure is covered in detail on Asylum in Brazil.
Art. 34Law 9.474/1997
A claim suspends extradition
A refugee claim suspends, until a final decision, any extradition proceedings — administrative or judicial — based on the same facts.5
Art. 33Law 9.474/1997
Recognition closes the request
Recognition as a refugee bars examination of any extradition request based on the facts that grounded asylum. The Migration Law repeats the bar (Art. 82 IX).25
Art. 35Law 9.474/1997
The extradition file must be told
The law requires notice to the body handling the extradition. The claim's protocol number should be filed with the STF at once rather than relying on the agencies to exchange information.5
Belarus, Central Asia and international protection
Art. 84 § 2reciprocity
Requests without a treaty
There is no treaty in force with Belarus: in May 2025 Belarus's justice ministry listed Brazil among the states with which an extradition treaty is still being prepared.10 Without a treaty, arrest via the INTERPOL channel requires a promise of reciprocity received through diplomatic channels.2 For Central Asia and the South Caucasus we found no treaties or cases — no data.
UNCAT, Art. 22declaration 26.06.2006
UN Committee against Torture
Brazil has recognised the Committee's competence to consider individual complaints.11 Where there is a real risk of torture after surrender, a complaint with a request for interim measures is possible — see non-refoulement under Article 3 of the Convention.
ACHRCourt since 10.12.1998
The Inter-American system
Brazil acceded to the American Convention on Human Rights in 1992 and accepted the Inter-American Court's jurisdiction on 10 December 1998.12 The Inter-American Commission may ask a state for precautionary measures where there is a serious and urgent risk of irreparable harm (Art. 25 of its Rules).13 The ECtHR and Rule 39 are not available here.
The first days after arrest in Brazil
The written defence is due 10 days after questioning, so the position is prepared before it. A general sequence, adjusted after a consultation.
Art. 91Law 13.445
A lawyer and an interpreter for the STF questioning
If you have no lawyer, the rapporteur will appoint one. Do not explain the substance of the Russian charge without counsel.
Art. 87Law 13.445
Do not declare voluntary surrender
Even if it seems "quicker", it is a waiver of judicial review.
Arts. 34–35Law 9.474/1997
A refugee claim — and its number in the STF file
If return is dangerous, the claim is filed as early as possible and reported in the extradition case.
Art. 86Law 13.445
Apply for house arrest or liberty
Documents on lawful status, housing, family and work in Brazil help.
Documents for the persecution argument
Exactly what was missing in Davydov: the Russian case file translated into Portuguese, publications, evidence of political activity.
INTERPOL in parallel
An application to the Commission for the Control of INTERPOL's Files (CCF) will not stop the STF, but can affect how the case is seen. See the access request and Red Notice removal.
What we do in a Brazilian case
- We assess whether the facts of the Russian charge and the persecution story coincide — this decides whether Art. 34 of Law 9.474 applies
- We prepare evidence of the political nature of the case and translations into Portuguese
- We prepare the STF position and the application for a non-custodial measure; before the STF our partner lawyer admitted in Brazil appears
- We work on the INTERPOL notice through the CCF
- Where torture is a risk — a complaint to the UN Committee against Torture or the Inter-American Commission
- Outcome. The STF, the President and CONARE decide independently; no one can promise a refusal.
- Time. Neither the statute nor the treaty limits the overall length of an STF case; waits can be long.
- Liberty. We cannot guarantee that the person will not be held in custody pending the ruling.
Frequently asked questions
Does Brazil extradite Russians?
Yes. A 2002 extradition treaty with Russia is in force, and in 2024 Brazil surrendered at least two people accused of fraud to Moscow. In August 2026 the STF authorised the extradition of Alexander Davydov. Every case goes through the STF, and the final decision on surrender is the President's.
Arrested in Brazil on an INTERPOL notice — how long until Russia's request must arrive?
Under the treaty with Russia the formal request with documents must arrive within 90 days of the arrest, otherwise the person is released (treaty Art. 12). The statute's general 60-day period applies only where a treaty does not provide otherwise.
Can an STF extradition ruling be appealed?
No. The statute says expressly that the STF ruling on legality cannot be appealed (Law 13.445, Art. 90). But the President's decision on surrender still follows, and a refugee claim suspends extradition on the same facts.
If I acquire Brazilian citizenship, will I be safe from extradition?
Native-born Brazilians are not extradited. A naturalised citizen may be extradited for an ordinary crime committed before naturalisation or for drug trafficking (Const. Art. 5 LI), and the timing of the act relative to naturalisation is taken into account (Law 13.445, Art. 82 § 3). The Russia treaty adds that citizenship obtained to avoid extradition is disregarded (Art. 7(2)).
Will they extradite me under a "political" article of the Russian Criminal Code?
The Constitution bars extradition for political and "opinion" crimes (Art. 5 LII), and the treaty for acts of a political nature and where the aim is persecution. But if the court treats the act as an ordinary crime, a political motive does not block extradition; the STF assesses the nature of the act, and arguments must be supported by documents.
Sources
- 1Constitution of the Federative Republic of Brazil — Art. 5 LI, LII; Art. 102 I gplanalto.gov.br
- 2Lei nº 13.445/2017 (Lei de Migração) — Arts. 81–99planalto.gov.br
- 3Decreto nº 6.056/2007: Brazil–Russia Extradition Treaty (Moscow, 14.01.2002; in force 01.01.2007) — Arts. 6–8, 11–14, 17planalto.gov.br
- 4Russian Federal Law No. 99-FZ of 04.07.2003 ratifying the extradition treaty with Brazil (in Russian)rulaws.ru
- 5Lei nº 9.474/1997 on refugee status — Arts. 33–35planalto.gov.br
- 6STF, 18.08.2026: extradition of Alexander Davydov to Russia authorised (Ext 2000)stf.jus.br
- 7STF, 28.02.2024: Sergey Cherkasov kept in custody; surrender is the President's prerogativestf.jus.br
- 8Gazeta do Povo, 05.06.2024: Russia seeks the extradition of Vitaly Petrovgazetadopovo.com.br
- 9Lenta.ru, 28.06.2024: Brazil extradites Veronika Lebedeva; Denis Asfandyarov delivered on 07.06.2024 (in Russian)lenta.ru
- 10dev.by, 14.05.2025: Belarus preparing extradition treaties with nine states including Brazil (in Russian)devby.io
- 11UN: Convention against Torture — declarations under Art. 22 (Brazil — 26.06.2006)treaties.un.org
- 12OAS: American Convention on Human Rights — Brazil's accession and acceptance of the Court's jurisdictionoas.org
- 13Inter-American Commission on Human Rights: precautionary measures (Art. 25 of the Rules of Procedure)oas.org
General information, current as of October 2026; not legal advice. The outcome of Petrov's case and the President's decision in Davydov's case were not found in open sources at the date of update — no data.