UAE: asylum is impossible, but extradition is not automatic
Quincy Promes lived in Russia for years, out of reach of the Dutch courts — and was extradited from Dubai fifteen months after an airport arrest. His case shows three things at once: the UAE has no asylum system, extradition runs through a full court process, and being “untouchable” in one country does not carry over to another.
Published . Reading time 10 minutes.
The Promes case: out of reach in Russia, extradited from Dubai
Quincy Promes, a former Netherlands international, played for Spartak Moscow and lived in Russia while Dutch courts convicted him in absentia. Russia does not extradite him to the Netherlands, and his position seemed secure. It proved vulnerable in the UAE.
- 2023Netherlands
Conviction in absentia: 18 months
For stabbing a cousin. Under appeal.
- 02.2024Netherlands
Conviction in absentia: six years
For involvement in importing more than a tonne of cocaine through Antwerp in 2020. Under appeal.3
- 03.2024Dubai
Airport arrest on an INTERPOL notice
During Spartak’s training camp, shortly before flying back to Russia, at the Netherlands’ request. He was already under local restrictions over a traffic incident. Russia, according to Dutch media, filed its own extradition request on tax-fraud charges.1
- 05.2024Dubai court
First hearing
His Dutch lawyer explained that the Dubai judge would not review the convictions — they were under appeal — but only the alleged facts and whether they carry at least one year’s imprisonment.1
- 2024on bail
Releases and re-arrests
Released, re-arrested after social-media posts while on bail, released again. In July 2024 Spartak terminated his contract.
- 12.06.2025Dubai
Re-arrest
Arrested again at home in Dubai.2
- 20.06.2025extradition
Extradited to the Netherlands
About 15 months after the first arrest.3
Why there is no asylum in the UAE — by design
1951 Convention and 1967 Protocolthe UAE is not a party
This is not strict migration policy or a high refusal rate but the absence of the legal construct itself: no law on an asylum procedure, criteria for refugee status or rights flowing from it.8
Does not exist
UNHCR is present in the UAE and can help with resettlement to a third country, but it creates no status inside the country and cannot stop extradition or deportation.Real and multi-stage
Diplomatic channel and Ministry of Justice, Court of Appeal, review of refusal grounds, Court of Cassation, final decision of the Ministry of Justice.UN Convention against Torturenon-refoulement
There is no European safety net either: the UAE is not in the Council of Europe, so the ECtHR is unavailable, and it has not accepted individual complaints to the UN Committee against Torture. But as a party to the Convention against Torture it is bound by the ban on sending anyone to a country where they face torture.9
But extradition is not automatic
Extradition is governed by Federal Law No. 39 of 2006 on International Judicial Cooperation in Criminal Matters, as amended by Federal Decree-Law No. 38 of 2023, and by any treaty with the requesting state, which takes priority.4 As UAE practitioners describe it, it is a sequence of separate stages, not a single administrative decision.6
Law No. 39/2006diplomatic channel
Diplomatic channel and Ministry of Justice
The formal request arrives through diplomatic channels and is first reviewed by the UAE Ministry of Justice.
double criminalityand statutory bars
Court — usually the Court of Appeal where the person is
Checks the formal conditions, including double criminality, and the absence of statutory bars.
Grounds for refusal
According to UAE practitioners, the law bars extradition, among other things, for political offences, where the limitation period has expired, where there is a risk of torture or an unfair trial, or where the case falls within the UAE’s own jurisdiction.
Court of Cassation
The Court of Appeal’s decision can be appealed; if extradition is refused, the prosecution can appeal too.
Final decision of the Ministry of Justice
A final court decision in favour of extradition is executed through the Ministry of Justice, which takes the final decision.
Detention limits: the window that matters
Law No. 39/2006 as amended 2023commentary
Without a bilateral treaty the UAE can still extradite on the basis of reciprocity. But the requesting state must act: according to commentary on the 2023 amendments, a person may be held on a foreign judicial warrant for up to 60 days pending a formal request, with release on guarantees possible; where a treaty sets a different period, the treaty applies.5 It is a concrete, checkable point for the defence, verified against the documents in each case.
Russia and the UAE: a treaty exists, and that changes the risk
Russia–UAE extradition treatyAbu Dhabi, 25.11.2014
The treaty was signed by Russia’s Prosecutor General and the UAE Minister of Justice; the State Duma considered ratification in January 2016.10 It covers acts punishable under both states’ laws by at least one year’s imprisonment. Entry into force and the full list of refusal grounds must be checked against the text in each case. For other CIS states the position has to be checked country by country: without a treaty, a request is handled under the general law on the basis of reciprocity, with the detention limit above.
The UAE in the register AE
- Asylum
- None: not a party to the 1951 Convention
- Extradition law
- No. 39/2006, as amended 2023
- Treaty with Russia
- Signed 25.11.2014
The treaty and the procedure are covered in the guide “Extradition from the UAE”.
Convictions in absentia: a separate line of defence
Both Dutch convictions were handed down in absentia and were under appeal. That is why, as his lawyer explained, the Dubai court did not assess their merits or severity but looked at the alleged facts and the penalty threshold.
This opens a separate line of defence where a request rests on a conviction in absentia: challenge not only the general refusal grounds but the procedural soundness of the conviction itself. Was there real access to a defence, was the person properly notified, is a full retrial available on return?
When two states want the same person
Where several states seek the same person, the UAE authorities decide which request to execute under Law No. 39/2006 and the treaties. In the Promes case the Netherlands prevailed. For people facing risk both from their home country and from a third state, “which outcome is less dangerous for me?” is not hypothetical: this procedural configuration is worth planning in advance — lawfully, through the arguments each procedure allows.
What this means in practice
- A conviction in absentia is not a ready ticket to extradition. If under appeal, the UAE court looks at the facts and the penalty threshold.
- Competing requests are a real scenario. Where risk comes from several jurisdictions, think each procedure through in advance.
- Moving to the UAE is not a shield in itself. Unlike Spain or Germany, there is no parallel asylum track.
- The court procedure leaves room for defence: double criminality, political character, risk of torture or unfair trial, limitation.
- The final Ministry of Justice stage deserves as much attention in the strategy as the court.
- A treaty with the home country changes the procedure: for Russia, the 2014 treaty; for others, check first.
- A “safe haven” reputation is not legal protection: the UAE acts on INTERPOL notices more actively than often assumed.
Anyone considering the UAE as a place to live while facing a Red Notice risk needs to build the defence around the court procedure in advance. Whether a Red Notice or diffusion exists cannot be said in advance; one way to check is an access request to the CCF. If someone is already detained — emergency help. Before the UAE courts our UAE-licensed partner lawyer appears; no one can predict the decision of a UAE court or the Ministry of Justice.
Questions
Can I claim political asylum in the UAE?
No. The UAE is not a party to the 1951 Refugee Convention or the 1967 Protocol and has no national asylum procedure. Protection against extradition has to be built within the extradition procedure itself and, where appropriate, before the CCF.
If there is no extradition treaty with my country, am I safe?
No. The UAE can extradite on the basis of reciprocity under Federal Law No. 39/2006. The law limits detention on a foreign warrant pending a formal request — according to commentary on the 2023 amendments, to 60 days unless a treaty provides otherwise. That limit is an important point for the defence.
Related materials
Sources
Basis of this article: media reports on the Promes case (case details are taken from them), the text of UAE Federal Law No. 39/2006 and commentary by UAE practitioners on the 2023 amendments, UN Treaty Collection data.
- 1NL Times, 02.05.2024 — first hearing in Dubainltimes.nl
- 2NL Times, 12.06.2025 — re-arrestnltimes.nl
- 3Fox Sports / AP, 20.06.2025 — extradition to the Netherlandsfoxsports.com
- 4UAE Federal Law No. 39/2006 as amended by Decree-Law No. 38/2023lexismiddleeast.com
- 5Mondaq — amendments to the UAE law: detention limitsmondaq.com
- 6Charles Russell Speechlys — extradition in the UAEcharlesrussellspeechlys.com
- 7Mondaq — an extradition to the UK through the Dubai courtsmondaq.com
- 8UN Treaty Collection — 1951 Refugee Conventiontreaties.un.org
- 9UN Treaty Collection — Convention against Torturetreaties.un.org
- 10Kremlin.ru — Russia–UAE extradition treatykremlin.ru
This article is general information, not legal advice. Any situation requires an analysis of the applicable treaty, the facts and current UAE court practice.