Corporate dispute or criminal case: how the CCF tests a “raider” Red Notice
Two businessmen, two Red Notices, two applications to the Commission for the Control of INTERPOL’s Files with the same argument: “this is not a crime, it is a commercial conflict”. One Red Notice stayed. The other went. Here is why.
Published , reviewed . Reading time: 9 min.
The case where the notice stayed
At its 107th session (January–February 2019) the CCF examined a request from the former managing director of an export company, wanted on charges that included contraband and evasion of taxes and duties.1 His case was straightforward: the prosecution had grown out of a commercial conflict around a de facto market monopoly; the regulation had been designed to squeeze smaller players such as his firm; and the criminal case was simply a way of dealing with an inconvenient competitor through the police. He added that the authorities knew where he lived but had never sought his extradition, and that a court abroad had already refused to extradite an alleged accomplice.
The Commission accepted that the authorities may have protected a de facto monopoly and passed legislation unfavourable to smaller companies. That was not enough. The requesting National Central Bureau supplied judicial documents describing an organised scheme: transactions without the mandatory permits, concealment of the conduct, evasion of compulsory payments, and the role of each alleged accomplice in generating unlawful profit. The data was found compliant and the Red Notice stayed — with one correction: the contraband charge, for which prosecution had since been discontinued, had to be removed from the file.
…the mere fact that […] authorities may have participated in the protection of a de facto monopoly […] and that they enacted a legislation which was unfavourable to smaller companies […] does not in itself deprive the Applicant’s alleged acts of their criminal nature.
The other arguments failed too. The country’s nationals could not be extradited from the state where the applicant lived, so the absence of an extradition request there was explained. The refusal to extradite the accomplice rested on country-specific grounds — no extradition instrument in force at the time and a limitation period under that state’s law — which, the CCF held, said nothing about whether the Red Notice complied with INTERPOL’s rules.
The case where the notice was deleted
In June 2020 the CCF ordered the deletion of a Red Notice issued at the request of the United States for Yevgeny Prigozhin, who had been indicted in 2018 in connection with interference in the 2016 US presidential election. The CCF does not publish decisions with names; this one became public only because it leaked and was reported by The Intercept in November 2022, which found no sign that the document had been tampered with.2 On its face the charge — conspiracy to defraud the United States — belonged to ordinary criminal law, the same broad category as the charges in the first case.
According to the report, the Commission nonetheless found a predominant political dimension and concluded that the information provided by the US National Central Bureau did not meet the requirements of Article 3 of INTERPOL’s Constitution. Keeping the notice, it said, would have had significant adverse implications for the Organization’s neutrality. The CCF also stressed that its decision did not mean the US charges were unlawful.
What the CCF was really comparing
Both cases involved charges of an economic kind. But the Commission was asking two quite different questions — and that difference is exactly what anyone who says “my case is a corporate raid” needs to grasp.
Is there an organised scheme?
Do the facts show an organised criminal scheme, so that this is no longer just a commercial dispute? Rule: Art. 83(1)(a)(i) RPD.Does politics outweigh?
Does the political context outweigh the ordinary-law framing of the charge? Rule: Article 3 and the predominance test.Art. 83(1)(a)(i) RPDtext of the Rules
The first question. Article 83(1)(a)(i) of INTERPOL’s Rules on the Processing of Data bars Red Notices for offences deriving from private disputes or breaches of administrative rules — unless the criminal activity is aimed at facilitating a serious crime or is suspected of being connected to organised crime. That proviso is where many hopes founder. Showing that a business conflict lies behind the case is not enough; you have to show that the alleged conduct does not amount to a separately documented criminal offence.
Art. 3 Constitutioninterpol.int
The second question. Here Article 3 and the predominance test apply. The Commission was prepared to assume that the charge might belong to ordinary criminal law, yet treated the political weight of the case as decisive for INTERPOL’s neutrality. The method is set out in our article on the predominance test.
Practical lessons for real “raiding” cases
For clients from post-Soviet countries, where hostile takeovers driven by criminal prosecution are a familiar pattern, both decisions carry concrete lessons.
Does not work on its own
- A bare assertion of “raiding” — the Commission looks for a rebuttal of the specific elements of the charge: the organised nature of the scheme, the accomplices, the documented transactions
- A political or regulatory backdrop: regulation favouring certain players did not invalidate the charge, as the CCF said expressly
- One dramatic ground instead of several
Works
- Several grounds combined: in the case where the notice was deleted, what mattered was the political dimension the Commission recognised, not that the charge could be called economic
- A documented rebuttal of the specific facts alleged
- Defects in the request itself — a separate and often underrated ground
Art. 83(2)(b)(i) RPDsufficient judicial data
On defects in the request. Article 83(2)(b)(i) requires sufficient judicial data, including a succinct and clear description of the wanted person’s criminal activities, with time and place. In the 2019 decision the CCF read this as requiring the NCB to show facts linking the individual to the charges and demonstrating that the conduct is not merely private or administrative. Where such data is missing, there is a ground for challenge whether or not the private or political character of the case can be proved. For the procedure, see how the CCF works.
What a strong evidence file looks like in a corporate-raiding case
- Documents establishing the chronology of the corporate conflict before the criminal case was opened — who was in dispute with whom, when, and how quickly the prosecution followed.
- An analysis of whether the request meets Article 83(2)(b)(i): is there a real, detailed description of the alleged conduct, or only general wording?
- Where there is a political context (state-linked competitors, public statements by officials about the case), a full, separate Article 3 argument — not a passing mention.
- Evidence that others in the same business circle or sector were prosecuted in the same pattern.
- Expert evidence on the market or sector — but only in combination with a direct rebuttal of the specific facts, never as a stand-alone argument.
Distinguishing a legitimate prosecution from the use of criminal law as a weapon in a corporate takeover is work with the specific facts of the case, not with general statements about unfairness. If you suspect that a criminal case against you is tied to a corporate conflict, it is worth assessing early whether a comprehensive defence strategy is needed — one that coordinates the CCF application with lawful protection of assets and, where relevant, the question of asylum.
What we cannot promise
- That the CCF will accept a “commercial dispute” or Article 3 argument. As the 2019 decision shows, the Commission weighs the requesting country’s documents as well as yours.
- Shorter time limits than the CCF Statute sets — up to nine months for a deletion request from admissibility, extendable.
Questions
If the case genuinely grew out of a business conflict, will the Red Notice be deleted?
Not necessarily. A commercial background does not by itself strip a case of its criminal character. Under Article 83 of INTERPOL’s Rules on the Processing of Data, the exclusion for private disputes does not apply where the conduct is suspected of being connected to organised crime or aimed at facilitating a serious crime, and the CCF looks at whether the requesting country has shown that.
Can I argue both that the dispute is private and that the prosecution is politically motivated?
Yes. The two grounds do not exclude each other and the CCF can examine them side by side. But, as the two cases discussed here show, each needs its own, separately built body of evidence.
Related
Sources
This article is based on an anonymised CCF decision excerpt published by INTERPOL (2019), The Intercept’s report on the leaked 2020 CCF decision concerning Yevgeny Prigozhin, and the text of INTERPOL’s Rules on the Processing of Data. The CCF does not publish named decisions; details of the 2020 decision are as reported by The Intercept. Checked in October 2026.
- 1CCF, anonymised decision excerpt No. 3, 107th session (2019): Private matter, Lack of action for extraditioninterpol.int
- 2The Intercept, 11 November 2022: the leaked 2020 CCF decision deleting the Red Notice for Yevgeny Prigozhintheintercept.com
- 3INTERPOL’s Rules on the Processing of Data (RPD) — Articles 82, 83, 84 and 87interpol.int
- 4INTERPOL — Neutrality (Article 3 of the Constitution)interpol.int
This article is general information and does not constitute legal advice. Any specific case needs an analysis of its own facts.