The predominance test: how INTERPOL decides political cases
“My case is political” is the most common argument in INTERPOL cases. INTERPOL has its own method of testing it: since 1951 a request may not go through its channels if the offence is predominantly political in substance. The method as the Repository of Practice describes it — with anonymised decisions from it.
Published . Reading time 14 minutes.
The exact text of Article 3 and its aims
It is strictly forbidden for the Organization to undertake any intervention or activities of a political, military, religious or racial character.
Repository of Practicethird edition, 11.2024
According to INTERPOL’s Repository of Practice on Articles 2 and 3, the ban has three aims: to ensure the Organization’s independence and neutrality, to reflect the principles of international extradition law, and to protect individuals from persecution.3 A commentary on the rule itself is in the entry “Article 3 of INTERPOL’s Constitution”. If the prosecution is linked to political activity, also assess the grounds for political asylum.
The predominance test: a working principle, not a slogan
- 1951AGN/20/RES/11
The test enters INTERPOL practice
The General Assembly takes it from international extradition law: a request may not go through INTERPOL’s channels if the offence is predominantly political, racial or religious in substance — even if the requesting country’s law classes it as ordinary crime.
- 1984AGN/53/RES/7
Guidelines for applying Article 3
Each case is examined separately, in its own context. In the Repository’s words, the question of predominance “must be settled by examining the facts”.
- 11.2024Repository
Third edition of the Repository of Practice
History of the test, the elements of RPD Art. 34(3) and anonymised decisions.3
There is no ready list of “political” and “non-political” offences — the totality of facts is assessed.
Two kinds of offence: pure and relative
| Pure offences | Relative offences | |
|---|---|---|
| What they are | Criminalised solely because of their political, military, religious or racial character; no ordinary-law element | Contain an ordinary-law element but are committed in a political context |
| Examples | Treason, espionage; “insulting the authorities” and “expressing certain prohibited opinions” (named in the 1984 resolution) | Fraud, embezzlement, money laundering, corruption charged against politicians, business people, public figures |
| How assessed | Facts are still checked: treason and espionage are often committed for money, so the label alone does not decide | The predominance test: which outweighs — the political or the ordinary-criminal element |
The great majority of disputed cases — economic charges against politicians, business people and public figures — fall into the second category.
The seven elements of RPD Article 34(3)
RPD, Art. 34(3)an illustrative list
To check compliance with Article 3, the Rules on the Processing of Data (RPD) require examination of “all relevant elements, such as”:4
Nature of the offence
The charges and the underlying facts.
Status of the person
For example, a serving or former politician; whether refugee status was granted.
Source of the data
Who is behind the request; how the country has previously used INTERPOL’s channels and complied with the rules.
Position of other NCBs and international entities
For example, an official objection by the country where the person held office. See NCB.
Obligations under international law
Immunities and applicable international conventions.
Implications for neutrality
Whether INTERPOL would be drawn into an inter-state dispute.
General context of the case
The situation in the country: elections, a coup, mass protests at the time of the request.
A political context does not block a request by itself. The elements are weighed together, and the General Secretariat looks beyond the label the requesting country uses.
How it works: decisions from the Repository of Practice
Cases from the third edition (November 2024), retold without changing the outcome or the reasons:
| Case | What decided it | Outcome |
|---|---|---|
| Former president: corruption, illicit enrichment | Acts committed for personal enrichment, not for political ends | Publication approved |
| Former president: embezzlement over economic decisions that hit the treasury | Measures were political, taken in a difficult situation after a coup that removed him, with support from international financial institutions; no personal gain | Refused |
| Former prime minister: Red Notice and global diffusion | Had just lost a presidential election and remained the main opponent of the government; demonstrations for and against the government were ongoing | Refused: predominantly political |
| District head: large bribes some years earlier | Open opposition to the ruling party; an international organisation publicly pointed to a political element; four cases opened after he refused to resign | Refused |
| Opposition politician: defamation of a ruling-party official | Publicly accused a public official of corruption through the media; no personal gain; a legitimate exercise of free expression | Refused |
The pattern is consistent: the outcome depends less on the wording of the charge than on the totality of circumstances — the person’s status, personal gain, the timing of the case relative to political events, the position of other states and international organisations.
A special case: serving and former politicians
The Repository treats politicians and senior officials differently depending on who made the request.
Ordinary predominance analysis plus three factors
Possible immunity at home; acts within a political mandate (failure to follow an administrative or political procedure is usually not ordinary crime, and the NCB may be asked to show, for example, personal gain); context — coup, unrest, elections.International immunity questions are added
Whether the person holds office at the time of the request, acted in an official capacity, who the source is (an international tribunal is usually seen as neutral, which favours compliance), and whether the country the person serves or served objects.Freedom of expression: where the line is
| Against the state and officials | Against private persons, no political motive | |
|---|---|---|
| Article 3 | Generally applies | Generally does not apply |
| Repository example | A diffusion for “insulting a former head of state” was not recorded: a purely political offence | A diffusion for criminal defamation of a mayor was recorded: the mayor was not considered a state official and there were no other political elements |
Free expression is not absolute: genuine hate speech and direct incitement to violence are not protected and are processed on general terms.
What it means for defence strategy
- The wording of the charge does not decide the outcome. “Fraud” or “embezzlement” can be found political if the context points that way — and vice versa where personal gain or seriousness is proven.
- Chronology matters. The timing of the case relative to elections, changes of power or a public clash is one of the weightiest factors in published practice.
- Personal gain is the central question in cases against politicians and officials. If the requesting country cannot show gain rather than unpopular decisions, its position is much weaker.
- Third parties’ positions count: protests by other states, statements by international organisations.
- Refugee status is a significant factor within the person’s status; INTERPOL also has a specific policy on refugees.
If a notice or diffusion has already been recorded, the next step is usually a request to the Commission for the Control of INTERPOL’s Files: see “How the CCF works” and our Red Notice removal service. No one can predict how the General Secretariat or the CCF will weigh the elements in a given case, or promise a refusal or deletion. What can be done is to set out the facts relevant under RPD Art. 34(3) clearly, with documents and in time.
Questions
Does Article 3 automatically block any case against an opposition figure?
No. Being a political opponent does not by itself trigger Article 3. INTERPOL weighs all relevant elements together, including the nature of the charge, personal gain and the overall context.
Can a fraud or embezzlement charge be found political?
Yes, if the evidence supports it. INTERPOL’s published examples include economic charges against former officials found predominantly political because of the context and the absence of personal gain.
What matters more — the wording of the charge or the context?
The context. Predominance is settled by examining the facts, not by the label given by the requesting country.
Are other countries’ views taken into account?
Yes. The position of another NCB or an international organisation is one of the elements in RPD Article 34(3).
Does Article 3 apply to diffusions as it does to Red Notices?
Yes. Article 3 of the Constitution and Article 34 of the RPD cover all data in INTERPOL’s channels. Wanted-person diffusions, like Red Notice requests, are reviewed by the Notices and Diffusions Task Force (NDTF); afterwards, on the person’s application, the CCF can review compliance.
Does free-speech protection work in INTERPOL cases?
Partly. If a statement targets the state, its officials or institutions and is not hate speech or incitement to violence, Article 3 generally applies. If it targets private persons with no political motive, it generally does not.
Related materials
Sources
Basis of this article: the text of Article 3 of the Constitution, Article 34 of the RPD and INTERPOL’s Repository of Practice on Articles 2 and 3 (third edition, November 2024). Anonymised examples are retold without changing the substance of the decisions.
- 1Neutrality (Article 3 of the Constitution)interpol.int
- 2INTERPOL Constitutioninterpol.int
- 3Repository of Practice — Articles 2 and 3, 3rd ed., November 2024interpol.int
- 4INTERPOL legal documents, including the RPD (Art. 34)interpol.int
- 5Commission for the Control of INTERPOL’s Files (CCF)interpol.int
This article is general information, not legal advice. Whether a case falls under Article 3 is always assessed individually on its facts.