Article 2 of INTERPOL’s Constitution: human rights as a condition of cooperation
Article 2 requires INTERPOL to act “in the spirit of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights”. It underpins arguments about unfair trials, torture, refugee status and convictions in absentia. This page sets out how INTERPOL itself reads the provision and what standard of proof the Commission for the Control of INTERPOL’s Files (CCF) applies in its published decisions.
Based on: Constitution, RPD (2025 version), Repository of Practice (2024), CCF decision excerpts.
Two paragraphs, two functions
Constitution, Art. 2as amended in 19641
The Constitution dates from 1956; Article 2 was amended in 1964 at the Caracas session.1 It was the first reference to human rights in the Organization’s statutes.3
To ensure and promote the widest possible mutual assistance between all criminal police authorities within the limits of the laws existing in the different countries and in the spirit of the “Universal Declaration of Human Rights”;
What it does. Defines the mandate — and qualifies it twice: cooperation is bounded by national law and must be consistent with the goals and principles of the 1948 Declaration.
To establish and develop all institutions likely to contribute effectively to the prevention and suppression of ordinary law crimes.
What it does. Confines the Organization to ordinary-law crime — the counterpart of Article 3, which excludes political, military, religious and racial matters.
The three legal frameworks behind every INTERPOL request
Repository of Practicesection 13
INTERPOL’s Repository of Practice on Articles 2 and 3 of the Constitution derives three restrictions on INTERPOL’s mandate from Articles 2 and 3, and gives a Red Notice example of a breach of each.
| Framework | Provision | What it covers | Example of a breach |
|---|---|---|---|
| The laws of the different countries | Art. 2(1), first limb | National law of the country sending the request and of the country acting on it | No valid arrest warrant issued by the competent authority of the requesting country |
| The spirit of the Declaration | Art. 2(1), second limb | International human rights law reflecting the spirit of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights (UDHR) | Publication would entail a violation of the individual’s human rights |
| Ordinary-law crime only | Art. 2(2) and Art. 3 | INTERPOL’s internal law: matters of political, military, religious or racial character excluded | Involvement would compromise the Organization’s neutrality |
RPD Arts 2, 11(1), 34(1), 862025 version2
INTERPOL’s Rules on the Processing of Data (RPD) repeat Article 2 several times: the aim of the Rules (Art. 2), lawfulness (Art. 11(1)), the source’s duty to check compliance before recording data (Art. 34(1)), and the legal review of Red Notices (Art. 86).
“The spirit of the Declaration”: where INTERPOL takes the standard from
Repository of Practice, 2.1.3not exhaustive
The 1948 Declaration is not a treaty, so INTERPOL gives its “spirit” content from later sources of international law.3
| Source | Role | |
|---|---|---|
| a | The 1966 Covenants — above all the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights (ICCPR), which INTERPOL describes as particularly relevant to its compliance review | Treaties |
| b | Specialised conventions — racial discrimination, torture, rights of the child and others; the 1951 Refugee Convention is singled out as particularly relevant | Treaties |
| c | UN treaty bodies — interpretations, general comments, views on individual communications | Interpretation |
| d | UN Charter-based mechanisms — Human Rights Council, special procedures, Universal Periodic Review | Interpretation |
| e | Resolutions of authoritative bodies — UN General Assembly and Security Council | Consensus |
| f | Case law of national, regional and international courts — including the European, Inter-American and African human rights courts and the International Court of Justice | Guidance |
ECtHR resolution, 22.03.2022Russia outside the ECHR from 16.09.20225
How the General Secretariat tests Article 2 compliance
Repository of Practice, 2.1source 3
What INTERPOL does not do. It does not carry out its own assessments of human rights conditions in member countries and does not investigate allegations of torture or unlawfully obtained evidence. It relies on findings by competent bodies — for example a UN Committee against Torture finding that the person was tortured, or a national court ruling that wiretapping was unlawful.
What it does with such findings. It asks how far the established violation bears on the data. A conviction resting on a confession extracted by torture cannot be processed. Excessive pre-trial detention is a violation but does not necessarily taint the data; the question then is whether the state has remedied it.
RPD Art. 34(3)in adapted form
What it weighs. For Article 2 the General Secretariat applies the RPD Art. 34(3) elements in adapted form:
- the nature of the offence — does the charge itself curtail human rights?
- the person’s status — refugee status, for instance;
- the source — the National Central Bureau (NCB) of the country the person fears, and its compliance record;
- international-law obligations — is the right derogable; would the violation occur on publication or only potentially later?
- general context — country information alone is not a ground for refusal but helps in reading the request.
Four possible outcomes
The whole request is tainted
The breach is so fundamental that INTERPOL’s channels cannot be used — e.g. a request from the country of origin of a refugee protected against it, or a competent body’s finding that surrender would breach non-refoulement.One form barred, others allowed
A Red Notice may be ruled out because of a serious risk on extradition, while a crime-analysis file entry on possible links to an organised group remains permissible.A curable defect
Discriminatory wording or unnecessary personal details: once removed, the data can be processed.No violation
Including cases where concerns existed but did not lead to a finding of non-compliance.What the Commission treats as a proven Article 2 breach
A formula recurs in published decisions: the simple assertion of procedural irregularities cannot rise to the level of an Article 2 violation; the applicant must convincingly demonstrate the likelihood of a flagrant denial of a fair trial. Four official excerpts, summarised:6
CCF, 2019 No. 10data retained; PDF
Conviction in absentia with a right to retrial
The applicant had been convicted in absentia and argued he could not defend himself. The NCB confirmed that on surrender or extradition he could challenge the judgment and be retried with counsel of his choice.
Rule. A conviction in absentia does not in itself breach Article 2 where a fresh determination on the merits is guaranteed. An argument based on UDHR Article 13 (freedom of movement) against a valid diffusion was also rejected.
CCF, 2025 No. 4data retained; PDF
General country reports unrelated to the case
The subject of a Blue Notice relied on Inter-American Court case law and general reports on the requesting country’s justice system.
Rule. The Commission does not assess a country’s judicial system as a whole. General criticism by outside organisations that does not address the applicant’s own situation cannot establish an Article 2 violation.
CCF, 2023 No. 5data deleted; PDF
Extradition refused; refugee status in a third country
A court in the country of residence refused extradition, finding serious grounds to fear breaches of fundamental rights; the applicant had refugee status there — protecting him against his country of nationality, not against the requesting state.
Rule. The refugee policy did not apply stricto sensu, but the reasoned refusal to extradite reinforced the Article 2 arguments. Refugee status and doubtful criminal involvement were treated as factors weighing against compliance.
CCF, 2024 No. 2data deleted; PDF
An NCB that would not answer
The applicant set out detailed arguments; despite extensions, the NCB did not answer the Commission’s questions.
Rule. The NCB’s failure to respond to detailed submissions raised serious doubts as to Article 2 compliance; combined with an insufficient description of criminal involvement (RPD Art. 83), the data were deleted.
The CCF’s official collection contains further Article 2 excerpts — on the right to life, torture and ill-treatment, and the right to medical care.6 An annotated selection is in our CCF decisions database.
What works under Article 2 — and what does not
Repository of Practice, 2.1.4and the decisions above
Our distillation of section 2.1.4 of the Repository of Practice and the decisions above. A guide for building a file, not an official scale.
Weak
- General NGO reports on the country with no link to the case
- Undocumented assertions of procedural irregularities
- Narratives of innocence: the CCF does not weigh evidence or decide guilt
Significant
- Specific documents from your own case: trial record, service of process, details of defence counsel
- Evidence that reports or UN special procedures refer to you personally
- The NCB’s failure to answer the Commission’s specific questions
Strong
- Refugee status granted against the country that issued the request
- A reasoned court refusal of extradition on human rights grounds
- A competent body’s finding of a violation in this very case (UN Committee against Torture, a national or international court)
INTERPOL’s refugee policy
GA-2017-86-RES-09General Assembly resolution4
The 2017 General Assembly resolution covers people with refugee status and asylum seekers. It rests on Article 2 and balances protection of refugees against the risk of the status being abused by criminals.
Confirmation of status
Member countries are encouraged to inform the General Secretariat or the CCF of grants of status and the outcome of asylum claims. INTERPOL does not assess claims itself.
Deletion
Once status is confirmed, INTERPOL deletes any notice or diffusion from the country where the person fears persecution.
Possible restoration
If asylum is refused or status revoked, the data may be kept or restored — provided they comply with INTERPOL’s rules.
In practice the decisive evidence is official confirmation of status by the competent authority of the host state. Where the status protects against a different country from the one seeking the person, deletion is not automatic and the arguments are assessed under Article 2 in the ordinary way.
That was the position in CCF 2023 No. 5 above. On asylum procedures see our political asylum page.
Article 2 and Article 3: which provision to invoke, and when
Repository of Practice, 2.3source 3
| Article 2(1) | Article 3 | |
|---|---|---|
| Nature | Brings external international human rights standards into INTERPOL’s practice | INTERPOL’s own rule, read through its resolutions and practice |
| Protects | Primarily the individual | Both the individual and the Organization — against being drawn into politics |
| Only under this article | Persecution on grounds of gender or sexual orientation (unless religiously based) | Questions of the Organization’s neutrality |
| Under both | Violations of freedom of expression, assembly and association — engaging both human rights and the “political” limb | |
| If Article 2 alone falls short | Human rights doubts are fed into the Article 3 predominance test through “obligations under international law” and “general context” | |
For a full treatment of Article 3 see Article 3 of INTERPOL’s Constitution.
What not to expect from Article 2
Realistic
- Deletion where refugee status against the requesting country is confirmed.
- Deletion on specific, documented violations in your own case — particularly where a court or UN body has found them.
- Using the same material in extradition and asylum proceedings.
Unrealistic
- Deletion based solely on a country’s general reputation.
- Reopening a conviction: the CCF is not an appeal court and does not weigh evidence.
- A guaranteed outcome: decisions rest with the General Secretariat and the CCF.
Services where human rights arguments are decisive: Red Notice removal via the CCF — from €5,000, political asylum — from €2,000, extradition defence — on request, risk analysis and audit — from €2,000. The exact fee is set after a free initial consultation (60 minutes).
Related
Sources
- 1Constitution of the ICPO-INTERPOL [I/CONS/GA/1956 (2023)], Art. 2 and reference notes (1964 amendment)interpol.int
- 2INTERPOL’s Rules on the Processing of Data [III/IRPD/GA/2011 (2025)], Arts 2, 11, 34, 86interpol.int
- 3INTERPOL, Repository of Practice: Application of Articles 2 and 3 of INTERPOL’s Constitution, 3rd ed., November 2024 (sections 1, 2.1, 2.3)interpol.int
- 4INTERPOL Refugee Resolution, GA-2017-86-RES-09interpol.int
- 5European Court of Human Rights, Resolution on the consequences of the cessation of membership of the Russian Federation to the Council of Europe in light of Article 58 of the Convention, 22 March 2022echr.coe.int
- 6CCF — Sessions and decisions: official excerpts 2019 No. 10, 2023 No. 5, 2024 No. 2, 2025 No. 4 and topic listinterpol.int
This page is general information, not legal advice. Summaries of CCF decisions do not replace their text; every case turns on its own facts.