Evidence of political persecution: what the CCF, courts and asylum authorities accept
“My case is political” is an argument all three forums hear: the Commission for the Control of INTERPOL’s Files (CCF), the court deciding on extradition, and the immigration authority. Each asks its own question and weighs evidence in its own way. This guide sets out which material carries more weight, which carries less, and how to prepare it so that it is actually read.
Published . Reading time 14 minutes.
Three forums, three different questions
The same bundle cannot be sent to all three forums without reworking: they test different things.
| CCF | Extradition court (Council of Europe states) | Asylum authority (EU) | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Core question | Does a political element predominate; do the data comply with INTERPOL’s rules? | Is there a real risk of treatment prohibited by Article 3 ECHR, or of a flagrantly unfair trial? | Is there a well-founded fear of persecution for political opinion or another ground? |
| Basis | Arts. 2 and 3 of the INTERPOL Constitution; Art. 34(3) RPD | Art. 3 ECHR and ECtHR case law; national extradition law | Regulation (EU) 2024/1347, applicable from 12 June 2026 |
| Who proves what | The applicant sets out arguments; the NCB responds; the Commission may seek information itself | The applicant adduces evidence of substantial grounds, then the state must dispel any doubts (J.K. and Others v. Sweden, § 91) | The applicant submits all elements available; if the Art. 4(5) conditions are met, unsupported details are accepted without further evidence |
| Form | Written only, through the portal, in one of four languages | Oral and written, under national procedure | Interview plus documents |
Sources: INTERPOL’s Repository of Practice on Articles 2 and 31, ECtHR J.K. and Others v. Sweden5, Regulation (EU) 2024/1347.8 More on the CCF’s method in “The predominance test”.
What weighs more: from decisions to impressions
Repository of Practice, para. 55seven elements of Art. 34(3) RPD
INTERPOL lists what it considers in an Article 3 review: the nature of the offence (the charges and underlying facts), the status of the persons concerned, the identity of the source of the data, the position expressed by another NCB or international entity, obligations under international law, the implications for the Organization’s neutrality and the general context of the case.1 That is your evidence map: each element needs its own document.
| Type of evidence | Weight | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Refugee status in another country | very high | Under INTERPOL’s refugee resolution, once status is confirmed, a notice or diffusion from the country the person fears is deleted |
| Another country’s court refusing extradition in the same case | high | An independent court has already analysed the same documents; the CCF also takes other states’ positions into account |
| Decisions of UN bodies or the ECtHR on you or co-accused | high | International-law obligations; findings on specific violations |
| The case documents | high | They show the charge, the chronology, the role — or its absence |
| UN, NGO and state reports on your category of case | medium | Important where they address your category of case directly and are corroborated |
| Expert reports | medium | Depend on the expert’s qualifications and the link to the facts |
| Media articles, general country reports | low on their own | Not persuasive by themselves; they work as corroboration |
The scale is our generalisation from the rules and published practice, not an official classification by any body.
The case documents
Start with what the state itself has issued. The charging decision shows exactly what is alleged: if the wording of the charge mentions posts, a picket, a donation, or involvement with an organisation declared “undesirable” or “extremist”, this is plain without any interpretation. If the charge is an ordinary one — fraud, embezzlement — the question is whether the personal role, intent and benefit are described. How to obtain these documents from abroad is covered in “Obtaining a Russian criminal case file”.
Separately, gather documents on the context: dates of public activity, a dismissal, a conflict with an official, a corporate dispute — and the dates of the procedural decisions. A chronology in which the case is opened right after a politically significant event is one of the clearest arguments.
A 2023 decision shows how someone else’s analysis of the documents works: the Commission relied on the findings of a foreign court that had refused extradition because the documents did not describe the applicant’s role, and deleted the data without even reaching the political-character argument.19 Published decision excerpts are collected on the Commission’s website2 and in our CCF decisions database.
Decisions of other states
GA-2017-86-RES-09INTERPOL refugee resolution
Refugee status. The 2017 INTERPOL General Assembly resolution provides that once a member country has confirmed a person’s refugee status, INTERPOL deletes any notice or diffusion requested by the country where the person fears persecution. If asylum is refused or status revoked, the data may be maintained or restored if they conform to the rules.3 The CCF portal expressly asks applicants to tick a “protective status” box for refugees and asylum seekers.4 A decision granting asylum is therefore the first thing to attach to a CCF request; if no decision has been made yet, attach proof of the application.
Refusal to extradite. A decision by another country’s court refusing extradition in the same case is a ready-made analysis of the evidence. Obtain the full reasoned text, not just the operative part, and translate it into the forum’s language.
INTERPOL refusals for related persons. If Red Notices against co-accused have been deleted or not published, say so, citing the decisions if the defence holds them.
International bodies
ECtHR, NA. v. the United Kingdom, §§ 119–121
The ECtHR assesses material from “reliable and objective sources” — other states, UN agencies, reputable NGOs. It considers the source’s independence, reliability and objectivity, the authority and reputation of the author, the seriousness of the investigations behind a report, the consistency of its conclusions and their corroboration by other sources. The Court gives particular weight to UN agencies because of their direct access to the authorities of the country concerned.6
What to look for: opinions of the UN Working Group on Arbitrary Detention10 and decisions of the UN Human Rights Committee on your case or those of co-accused; reports of the Office of the UN High Commissioner for Human Rights on Russia11; ECtHR judgments under comparable provisions. In a 2017 decision the CCF deleted the data where the applicant submitted national and international decisions finding fair-trial violations in the cases of his associates.20
ECtHR, NA. v. the United Kingdom, § 122
The closer a report is to the grounds of risk in the particular case, the more it weighs: the Court expressly distinguishes general assessments from reports that “directly address the grounds” of the alleged risk.6
NGOs and lists of persecuted people
PACE Resolution 1900 (2012)political prisoner criteria
“Political Prisoners Support. Memorial”. The project keeps lists of political prisoners based on the definition in PACE Resolution 1900 (2012): people prosecuted solely for exercising civil rights or for their convictions and views, and people prosecuted with serious breaches of the law or selectively, for the authorities’ political motives.12 As of 19 October 2026 the project’s list of political prisoners included 1,848 people.13
OVD-Info. The OVD-Info database collects information on people persecuted on political grounds — not only those deprived of liberty — by status and category of case.16 An entry in the database or an OVD-Info report on your case is independent confirmation of the facts and chronology.
International NGOs and states. Reports by Human Rights Watch and Amnesty International, and the US State Department’s country reports on human rights1718, show practice by category of case. In Saadi v. Italy the ECtHR relied on Amnesty International and Human Rights Watch reports, corroborated by a US State Department report.7
Media and general reports: corroboration, not foundation
Repository of Practicegeneral context
INTERPOL’s Repository of Practice states plainly that general information on a country’s human rights situation does not in itself lead to a denial of cooperation, though it helps to understand the context and identify what to scrutinise further.1 A 2024 decision illustrates this: the applicant’s arguments rested on a newspaper article and a general report with nothing specific to his case, while the NCB produced a court decision — the record was kept.21
A practical rule from the CCF portal: if a publication is freely available, give the link in the arguments summary and point to the relevant passage; attach a PDF only for material behind a paywall or requiring a log-in.4 Keep your own copy of every publication: pages get deleted, and independent media sites are blocked in Russia.
Expert reports
Three kinds of report come up most often:
- Country expert — a specialist in the country’s political and legal system who explains how particular articles are used there and what awaits a returnee. In an extradition court or an asylum case, such a report faces the same source test: qualifications, independence, reliance on verifiable data.6
- Legal analysis of the case — an opinion by a specialist in the country’s criminal law and procedure on whether the charge discloses an offence and what violations occurred. It is particularly useful for the CCF, which checks whether the person’s role is described.
- Linguistic report — in speech cases: what exactly was said and whether the text contains calls to action. It answers the prosecution’s own expert report, if there is one in the file.
The expert should disclose their qualifications, sources and who paid them for what. A report that simply repeats the applicant’s position usually adds no weight.
Your own account and witness statements
Art. 4(5), Regulation (EU) 2024/1347conditions for accepting without further evidence
In an asylum case the applicant’s own statements are the main evidence. Where particular aspects are not supported by documents, no further evidence is required for them if the applicant has made a genuine effort to substantiate the application, has submitted all available elements and explained the lack of others, their statements are coherent and plausible and do not run counter to available information, and their general credibility has been established, taking into account, among other things, when the application was made.8 The Regulation replaced Directive 2011/95/EU, repealed with effect from 12 June 2026.8
UNHCR Handbook, paras. 196, 203–204
The UNHCR Handbook takes the same approach: the duty to establish the facts is shared between the applicant and the examiner, and the applicant should be given the benefit of the doubt where the account is generally credible.9 The ECtHR recognises that gathering evidence from the country one has fled can be difficult, and that applicants frequently need to be given the benefit of the doubt when their statements and documents are assessed.5
The practical conclusion: the written account must match the documents in dates and details. Discrepancies between the asylum account, the CCF arguments and the position in extradition proceedings get noticed — and used against the applicant.
Translation and format
- CCF: the request and annexes must be in Arabic, English, French or Spanish; documents in other languages must be translated (Rule 30(3) of the Operating Rules)
- CCF: video and audio are not considered — only transcripts of the relevant passages
- CCF: the arguments summary may not exceed 10 pages and must list all annexes with a reference to each
- Courts and asylum authorities: requirements for translation (sworn or accredited translator) and apostilles depend on the country — check before filing
- For long documents, translate the key passages and attach the full original; mark the pages you rely on
- Render names and the names of authorities consistently across all documents and forums
The CCF portal’s detailed requirements are in “Documents for the CCF”.4
Building the dossier: the order of work
Chronology
Dates of public activity, conflicts, pressure and procedural decisions — in one table, with a document referenced for each row.
Case documents
Decisions opening the case, bringing charges, declaring a search, and the order for arrest in absentia — through an advocate in Russia.
Third-party decisions
Refugee status, extradition refusals, UN decisions, recognition of co-accused as political prisoners.
Context
UN and NGO reports on your category of case, media coverage of your case.
Expert reports
Only where there is a question that cannot be answered without an expert.
Translation and packaging
A separate bundle for each forum: language, length, index.
- No set of documents guarantees a decision. The CCF, courts and immigration authorities weigh the evidence independently.
- Genuine documents only. The file rests on genuine documents and verifiable sources; false information destroys both the case and the applicant’s credibility.
Questions
Are media articles enough to prove that a case is political?
Usually not. Publications confirm facts and chronology but decide little on their own. In a published 2024 CCF decision, a newspaper article and a general report with nothing specific lost out to a court decision produced by the NCB. You need a link to your case: documents, decisions, reports on your category of case.
I am not on Memorial’s list of political prisoners — does that hurt my case?
Not necessarily. The project recognises only people deprived of liberty as political prisoners, so those who have left are not listed. The recognition of co-accused in the same case, the project’s analysis under your article and an entry in the OVD-Info database can all help.
Does refugee status automatically remove a Red Notice?
Under INTERPOL’s refugee resolution, once a state confirms the status, INTERPOL deletes the notice or diffusion from the country the person fears. But the status must be confirmed, and if it is refused or revoked the data may be kept or restored. A CCF request attaching the asylum decision remains a necessary step.
Do all documents for the CCF have to be translated?
All annexes must be in one of INTERPOL’s working languages — Arabic, English, French or Spanish — or translated into one. The Commission does not consider video or audio: attach a transcript of the relevant passages.
Can one dossier be used for asylum, the CCF and an extradition court?
The core can be shared — the chronology, case documents, third-country decisions. But each forum asks its own question and has its own formal requirements, so the bundle is reworked for each, making sure the positions do not contradict one another.
Further reading
Sources
- 1INTERPOL — Repository of Practice on Articles 2 and 3 of the Constitution, November 2024 update, paras. 32, 55interpol.int
- 2CCF — sessions and published decision excerptsinterpol.int
- 3INTERPOL — Refugee Resolution GA-2017-86-RES-09interpol.int
- 4CCF Portal User Guide for Applicants (March 2026), section 10.2interpol.int
- 5ECtHR, J.K. and Others v. Sweden [GC], 23.08.2016, §§ 91–98hudoc.echr.coe.int
- 6ECtHR, NA. v. the United Kingdom, 17.07.2008, §§ 119–122hudoc.echr.coe.int
- 7ECtHR, Saadi v. Italy [GC], 28.02.2008, §§ 128–129, 143hudoc.echr.coe.int
- 8Regulation (EU) 2024/1347 on qualification, Arts. 4, 9, 41, 42eur-lex.europa.eu
- 9UNHCR — Handbook on Procedures and Criteria for Determining Refugee Status (2019 reissue)unhcr.org
- 10UN — Working Group on Arbitrary Detentionohchr.org
- 11OHCHR — Russian Federation: reports and documentsohchr.org
- 12Political Prisoners Support. Memorial — who political prisoners are (in Russian)memopzk.org
- 13Political Prisoners Support. Memorial — lists of the persecuted (data as of 19.10.2026, in Russian)memopzk.org
- 14Memorial, 14.03.2024 — what is needed for the project to recognise a political prisoner (in Russian)memopzk.org
- 15Memorial, 13.05.2026 — “We are ‘extremists’”: frequently asked questions (in Russian)memopzk.org
- 16OVD-Info — lists of people persecuted on political grounds (in Russian)ovd.info
- 17Human Rights Watch — Russiahrw.org
- 18US State Department — 2023 Country Report on Human Rights Practices: Russiastate.gov
- 19CCF, decision excerpt No. 1 of 2023 (extradition refusal, description of criminal activities)interpol.int
- 20CCF, decision excerpt No. 5 of 2017 (trial in absentia, political character)interpol.int
- 21CCF, decision excerpt No. 3 of 2024 (Article 3, SLTD database)interpol.int
This material is general information, not legal advice. The weight of evidence is assessed by the forum hearing the case and depends on the facts and the law of the country concerned.