Turkey as a transit jurisdiction: why “medium risk” does not mean “safe”
Turkey’s extradition statute looks protective on paper. But the final word belongs not to a court but to the Minister of Justice and the President, and there is a faster route alongside it — deportation. Where the decision is really made.
Published , reviewed . Reading time: 10 min.
Türkiye in the register TR
- Statute
- Law No. 6706 on International Judicial Cooperation in Criminal Matters, April 2016
- Court
- Ağır Ceza Mahkemesi where the person is found
- Final word
- Minister of Justice and President Art. 19
- Treaty
- European Convention on Extradition 1957
- Parallel route
- Deportation under Law No. 6458
October 2017: not extradition in the textbook sense
In November 2017 Habertürk reported a story that barely reached international headlines but describes precisely how extradition in Turkey can work when state interests are at stake. Two Russians, Aleksandr Smirnov and Yury Anisimov, held in Turkey since 2016 on suspicion of espionage and of involvement in the killings of Chechens, had been returned to Russia in October. At about the same time, the Crimean Tatar leaders Akhtem Chiygoz and Ilmi Umerov were unexpectedly released in Russian-occupied Crimea and flown to Ankara.
According to the report, a Turkish prosecutor asked at a hearing for the two Russians to be released, citing an August 2017 decree that allows foreigners held in Turkey to be exchanged for certain persons held abroad. Officials on both sides declined to comment.1
That is exactly why Turkey is described as a medium-risk jurisdiction: the risk is not that the law is bad on paper, but that the law is not the last word on a person’s fate. For the full country profile see our guide to extradition from Türkiye.
A law that looks protective — on paper
The formal basis for extradition is Law No. 6706 on International Judicial Cooperation in Criminal Matters, adopted in April 2016, a few months before the attempted coup that transformed Turkish practice. At first sight it compares well with the Spanish or German models.3
Art. 10(2) Law 6706double criminality
Double criminality and a seriousness threshold
At the investigation or trial stage, only offences punishable by at least one year’s deprivation of liberty under both the requesting state’s law and Turkish law. For persons already sentenced, the sentence must be at least four months.
Art. 11(1)(a); Art. 38 Constitutionnationals
No extradition of Turkish citizens
Except for obligations under the Rome Statute of the International Criminal Court.
Art. 3 ECE 1957text of the Convention
Political and military offences
Turkey is a party to the European Convention on Extradition, whose Article 3 allows refusal for political offences and where a request is in fact aimed at persecution on grounds of race, religion, nationality or political opinion. European courts rely on this shield when refusing Turkish requests concerning activists and alleged Gülen supporters, and it is equally available against requests made to Turkey.
Art. 11(1)(d)no assurances, no surrender
Death penalty or punishment incompatible with human dignity
Unless the requesting state gives assurances.
Art. 11(1)(ç)ne bis in idem
Double jeopardy
No extradition where the person has already been acquitted or convicted in Turkey for the same act.
Admissibility is decided by the heavy criminal court (Ağır Ceza Mahkemesi) of the place where the person is found, or the Ankara court where the location is unknown — structurally similar to the Audiencia Nacional in Spain or the Oberlandesgericht in Germany.
The weak link: what happens after the court says yes
Art. 19 Law 6706execution depends on the President
This is the fundamental difference, and it explains why a technically sound defence in a Turkish court is necessary but not sufficient. If the court finds extradition admissible, execution depends on a proposal by the Minister of Justice and approval by the President of the Republic, in consultation with the Ministries of Foreign Affairs and the Interior.
Ağır Ceza Mahkemesi
Law 6706, ECE 1957- Examines double criminality, refusal grounds and the risk of ill-treatment.
- Outcome: extradition admissible or not.
Minister of Justice and President
Art. 19 Law 6706- Approval in consultation with Foreign Affairs and Interior.
- Not bound by the court’s reasoning; considerations outside the case file can weigh.
A court ruling is not the end of the matter. It is followed by a separate, essentially political stage, and it is there, not in the courtroom, that the wider state of relations with the requesting country comes into play. The reported example is October 2017.
The case that showed the limits of international protection
If 2017 illustrates the executive acting around the courts, Mamatkulov and Askarov v. Turkey, decided by the Grand Chamber of the European Court of Human Rights on 4 February 2005, shows the same at the level of international supervision.2
Two Uzbek nationals, members of the opposition Erk party, were arrested in Turkey at Uzbekistan’s request. Their lawyers applied to Strasbourg, and the Court indicated an interim measure under Rule 39 of its Rules asking Turkey not to extradite them until it had examined the case. Turkey extradited both regardless.
| Article of the Convention | Outcome | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Art. 34 — right of individual application | Violation found | Extradition in breach of the Rule 39 indication; the judgment established that interim measures are legally binding |
| Art. 3 — prohibition of torture | No violation found | General reports on ill-treatment in Uzbekistan did not establish a specific, individual risk to these applicants |
The lesson has two sides. Even an express indication from Europe’s highest human rights court did not stop the extradition. And general human rights reports do not win a case by themselves: what is needed is individualised evidence of risk to this particular person — the same principle that applies before the Commission for the Control of INTERPOL’s Files (CCF) under the Article 3 predominance test.
The growing alternative route: deportation instead of extradition
Historically the main risk in Turkey was extradition itself. Practice in recent years shows a shift towards an instrument that bypasses that procedure entirely.
The guarantees of an extradition statute protect against extradition. They do not automatically protect against administrative removal.
| Extradition | Deportation | |
|---|---|---|
| Statute | Law No. 6706 on International Judicial Cooperation | Law No. 6458 on Foreigners and International Protection |
| Basis | A foreign state’s request | Among others, public order and security |
| Bars | Double criminality, political offences, death penalty, nationals | Serious indications of death penalty, torture or inhuman treatment |
| Control | Heavy criminal court, then Minister and President | Challenge before the administrative courts |
| Speed | Judicial and executive stages | Faster, with different safeguards |
Human rights organisations have documented cases in which removal from Turkey was used against dissidents from authoritarian states. Double criminality, judicial scrutiny and the political-offence bar protect against extradition, but not necessarily against administrative deportation — a different legal track that requires a separate defence strategy.
The post-2016 context: how extradition became a political tool
After the failed coup of July 2016, the Turkish authorities launched a sweeping campaign against people associated with the movement of Fethullah Gülen (designated in Turkey as a terrorist organisation under the acronym FETÖ). Thousands of alleged supporters left the country, and extradition requests became a principal instrument for pursuing them abroad. Many Western states refused, relying on the political-offence and discrimination clauses of the European Convention on Extradition. The same logic of politics shaping extradition runs in the other direction when Turkey is the requested state.
What this means in practice
- Winning before the Ağır Ceza Mahkemesi is not the end of the case. Because of Article 19, any admissibility ruling passes through an executive stage where considerations unrelated to the legal merits can weigh.
- International interim measures do not protect automatically. Even an express Strasbourg indication did not stop the extradition of Mamatkulov and Askarov, although it later led to a finding of a separate violation.
- General human rights reports are not enough. As before the CCF under Article 3, you need person-specific evidence.
- Deportation is a separate channel of risk that needs its own strategy.
- Turkey’s relations with the requesting state matter as much as the case file, given the reported willingness to use detainees in negotiations.
Questions
Does Turkey’s protective extradition law make it a safe transit country?
No. Under Article 19 of Law No. 6706, a court finding that extradition is admissible still goes to the Minister of Justice and the President, who can weigh considerations unrelated to the case file. The events reported in 2017 illustrate the risk.
Does an ECHR interim measure under Rule 39 guarantee that extradition will be stopped?
Not automatically. In Mamatkulov and Askarov v. Turkey, Turkey extradited the applicants despite the Court’s indication; the Grand Chamber later found a separate violation of Article 34 of the Convention.
Can Turkey deport me instead of extraditing me?
Deportation is a separate administrative procedure under Law No. 6458 on Foreigners and International Protection. That law bars removal where there is a serious risk of the death penalty, torture or inhuman treatment, and decisions can be challenged in the administrative courts, but the safeguards differ from those in extradition proceedings.
Related
Sources
This article draws on the text of Law No. 6706 as summarised by Turkish practitioners, the 2005 Grand Chamber judgment, contemporaneous reporting on the 2017 events and the European Convention on Extradition. Facts current as at October 2026.
- 1RFE/RL: report that Turkey swapped two alleged Russian spies for Crimean Tatar leaders (November 2017)rferl.org
- 2Mamatkulov and Askarov v. Turkey, ECtHR Grand Chamber, 4 February 2005, nos. 46827/99 and 46951/99refworld.org
- 3Mondaq: Law No. 6706, Articles 10, 11, 19 and 20 explainedmondaq.com
- 4Council of Europe: European Convention on Extradition (ETS No. 024), Articles 3 and 4coe.int
This article is general information, not legal advice. Assessing a particular situation requires analysis of the facts and of the current political context.