Extradition from Portugal to Russia and Belarus
The Portuguese procedure has two phases: first the Minister of Justice decides whether the request may proceed, then the Court of Appeal decides whether extradition is admissible. The Constitution bars extradition on political grounds and restricts it where a life sentence is at stake, and the statute sets custody limits in days. How it works, and what the case of Arkady Bunin teaches.
Two phases and the time limits of each
Extradition proceedings are urgent and run even during court vacations. The administrative phase belongs to the Minister of Justice; the judicial phase is the exclusive competence of the Court of Appeal (Tribunal da Relação) for the district where the person is.1
Art. 46(2)Law 144/99
The minister filters requests at the door
The Minister of Justice decides, having regard to any guarantees required, whether the request may proceed or must be rejected outright “for political reasons or reasons of expediency or convenience”.1 This is not an appeal but a separate point at which the defence can put its case before any court is involved.
Arts. 46(3), 558 days
The court does not try the charges
The Court of Appeal checks the formal and substantive conditions for extradition, but no evidence on the alleged facts is admitted. Written opposition is filed within 8 days of the hearing and may rest on only two grounds: the wrong person has been detained, or the conditions for extradition are not met; no more than 10 witnesses.1
Arts. 49, 58suspensive
Appeal to the Supreme Court
Only the final decision can be appealed, within 10 days, to the criminal section of the Supreme Court of Justice (Supremo Tribunal de Justiça). An appeal against a decision granting extradition suspends it. A further application to the Constitutional Court is possible.1
Custody: every limit is written into the statute
Once a limit expires, custody ends or is replaced with another coercive measure — a duty, not a matter of the court’s discretion.1
| Provision | Limit | What happens |
|---|---|---|
| Arts. 39, 64 | — | The police may detain a person whom official information, including INTERPOL’s, shows to be wanted by foreign authorities |
| Arts. 53, 62, 64 | 48 hours | Brought before the prosecutor at the Court of Appeal for a hearing by the judge and a decision on continued detention |
| Arts. 38(5), 64(3) | 18 / 40 days | Release if the requesting state has not confirmed that a request will follow (18 days) or the request has not arrived (40 days) |
| Art. 63(1), (3) | 15 / 60 days | The administrative phase for a detained person takes no more than 15 days; if the request is not filed in court within 60 days of arrest, custody is replaced with another measure |
| Art. 52(1)–(2) | 65 + 25 days | Decision of the Court of Appeal; the 25-day extension applies only where no non-custodial measure is possible |
| Art. 52(3)–(4) | 80 days / 3 months | Custody cap during an appeal to the Supreme Court / to the Constitutional Court |
| Arts. 60–61 | 20 + 20 days | Surrender no later than 20 days after the decision becomes final; if nobody collects the person, release 20 days after the agreed date |
Arts. 38(6), 41Portuguese CCP
Constitution and statute: when extradition is impossible
Extradition, or surrender on any basis whatsoever, shall not be permitted for political reasons, or for crimes that are punishable under the law of the requesting state by death or by any other penalty resulting in irreversible harm to physical integrity.
Const. Art. 33(4)reservation to the 1957 Convention
Life imprisonment is the key argument against Russian requests
For crimes punishable by life imprisonment, extradition is allowed only if the requesting state is bound to Portugal by a relevant treaty and guarantees that such a penalty will not be imposed or enforced.6 In its reservation to the 1957 Convention Portugal declared that it does not extradite for such offences; Russia objected to that reservation.5 The Russian Criminal Code retains life imprisonment for a number of serious offences — aggravated murder under Art. 105(2), for example — so the question of guarantees arises in every such case.
Arts. 6, 7Law 144/99
Mandatory refusals
A request is refused if the proceedings do not meet the requirements of the ECHR; if there are substantial grounds to believe the person is pursued because of race, religion, sex, nationality, language, political or ideological convictions; if trial by an exceptional court is threatened; if the offence is political or purely military; or if reciprocity is not assured.1
Arts. 8, 18(2)Law 144/99
Ne bis in idem and humanitarian grounds
Extradition is not allowed where proceedings for the same facts ended in acquittal, discontinuance or a sentence already served. It may also be refused where it would have serious consequences because of age, health or other personal reasons.1
Art. 32(6)time of decision
Nationality is assessed at the time of the decision
Portuguese citizens are extradited only under a treaty, for terrorism or international organised crime, and with fair-trial guarantees. Crucially, nationality is assessed when the extradition decision is taken, not at the time of the offence or of arrest.16 If extradition is refused on nationality grounds, Portugal itself opens criminal proceedings on the same facts (Art. 32(5)).
Arkady Bunin: three courts in favour, and a way out through citizenship
Timeline from Executive Digest, citing Jornal de Notícias.7 We found no publicly available court decisions, so we do not give dates for the individual instances.
- 2011Albufeira
Move to Portugal
The Russian businessman settled in the south of the country with his wife and three children.
- 2013Russia
The charge
Russian authorities accused him of organising the 2007 kidnapping of a contractor who was later murdered near Kaliningrad.
- 2014arrest
Arrested as internationally wanted
He was wanted through INTERPOL. Because Russia did not formalise its request within the statutory time limit, custody was replaced with weekly reporting to the SEF immigration service.
- before 2022courts
Évora, the Supreme Court and the Constitutional Court
The Évora Court of Appeal, the Supreme Court and the Constitutional Court all ruled in favour of extradition.
- VIII.2022outcome
Citizenship and the end of the case
While his surrender was being prepared, Bunin acquired Portuguese citizenship and had the proceedings closed. He also applied to the ECtHR, citing the risk to his life and inhuman conditions in Russian prisons.
- Portuguese courts do not treat a Russian request as unenforceable per se. Three instances in a row allowed extradition — risks must be proved, not merely asserted.
- Time limits work for the defence. A request not formalised in time cost the requesting state its custody order.
- The person’s status on the date of decision matters. That applies to citizenship and, in practice, to protection granted in asylum proceedings.
Belarus, Central Asia and the Caucasus
No treaty, and the EU line applies
Belarus is not a party to the 1957 Convention;5 the statute requires reciprocity (Art. 6(4)), and since 2022 requests from Minsk are not processed save for case-by-case exceptions.8 We found no extraditions to Belarus since 2022.Law 144/99 and reciprocity
No state in the region is a party to the 1957 Convention.5 There is no reliable data on Portuguese practice since 2022. ECtHR interim measures under Rule 39 are binding on Portugal.4The 1957 Convention
All three are parties to the Convention.5 We found no data on extradition practice from Portugal since 2022.Portugal is in the Schengen area. An SIS alert issued by another EU state leads to surrender under the European Arrest Warrant, with no ministerial phase; see the EAW reference page. Article 33(8) of the Constitution guarantees asylum to those persecuted for their activity in defence of democracy, freedom and human rights;6 an asylum claim and the extradition defence are prepared together — see our asylum service.
Arrested in Lisbon or Faro: the first 48 hours
The tightest limits in the Portuguese procedure fall in the first days.
Arts. 53, 5448 hours
The hearing before the judge — with a lawyer and an interpreter
The rapporteur judge establishes your identity and explains your right to oppose extradition or to consent to it. If you have no lawyer of your own, one is appointed.
Art. 40(4)irrevocable
Do not consent to extradition
Consent approved by the judge cannot be withdrawn and is equivalent to the final decision in the case.
Art. 558 days
Prepare the opposition at once
You have eight days after the hearing for the written case, evidence and list of witnesses. Documents from Russia, translations and expert opinions must be gathered from day one.
Art. 46(2)minister
Address the minister
While the request is in the administrative phase, arguments on the political nature of the case can be put to the Minister of Justice.
Parallel tracks
An access request to the Commission for the Control of INTERPOL’s Files (CCF), and where needed asylum and an ECtHR application. Portugal also accepts individual complaints to the UN Committee against Torture.9
How we run a Portuguese case
- Analysis of the request: penalties, the risk of a life sentence, limitation
- A file on the political nature of the prosecution, translated into Portuguese
- Before a Portuguese court our partner advocate admitted there appears
- Monitoring custody limits under Arts. 38, 52, 63 and 64
- The CCF, asylum and the ECtHR — where the case requires them
What we do not promise
- No outcome is guaranteed. The decision belongs to the Minister of Justice and the Portuguese courts.
- The EU’s 2022 political agreement does not repeal the statute. It leaves room for case-by-case exceptions.
- Practice since 2022 is unpublished. Chances can only be assessed on the case documents.
Frequently asked questions
Does Portugal extradite Russians now?
Since 2022 EU states have agreed not to process Russian requests save for case-by-case exceptions, and we found no extraditions to Russia since then. But the 1957 Convention still applies, and before 2022 Portuguese courts did allow extradition. Arrest on a Red Notice remains possible.
How long can I be held after an INTERPOL arrest?
If no request arrives, release follows after 18 or 40 days. Once the request has arrived, the Court of Appeal must decide within 65 days, extendable by 25; during an appeal to the Supreme Court custody may not exceed 80 days. You can ask for another coercive measure instead of custody.
Will Portuguese citizenship protect me?
Portuguese citizens are extradited only for terrorism or international organised crime under a treaty and with fair-trial guarantees. Nationality is assessed when the extradition decision is taken. In that case Portugal may prosecute the same facts itself.
I face life imprisonment in Russia. Does that prevent extradition?
It is a serious obstacle. The Constitution allows extradition for such crimes only under a treaty and with a guarantee that a life sentence will not be imposed or enforced, and Portugal has made a matching reservation to the 1957 Convention. The court assesses how reliable the guarantees are.
Can the extradition decision be appealed?
Yes. The final decision of the Court of Appeal can be appealed to the Supreme Court within 10 days, and the appeal suspends extradition. The Constitutional Court and the ECtHR may follow.
Statutes, documents and reports
- 1Lei n.º 144/99 (International Judicial Cooperation in Criminal Matters Act), consolidated text as amended by Law 55/2026 — Arts. 6–8, 18, 31–75pgdlisboa.pt
- 2Council of the EU, doc. 9784/22 of 02.06.2022: justice ministers’ agreement of 04.03.2022consilium.europa.eu
- 3Cour de cassation (France), 11.10.2022, No. 22-80.120: Russia remains a party to the 1957 Conventioncuria.europa.eu
- 4ECtHR, Mamatkulov and Askarov v. Turkey, 04.02.2005: interim measures are bindinghudoc.echr.coe.int
- 5European Convention on Extradition 1957: parties, dates, Portugal’s reservations and Russia’s objectiontreatydatabase.overheid.nl
- 6Constitution of the Portuguese Republic, Art. 33parlamento.pt
- 7Executive Digest, 03.08.2023 (citing Jornal de Notícias): the Arkady Bunin caseexecutivedigest.sapo.pt
- 8Agence Europe, 04.03.2022: EU member states suspend criminal judicial cooperation with Russia and Belarusagenceurope.eu
- 9UN Convention against Torture: Portugal’s declarations under Arts. 21–22treaties.un.org
General legal information as of October 2026, not advice on an individual case. Translations of provisions are by INTERPOLSTOP; before any procedural step the wording is checked by a partner advocate admitted in Portugal.