Political asylum: 40 countries compared
Forty national asylum systems: 24 EU member states, eight European countries outside the Union (from the United Kingdom and Norway to Georgia, Armenia and Türkiye), six countries in the Americas, Australia and New Zealand. This page sets out what separates them: who decides, where and within what time an appeal must be lodged, which deadlines run even before a claim is made, and what happens when an extradition request or a Red Notice is in play at the same time. Details and sources are on each country page.
Three legal regimes
The first thing that shapes a case is whose rules apply in the country: the common European ones, part of them, or national law alone.
Regs (EU) 2024/1347, 2024/1348, 2024/1351apply from 12.06.2026
The EU Pact
AMMR, APR, Qualification RegulationPart of the Pact
AMMR, Eurodac, screening- Denmark: AMMR and Eurodac by agreement with the EU (Act No. 726 of 01.09.2026); the Procedures and Qualification Regulations do not apply
- Norway, under the 2001 Dublin agreement and as a Schengen associate
- Switzerland, as a state associated with Schengen and Dublin
National law only
The 1951 Convention and domestic statutes- Europe: United Kingdom (Immigration Rules, Part 11), Armenia, Georgia, Montenegro, Serbia, Türkiye
- Americas: United States (INA §208), Canada (IRPA), Argentina, Brazil, Mexico, Uruguay
- Oceania: Australia, New Zealand
For new claims, Regulation (EU) 2024/1351 on asylum and migration management (AMMR) replaced Dublin III in deciding which state examines a claim, and Regulation 2024/1348 (APR) introduced a common procedure, including a border procedure.12 Claims registered before 12 June 2026 are still allocated under the Dublin III criteria. Anyone who passed through another Dublin state before reaching Denmark, Norway or Switzerland falls under the same AMMR responsibility rules, but who qualifies as a refugee and how the interview is run are still governed there by national law.
The regulations apply directly, but national law has not been rewritten everywhere. In Lithuania the Pact transition law was still before the Seimas on 21 October 2026, in Latvia the new Asylum Law is a draft (screening and the return border procedure came with the Immigration Law in force since 15.09.2026), and Slovenia has no transition act at all; some deadlines there are therefore contested, and the period stated in the decision itself is the guide. In the countries with national law only, from Serbia and Türkiye to Georgia, the Pact, the AMMR and SIS alerts do not apply, but in the European countries of that group the European Convention on Human Rights does.
Who decides, and how long you have to appeal
The appeal period is usually shorter than people expect, and in accelerated procedures it shrinks to a few days. Missing it often shuts out judicial review altogether. The tables are grouped by region: EU, Europe outside the EU, the Americas, Oceania.
EU member states
| Country | First instance | Appeal | Appeal deadline |
|---|---|---|---|
| Austria | BFA, Federal Office for Immigration and Asylum | BVwG, the only court of fact, with full jurisdiction | 4 weeks; 2 weeks for certain inadmissibility decisions |
| Belgium | CGRS / CGVS, an independent federal body | CALL: full review, can grant status itself | 30 days; 10 (sometimes 5) in accelerated cases |
| Bulgaria | State Agency for Refugees (SAR) | Administrative court; cassation to the Supreme Administrative Court, not in every case | 14 days; 7 in the accelerated procedure Art. 84 LAR |
| Croatia | Ministry of the Interior, International Protection Procedures Department | Administrative Court, then the High Administrative Court | 30 days; 8 days; 5 working days at the border |
| Cyprus | Asylum Service; claims lodged through the police AIU | IPAC, then the Administrative Court of Appeal: 14 days, points of law only | 20 or 10 days s. 12A, Law 73(I)/2018 |
| Czechia | Ministry of the Interior, Department of Asylum and Migration Policy (OAMP) | Regional court, then cassation to the Supreme Administrative Court (NSS) | 10 or 15 days § 32a; cassation 2 weeks |
| Denmark | Danish Immigration Service (Udlændingestyrelsen) | Refugee Appeals Board (Flygtningenævnet); its decision is final, no court review of the merits | a refusal in the normal procedure is appealed automatically; AMMR transfer decisions: 7 days § 53 a(2) |
| Estonia | Police and Border Guard Board (PPA) | Administrative court | 14 days; 5 in the accelerated and border procedures § 41 |
| Finland | Finnish Immigration Service (Migri) | Administrative court, then the Supreme Administrative Court (KHO) with leave | 30 days; 10 in accelerated cases s. 190 c |
| France | OFPRA; legal target 6 months | CNDA | 1 month; 10 days for some decisions |
| Germany | BAMF, after a personal hearing (Anhörung) | Verwaltungsgericht → OVG/VGH → BVerwG | 2 weeks; 1 week if “manifestly unfounded” § 74 AsylG |
| Greece | Asylum Service (Υπηρεσία Ασύλου) | Independent Appeals Committees, then an annulment application to the administrative court within 30 days | 30 or 10 days Art. 135 |
| Ireland | International Protection Office (IPO) | TARA, then judicial review in the High Court: 28 days | 1 month; 10 days in the accelerated and border procedures s. 187 |
| Italy | Territorial Commission (Commissione Territoriale) | Specialised court section, then cassation | 30 days; 7 accelerated, 5 border procedure |
| Latvia | PMLP, Office of Citizenship and Migration Affairs | District Administrative Court, the only instance | 1 month on the merits; 15 or 5 working days for some decisions s. 48(4); the law has not yet been aligned with the Pact, so go by the period stated in the decision |
| Lithuania | Migration Department under the Ministry of the Interior | Vilnius Regional Administrative Court, then the Supreme Administrative Court: 14 days | 14 days, 7 during the emergency; the Pact transition law has not been adopted, so deadlines may change |
| Luxembourg | Minister for Home Affairs, Directorate-General of Immigration | Administrative Tribunal, then the Administrative Court: 15 days, merits refusals only | 20 days; 10 in accelerated cases Art. 31 |
| Netherlands | IND, Immigration and Naturalisation Service | District court (rechtbank), then the Raad van State: 4 or 2 weeks | 2 weeks; 1 week for inadmissibility, manifestly unfounded claims and AMMR transfers Art. 69 Vw |
| Poland | Office for Foreigners (Urząd do Spraw Cudzoziemców) | Refugee Board; four levels in all, up to the Supreme Administrative Court | 14 days |
| Romania | IGI, Directorate for Asylum and Integration | District court (judecătorie), then the tribunal: 5 days from pronouncement | 10 days Art. 55; 7 in the accelerated procedure |
| Slovakia | Migration Office of the Ministry of Interior (Migračný úrad) | Administrative Court in Bratislava or Košice, then the Supreme Administrative Court | 1 month, 10 or 7 days § 211 SSP |
| Slovenia | Ministry of the Interior and Public Administration, Migration Office | Administrative Court in Ljubljana, then the Supreme Court | 15 days; 3 days in accelerated cases, contested after 12.06.2026 since the Regulation requires at least 5 |
| Spain | OAR (Ministry of the Interior); proposal by CIAR | Audiencia Nacional; cassation in the Tribunal Supremo | 2 months for the court action; optional reposición 1 month Art. 46 LJCA |
| Sweden | Migrationsverket, the Swedish Migration Agency | Migration court, then Migrationsöverdomstolen (leave required) | 3 weeks, lodged with Migrationsverket s. 44 FL |
Europe outside the EU
| Country | First instance | Appeal | Appeal deadline |
|---|---|---|---|
| Armenia | Migration and Citizenship Service (MCS), Ministry of Internal Affairs | Administrative Court → Administrative Court of Appeals → Court of Cassation | 2 months; 10 working days in extradition cases. UNHCR guidance is inconsistent, so count on the shorter period |
| Georgia | Migration Department, Ministry of Internal Affairs | Tbilisi City Court, then the Court of Appeals | 10 calendar days Art. 55(1); 7 for inadmissibility and the border procedure |
| Montenegro | Directorate for Asylum (Direkcija za azil), Ministry of the Interior | Administrative Court of Montenegro (Upravni sud) | 15 days from service Arts 47, 48 |
| Norway | UDI | Immigration Appeals Board (UNE) | 3 weeks |
| Serbia | Asylum Office of the Ministry of Interior (Kancelarija za azil) | Asylum Commission, then the Administrative Court within 30 days | 15 days; 8 accelerated, 5 at the border Art. 95 |
| Switzerland | State Secretariat for Migration (SEM) | Federal Administrative Court (BVGer) | 7 working days or 30 days, depending on the procedure |
| Türkiye | PMM (Göç İdaresi Başkanlığı) and its provincial directorates | Administrative court | 30 days; 15 in the accelerated procedure Art. 80(1)(ç); 7 days to challenge deportation |
| United Kingdom | Home Office | First-tier Tribunal | 14 days |
The Americas
| Country | First instance | Appeal | Appeal deadline |
|---|---|---|---|
| Argentina | National Commission for Refugees (CONARE) | Direct judicial appeal to the Federal Court of Appeals, signed by a lawyer; the hierarchical appeal to the Minister was abolished by Decree 942/2024 | 5 working days Art. 50 |
| Brazil | National Committee for Refugees (CONARE), Ministry of Justice | Minister of Justice; the decision is administratively final | 15 days Art. 29 |
| Canada | IRB, Refugee Protection Division (RPD) | RAD, then the Federal Court with leave | 15 days to the RAD; 15 days to the Federal Court |
| Mexico | Mexican Commission for Refugee Assistance (COMAR) | Recurso de revisión; amparo remains available in parallel | 15 working days Art. 25 |
| United States | USCIS (affirmative) or an EOIR immigration judge (in removal proceedings) | BIA, then the federal court of appeals | 30 days to the BIA; 30 days to the court of appeals |
| Uruguay | Refugee Commission (CORE), Foreign Ministry | Revocación before CORE plus a hierarchical appeal to the Minister, then the Administrative Disputes Tribunal (TCA) | 10 days Art. 40 |
Oceania
| Country | First instance | Appeal | Appeal deadline |
|---|---|---|---|
| Australia | Department of Home Affairs | Administrative Review Tribunal (ART), then the Federal Circuit and Family Court within 35 days | 28 days; 14 in detention |
| New Zealand | Refugee Status Unit, Immigration New Zealand | Immigration and Protection Tribunal, then the High Court within 28 days, points of law only, with leave | 10 working days; 5 in detention |
From the country cards in this section, checked 18.10.2026. Deadlines depend on the procedure and the decision; the exact period is stated in the decision itself.
Deadlines that run before you even apply
In six countries in this section the law ties the right to have a claim examined, or to the normal procedure, to how quickly the person applied or filed the papers.
Art. 50Aliens Act 1980
Belgium: 8 working days
The claim must be made within eight working days of arrival. Registration and Annex 26
IRPA s. 101(1)(b.1)one-year rule
Canada: one year from first entry
A claim made more than a year after first entry is ineligible, one of the five gates that decide whether there will be a hearing at all. Eligibility bars
CESEDAOFPRA form
France: 21 days for the form
After registration at the GUDA, the OFPRA form is completed within 21 calendar days, in French, together with the written personal account (récit). The récit personnel
Art. 32(1)Georgian law of 2025
Georgia: 30 days after entry
A claim made more than 30 days after entry without good reason goes to the accelerated procedure, and a refusal there allows removal and extradition before the court has ruled. The 30-day rule
Art. 18Ley sobre Refugiados
Mexico: 30 working days
The claim to COMAR must be filed within 30 working days of entry, or of the point when filing became possible. Deadlines in Mexico
INA §208(a)(2)(B)one-year deadline
United States: one year after last arrival
Form I-589 must be filed within a year of the last arrival; missing it is the most common way the right to asylum is lost. The one-year deadline
Asylum, extradition and Red Notices
For people wanted by their own state, an asylum case almost never runs alone. The country pages in this section reach the same conclusion: an INTERPOL notice does not prevent a claim, but it changes how the claim is examined.
A Red Notice may support the account of persecution, but the asylum authority will examine the charge itself, and the applicant will have to show why the prosecution amounts to persecution rather than legitimate law enforcement.
Art. 1F(b) 1951 Conventionserious non-political crime
Serious crimes can lead to exclusion from protection under Article 1F(b) of the Refugee Convention.6 Criminal cases at home should therefore be disclosed, including those you consider politically motivated: concealment damages credibility far more than the facts themselves, and evidence of political motivation can become part of the claim. In the United States, a prosecution that is in reality political does not fall under the “serious non-political crime” bar, while a conviction for a particularly serious crime closes off both asylum and withholding of removal.
Art. 10 APRReg. (EU) 2024/1348
In EU states an applicant may be extradited to a third country during the procedure only if the authorities are satisfied that this will not lead to direct or indirect refoulement to the country of persecution.2 Some states have written that exception into their law; others have gone the other way and barred the extradition of applicants altogether. Both groups are set out below.
Where a claim or status blocks extradition
| Country | Provision | What happens to extradition |
|---|---|---|
| Spain | Arts. 19.2, 19.3 Ley 12/2009 | A claim suspends execution of an extradition decision until the asylum claim is finally decided; the court or authority handling the extradition must be told. Surrender to another EU state under a European Arrest Warrant is not suspended.3 |
| Czechia | § 27(2), § 3d(1)(d) Act 325/1999 Coll.; § 91 Act 104/2013 Coll. | Where extradition is pending, the Ministry gives the claim priority and decides within 90 days. Extradition is barred for a person granted international protection, to the extent of that protection. The right to remain during the procedure is not lost where the extradition request comes from the country of nationality.4 |
| Slovakia | § 501(b) Trestný poriadok as amended by Act 69/2026 Coll. | Extradition is barred for a person who has applied for or been granted international protection, to the extent of that protection. This does not apply to a repeat application after a final decision on the earlier one.8 |
| Romania | Arts. 6(1), 6(2), 76(3)(e) Law 122/2006 | During the procedure an applicant may not be extradited, expelled or returned from the border, save in the cases under Art. 44 of the counter-terrorism Law 535/2004. Protection continues after recognition. A claim made plainly to delay an imminent extradition goes to the accelerated procedure.9 |
| Croatia | Arts. 7(1), 7(2), 7(4), 53(4) Protection Act | Extradition to the country of origin is not carried out until the decision on the claim is enforceable. A claim does not stop surrender under a European Arrest Warrant or extradition to a third country without a refoulement risk, and there is no right to remain meanwhile.10 |
| Montenegro | Arts. 12(5), 12(6) Law on Protection of Foreigners | Extradition to the country of origin is barred until the decision on the claim is final, including the time for a court action. A person already in extradition proceedings has 5 days instead of 15 to lodge the claim. Extradition to a third country or under a European Arrest Warrant is not stopped.11 |
| Brazil | Arts. 33–35 Law 9.474/1997 | A claim suspends any extradition proceeding based on the same facts until a final decision; recognition bars further examination of the request. The body handling the extradition is notified of the claim.12 |
| Argentina | Arts. 14, 15 Law 26.165; Art. 41.3 Decree 646/2025 | A claim suspends execution of an extradition decision until status is finally decided, though the court still hears the case; recognition ends extradition to the country of nationality. Where extradition is pending, CONARE decides within 10 working days.1314 |
| Uruguay | Art. 41 Law 18.076 | Final recognition as a refugee means automatic refusal of extradition. Where extradition of an applicant is sought, the judge first decides on status, after an opinion from CORE, and only then on extradition.15 |
Where extradition triggers special time limits
| Country | Provision | What happens to extradition |
|---|---|---|
| Canada | IRPA s. 105 | Once an authority to proceed has been issued for an offence with a maximum of 10 years or more, the IRB suspends the claim; a surrender order by the Minister of Justice is treated as a rejection under Art. 1F(b). A claim not made before the surrender order can no longer be made before surrender.5 |
| Georgia | Arts. 26(3)–(4), 32(6), 37(10) Law of 2025 | A person detained on an extradition request has 10 calendar days to claim; a late claim without good reason is not accepted and does not hold up extradition. The decision comes within a month. After a refusal in the accelerated procedure extradition is allowed at once, even while the court case is pending.16 |
| Mexico | Art. 53 Ley sobre Refugiados | The Foreign Ministry notifies COMAR of an extradition request within 5 working days; COMAR gives the judge an opinion on whether extradition is compatible with non-refoulement and decides any pending claim within 10 working days.17 |
Where a claim does not stop extradition
| Country | Provision | What happens to extradition |
|---|---|---|
| Bulgaria | Art. 29(12) LAR | A foreigner subject to extradition or surrender under a European Arrest Warrant has no right to remain during the procedure. What has to be challenged is the finding that extradition will not lead to refoulement.18 |
| Ireland | s. 68(b)(i) International Protection Act 2026 | A person being extradited or surrendered to another state, a third country or an international court has no right to remain; non-refoulement is preserved, but it is decided in the extradition proceedings.19 |
| Luxembourg | Art. 20, Law of 11.06.2026 | A person being extradited to another EU state, a third country or an international court has no right to remain while the claim is examined; the defence in the extradition proceedings becomes the main line.20 |
| United Kingdom | Extradition Act 2003 | The asylum case and the extradition case run on separate tracks. |
In Canada the Federal Court has held it an error to treat a Red Notice alone as sufficient for exclusion under Art. 1F(b) (Rihan, 2010 FC 123). A CCF decision does not bind the IRB, but an RPD member will weigh it with the rest of the evidence. For the other countries in this section the country pages cite no express rule linking the two procedures: the persecution arguments are made both in the asylum case and before the extradition court.
Three tracks that run at the same time
Asylum
Protection against return to the country of persecution. In Czechia and Slovakia protection expressly bars extradition within its scope; in Spain and Brazil a claim suspends extradition; in Uruguay recognition as a refugee means extradition is refused.Extradition defence
An asylum claim does not replace the defence in extradition proceedings; it adds to it. Where removal is imminent and the risk serious: Rule 39 interim measures of the ECtHR and the bar on return where there is a risk of torture.The notice itself
INTERPOL’s own rules restrict processing data on recognised refugees at the request of the country they fled.7 Start by finding out what is held about you: an access request.In this section
EU member states
- Austria: the BFA and a single court of fact (BVwG)country guide
- Belgium: the CGRS decides, the CALL reviews in fullcountry guide
- Bulgaria: SAR, a 2002 law under the EU Pact, and extraditioncountry guide
- Croatia: transit, SOA assessments and deadlines after NN 59/26country guide
- Cyprus: IPAC, 20 and 10 days to file, asylum when Russia seeks extraditioncountry guide
- Czechia: Act 325/1999 Coll. after 12.06.2026 and extraditioncountry guide
- Denmark: Refugee Appeals Board, § 7 and AMMR by agreementcountry guide
- Estonia: the 2026 protection act and practice for Russianscountry guide
- Finland: closed eastern border, Migri and deadlines after 12.06.2026country guide
- France: OFPRA, the written account and the CNDAcountry guide
- Germany: the BAMF, the Anhörung and the administrative courtscountry guide
- Greece: Law 5307/2026, two appeal tiers and extraditioncountry guide
- Ireland: the 2026 Act, the IPO and TARAcountry guide
- Italy: Territorial Commissions and specialised courtscountry guide
- Latvia: one judicial instance and a draft new lawcountry guide
- Lithuania: the Belarus border, the sanctions law and the EU Pactcountry guide
- Luxembourg: the law of 11.06.2026 and appeal deadlinescountry guide
- Netherlands: the IND, A and B status, Raad van Statecountry guide
- Poland: the Belarus border, the AMMR and four instancescountry guide
- Romania: Article 6 of Law 122/2006, IGI and extradition to Russiacountry guide
- Slovakia: new Act 69/2026 Coll. and no extradition of applicantscountry guide
- Slovenia: ZMZ-1 and EU regulations without a transposition actcountry guide
- Spain: OAR, CIAR, the Audiencia Nacional and Art. 19.2 Ley 12/2009country guide
- Sweden: Migrationsverket, migration courts and the 2025–26 reformscountry guide
Europe outside the EU
- Armenia: the MCS, 10 working days in extradition cases and Gyumricountry guide
- Georgia: the new international protection law and extraditioncountry guide
- Montenegro: Directorate for Asylum, Art. 12 and extraditioncountry guide
- Norway: UDI, UNE and the EU Pact in a non-EU statecountry guide
- Serbia: the 2018 Act, zero recognitions of Russians and extraditioncountry guide
- Switzerland: SEM, the accelerated procedure and the Federal Administrative Courtcountry guide
- Türkiye: geographical limitation, 7/15/30-day deadlines and deportationcountry guide
- United Kingdom: the 2026 reform, the Home Office and the First-tier Tribunalcountry guide
The Americas
- Argentina: CONARE, Decree 646/2025 and extradition to Russiacountry guide
- Brazil: Law 9.474/1997, CONARE and extradition to Russiacountry guide
- Canada: eligibility bars, the IRB, Red Notices and 1F(b)country guide
- Mexico: COMAR, 30 working days and deportation instead of extraditioncountry guide
- United States: INA §208, the one-year deadline, USCIS and the courtscountry guide
- Uruguay: Law 18.076, the appeal route and extraditioncountry guide
Oceania
- Australia: protection visa 866, the ART and the Extradition Act 1988country guide
- New Zealand: Immigration Act 2009, the Refugee Status Unit and the IPTcountry guide
Articles and law
Primary sources
- 1Regulation (EU) 2024/1351 on asylum and migration management (AMMR)eur-lex.europa.eu
- 2Regulation (EU) 2024/1348 on the asylum procedure (APR), Art. 10eur-lex.europa.eu
- 3Ley 12/2009 reguladora del derecho de asilo y de la protección subsidiaria, Art. 19boe.es
- 4Act No. 325/1999 Coll. on Asylum, as in force from 12.06.2026krajta.slv.cz
- 5Immigration and Refugee Protection Act, s. 105 (Extradition procedure)laws-lois.justice.gc.ca
- 61951 Convention relating to the Status of Refugees and 1967 Protocolunhcr.org
- 7INTERPOL Refugee Resolutioninterpol.int
- 8Act No. 69/2026 Coll. on international protection, Art. III (§ 501 Trestný poriadok)slov-lex.sk
- 9Law No. 122/2006 on asylum in Romania, Arts. 6, 76legislatie.just.ro
- 10Act on International and Temporary Protection (NN 70/15 … 59/26), Arts. 7, 53zakon.hr
- 11Law on International and Temporary Protection of Foreigners (Sl. list CG 2/2017, 3/2019, 77/2024), Art. 12natlex.ilo.org
- 12Law No. 9.474/1997, Arts. 33–35planalto.gov.br
- 13Law 26.165 on the Recognition and Protection of Refugees, Arts. 14, 15argentina.gob.ar
- 14Decree 646/2025 regulating Law 26.165, Art. 41argentina.gob.ar
- 15Law No. 18.076 on the right to refuge and refugees, Art. 41uruguay.justia.com
- 16Law of Georgia on International Protection of 26.06.2025, Arts. 26, 32, 37matsne.gov.ge
- 17Ley sobre Refugiados, Protección Complementaria y Asilo Político, Arts. 18, 53diputados.gob.mx
- 18Law on Asylum and Refugees (Bulgaria), Art. 29lex.bg
- 19International Protection Act 2026, s. 68irishstatutebook.ie
- 20Law of 11 June 2026 implementing the European Pact on Migration and Asylum, Art. 20legilux.public.lu
This overview is compiled from the country pages in this section; the law, practice and official statistics for each country are there, with links to primary sources. General information, not legal advice: asylum authorities and courts decide, and no outcome is guaranteed in advance.